This is such a venerable and ancient class of bugs, going at least as far back as AIX 3. Glad to see they're still makin' 'em like they used to.
(If you had SSH access to a host in your Tailscale ACL, you could log in as `-i` and get a root login.)
e40•1h ago
So, giving access via tailscale but using OpenSSH is safe, right?
lugoues•1h ago
Yes, this only involves their wrapper that is managed by ACL rules.
kbumsik•59m ago
Why own numbering instead of CVE?
vngzs•53m ago
It lets organizations (Tailscale) control the timing and narrative around the disclosure more directly. Organizations sometimes avoid the bureaucracy of going through CVE Numbering Authorities by self-publishing. Often a CVE assignment follows self-disclosure, especially when there's pressure to interoperate with vuln-scanning/compliance tooling
cyberax•51m ago
> "Tailscale SSH now rejects usernames with leading dashes."
Really? That's the fix?
A proper fix is to use "--" to separate arguments.
sedatk•48m ago
Their fix just future-proofs it in case the same bug gets reintroduced.
cyberax•21m ago
This is just a dirty fix. It adds weird restrictions and masks issues.
Refactoring external invocations to use safe argument handling is a better way to fix it. Along with tests that exercise weird names.
valleyer•24m ago
A proper fix is not to shell out to a command at all; use getpwnam(3) or similar.
doublepg23•43m ago
I’m a heavy Tailscale user, so I do trust them quite a bit, but I never used the Tailscale SSH feature.
I feel like OpenSSH’s security record is pretty unbeatable, not sure why I’d swap over for such a security-sensitive tool.
jdiff•33m ago
I've used it before to access my tailnet machines through a browser on a machine I can't download software on.
isatty•32m ago
Convenience for the most part but in general, I agree. I like having it as an option.
bakies•19m ago
Yeah pretty much just use tailscale as a vpn.. do one thing as they say.
dgacmu•8m ago
I used it for a bunch of remote monitor boxes to have a way of centrally managing ssh access to things that were often on- and off-line. It was simple and convenient and access was easily revocable.
modeless•35m ago
Tailscale SSH has caused me other problems in the past because it takes over port 22. I'm not a fan.
tptacek•1h ago
(If you had SSH access to a host in your Tailscale ACL, you could log in as `-i` and get a root login.)