frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Are AI "Chatbot Wrappers" ruining EdTech? I'm testing a proactive UX

2•Swadesh9422•21h ago
Hey everyone,

I’ve been doing customer discovery with CS students learning Data Structures and Algorithms. Right now, every AI tutor in the market is just a reactive chatbox (like ChatGPT next to a code editor).

The problem is, when a student is completely stuck on a logic problem (like Dynamic Programming), they don't even know what to prompt the AI. They just stare at the screen.

I am validating a new UX: A Proactive AI Mentor without a chatbox.

Instead of the user prompting the AI, the AI sits in the background and watches the code editor. It only intervenes via GitHub-style inline comments when a specific event triggers (e.g., they haven't typed in 60 seconds, or they write an O(n^2) loop when it should be O(n)).

Basically, it feels like a Senior Dev looking over your shoulder, rather than a search engine waiting to be asked.

As developers and founders, do you think this "event-driven/proactive" UX is the future for highly technical learning, or am I overcomplicating it? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Comments

a_void_sky•20h ago
I believe it is the way it is because it would cost too much otherwise. You can use the live API for continuously monitoring what the user is doing and if they are stuck but that would be expensive.
Swadesh9422•19h ago
You are right. Streaming every keystroke via a Live API would bankrupt me on day one. My current thought is to fake the 'live' feel using client-side heuristics. I'd only ping the LLM on specific events: a 60-second typing idle timeout, or intercepting the payload when they hit 'Run' and fail a test case. Do you think relying on frontend triggers like that is enough to make the UX feel proactive?

Ask HN: Programmable Watches with WiFi?

29•dakiol•3d ago•18 comments

Ask HN: Share your productive usage of OpenClaw

66•aavci•5h ago•41 comments

1Password pricing increasing up to 33% in March

115•otterley•15h ago•169 comments

New Claude Code Feature "Remote Control"

4•rob•7h ago•0 comments

Persistent Prompts and Built in Search

2•lazybusy•7h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Chromebook leads for K-8 school in need?

45•techteach00•2d ago•43 comments

AI isn't killing SaaS – it's killing single-purpose SaaS

4•JB_5000•10h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How do you know if AI agents will choose your tool?

31•dmpyatyi•1d ago•22 comments

Using "Hi Claudette " on Claude.ai

2•mlongval•12h ago•2 comments

Looking 4 open-source knowledge base and project management tool 4 personal use

3•TheAlgorist•13h ago•2 comments

ChatGPT finds an error in Terence Tao's math research

41•codexon•1d ago•8 comments

Would you choose the Microsoft stack today if starting greenfield?

17•JB_5000•1d ago•17 comments

Ask HN: How are you controlling AI agents that take real actions?

4•thesvp•1d ago•17 comments

Ask HN: Who has seen productivity increases from AI

6•Kapura•18h ago•7 comments

Ask HN: What Linux Would Be a Good Transition from Windows 11

12•Cyberis•1d ago•18 comments

Ask HN: Are AI "Chatbot Wrappers" ruining EdTech? I'm testing a proactive UX

2•Swadesh9422•21h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Any DIY open-source Alexa/Google alternatives?

6•personality0•21h ago•4 comments

Comparing manual vs. AI requirements gathering: 2 sentences vs. 127-point spec

2•thesssaism•22h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Is it better to have no Agent.md than a bad one?

5•parvardegr•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Where do you save links, notes and random useful stuff?

17•a_protsyuk•1d ago•39 comments

Does anyone use CrewAI or LangChain anymore?

9•rakan1•1d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: What is up with all the glitchy and off-topic comments?

9•marginalia_nu•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Why doesn't HN have a rec algorithm?

9•sujayk_33•3d ago•21 comments

Ask HN: What breaks when you run AI agents unsupervised?

12•marvin_nora•2d ago•8 comments

GLP-1 Second-Order Effects

22•7777777phil•1d ago•9 comments

I'm 15 and built a platform for developers to showcase WIP projects

12•amin2011•3d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Cognitive Offloading to AI

12•daringrain32781•2d ago•8 comments

So Claude's stealing our business secrets, right?

26•arm32•3d ago•18 comments

Ask HN: What Comes After Markdown?

8•YuukiJyoudai•2d ago•13 comments

Ask HN: If the "AI bubble" pops, will it really be that dramatic?

14•moomoo11•3d ago•11 comments