frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Tell HN: docker pull fails in spain due to football cloudflare block

303•littlecranky67•4h ago•128 comments

Tell HN: OpenAI silently removed Study Mode from ChatGPT

135•smokel•3h ago•43 comments

Ask HN: Do you trust AI agents with API keys / private keys?

10•devendra116•10h ago•23 comments

Ask HN: Anyone using Nostr as a lightweight back end/DB for rapid prototyping?

3•wasimsk•11h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Any interesting niche hobbies?

478•e-topy•6d ago•726 comments

Ask HN: What should I do with my app? 130 downloads 3 real subscribers

3•oyaa52•11h ago•5 comments

Is the pitch deck culture making founders worse at building businesses?

15•chinhqtran•1d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What are you building that's not AI related?

144•meander_water•3d ago•194 comments

Ask HN: Former grok-code-fast-1 users, what coding model are you using now?

2•whycombinetor•14h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Hiring in the age of AI-assisted coding: what works?

26•nitramm•1d ago•16 comments

Ask HN: Best books on building a programming language

16•ezzato•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Agentic Permutation of Testing Paths In A System

4•davidajackson•20h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do you handle marketing as a solo technical founder?

146•lazarkap•5d ago•107 comments

Tor Browser on Android leaks IP in desktop mode

13•shchess•1d ago•2 comments

Any Open Source projects in need of documentation writer?

21•tree666•2d ago•13 comments

Ask HN: Why Databases Instead of Filesystem?

12•uticus•2d ago•20 comments

Ask HN: Has anyone reconsidered Antivirus software after recent security news?

5•pants2•19h ago•3 comments

Do founders' political views affect how you see a product?

4•rishikeshs•1d ago•3 comments

I collected startup ideas. It changed how I think about ideas completely

9•vibecoder21•1d ago•11 comments

Is VC the new PMF strategy?

3•networkOne•1d ago•5 comments

Zooming UIs in 2026: Prezi, impress.js, and why I built something different

101•tinchox6•5d ago•44 comments

Ask HN: Should AI credits be refunded on mistakes?

19•ed_elliott_asc•4d ago•20 comments

Open Source card game cuttle.cards has its world championship Saturday at 1pm ET

4•aleph_one•1d ago•0 comments

Hybrid Attention

40•JohannaAlmeida•5d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Local-first meetings recorder and transcriber?

7•dandaka•3d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How do you manage your digital legacy for after you die?

15•orbanlevi•4d ago•15 comments

You've reached the end!

Open in hackernews

Tell HN: OpenAI silently removed Study Mode from ChatGPT

135•smokel•3h ago
Here's hoping that it will return soon, as I really liked it.

Comments

brumar•3h ago
After all, this "mode" was just a system prompt (last time I looked).
tomrod•3h ago
Can it be replicated by a user?
shlewis•3h ago
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/0xeb/TheBigPromptLibrary/r...

I think this is pretty much the entirety of study mode. Never used it before but as long as there's no UI changes, yes, it's 100% replicable.

ekjhgkejhgk•28m ago
How was that obtained btw?
xeromal•15m ago
Not sure about this one but Gemini's prompt was exposed by Gemini itself
asadm•10m ago
you can just ask it
beering•10m ago
People make a hobby out of tricking chat apps to leak their system prompt. But I doubt there’s much gain to be had by using this one vs coming up with a custom prompt.
box2•3h ago
There used to be a “Custom GPT” feature which basically just creates a prompt wrapper with some extra functionality like being able to call web APIs for more data. Can’t seem to find that menu right now, but it would have easily replicated the study feature. Maybe it was limited to paid accounts only.
alexthehurst•2h ago
It’s still there, but the builder is only in the web UI.
AmmarSaleh50•2h ago
Yeah custom gpts are only for paid users. However u can create a new project under "Projects", name it, then when u create it, you can see on the top right the three dots button, click it, open project settings, and there u can place your system prompt under instructions. Every chat you start in that project would send those instructions as a system prompt to the model you are chatting with. so essentially "Study Mode" could be recreated with this approach, or at least it should.
toomanyrichies•1h ago
Your comment made me ask myself: "Then why remove it? If it really is just a system prompt, I can't imagine tech debt or maintenance are among the reasons."

My best guess is this is product strategy. A markdown file doesn't require maintenance, but a feature's surface area does. Every exposed mode is another thing to document, support, A/B test, and explain to new users who stumble across it. I'm guessing that someone decided "Study Mode isn't hitting retention metrics", and decided to kill it. As an autodidact, I loved the feature, but as a software engineer I can respect the decision.

What I'm wondering about is whether there's a security angle to this as well. Assuming exposed system prompts are a jailbreak surface, if users can infer the prompt structure, would it make certain prompt injection attacks easier? I'm not well-versed in ML security, and I'd be curious to hear from someone who is.

beering•17m ago
But also, if you liked the feature, can’t you just ask chatgpt to tutor you? Does it work as well as the pre-baked Study Mode?
janpmz•3h ago
I was concerned about big players offering the same functionality when building listendock.com, but maybe there is a place for specialized apps like that.
el_io•3h ago
Haven't use 'Study Mode' in OpenAI, but can't you just ask it to act as a study coach or whatever you want it to be?
altmanaltman•3h ago
I remember videos with titles like "OPENAI CHANGED STUDYING COMPLETELY WITH THIS ONE SUPER UPDATE!" and obnoxious thumbnails on youtube when it was first launched. I guess studying changed it.
danielbln•3h ago
You have these grifter videos for everything, from OpenAI features to hot takes on the strait of Hormuz. These are best ignored entirely.
altmanaltman•3h ago
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44725764

Also discussed on HN. Yeah I can ignore them, but a lot of people watch those videos and fall for the grift (going by their views) and that's sad. It personally annoys me also when yt recommends them to me because it thinks I'm interested in software

ziml77•2h ago
I make sure to hit not interested the second I see anything I very much don't want pop up in me feed. I don't want mine to drift towards the average feed of the lowest effort, sensationalist garbage.
newswasboring•2h ago
Does this work? I've been doing that for some weeks now, nothing has changed about my home page.
sitkack•1h ago
It is more important to scrub your history and upvote.

You can use ublock to remove the sidebar completely

layer8•36m ago
In case you start watching such a video (and maybe in general), it’s probably more effective to downvote it and remove it from your watch history. And when you use “not interested”, there are two “tell us why” follow-up options “already watched” and “don’t like”. Selecting the latter may be necessary for “not interested” to have a stronger effect.

I don’t know if YouTube Premium makes a difference, but I don’t see highly clickbaity thumbnails very often.

ddtaylor•2h ago
Use DeArrow, it allows you to avoid most of that clickbait farming.
sitkack•1h ago
https://dearrow.ajay.app/
CatDeveloper_•3h ago
they do it with other stuff to i feel like they see how much users actually interact with those features and base their decsisoins kinda like how google owuld remove some features at random..
foundermodus•2h ago
What was the Study Mode? I never saw it.
exitb•1h ago
Teaching the user how to solve problems instead of solving them outright.
ok123456•2h ago
Gemini still has its study mode.
jegudiel•2h ago
I used to enjoy studying with ChatGPT too. I was on their Plus plan.
m-hodges•2h ago
I tried it a few times and always found it disappointing. It typically started off like a structured "lesson" but as I chatted with it, it would forget the syllabus is had proposed and we never "completed" the thing we set out to learn.
utopiah•2h ago
Before this Sora, and before that large government contracts. I don't think they care so much for the random consumer anymore. They use anything and everyone for PR but they get closer to IPO they are focusing what actually might make them profitable.

TL;DR: bet on stuff being removed

shivang2607•1h ago
Do people even used that ?
iugtmkbdfil834•1h ago
Anecdotally, I did not even know it was a thing. I either went to tutor me explicitly or purposefully explored a given branch with custom prompts ( + book recommendations on the subject ).
derrida•1h ago
Has ChatGPT gotten worse over past few months or is it I just have seen other things higher quality, or they stopped caring about user or something?

All of a sudden feels like it gives me boilerplate and boiler plate of PR and cheesy reasoning, and like no actual answers - worse even - highly confident wrong answers that it then seeks to justify or explain (like it doesn't seem humble enough to be like "Actually, got that wrong" or if challenged it just caves over, accepts too readilythe assumptions in what the user is asking, or just blindly accepts a premise of the question) it's almost useless, like before it used to seem like could get it to emulate the way a certain writer or discourse speaks, now it seems like this derpy highschool just wants to be in kid that went into public relations and the language no matter what the topic seems always the same, it's really spammy feeling,

I could be asking it questions about like how medieval monks talked about light and the breath in latin and it will be replying like I'm interested in monetising or improving my lifestyle or some b.s. I don't think it used to be this way?

reminds of a circa 2003-6 wordpress sites - blackhat seo - feeling to generate back links to push affiliate links or something, with markov generated content designed to push back links for the actual human written landing page

It's not like this on the other llms, something's up.

Or maybe they have just found the niche and it is a bunch of people who do think like that - like I dunno - middle management the world over

that is scary ... bonus ghastly incantations of the epistemology of middle management

omgJustTest•1h ago
people have been talking about "models of models" for arbitration opportunity in inference for about 1.5 yrs.

Arbitration idea: if a user doesn't need high QOS of newest LLM, slip them a cheaper LLM, run their query at reduced quality. measure if they cost you fewer $s in the lower QOS. => profit.

For chatgpt the arbitration opportunity looks more like "we could allocate this amount of gpu to training or inference, we are losing money if we offer the highest quality infra"

In addition there's other interesting economics scaling that can be done outside of "models of models" that are far more profitable. I won't go over all of them (and some of them I feel are quite powerful) but the laziest one is that subscription models count on some zombie users as a counterweight to highly expensive single users, and as a source of stable cashflow.

Zombie users are ones that are paying for sub but not actively or barely using the service

ssk42•1h ago
If I recall correctly, in their pivot to Codex they took a sizable amount of compute away from ChatGPT
suburban_strike•1h ago
It's gotten bad enough that I finally cancelled this month in protest. It's not just you.
MattRix•1h ago
I think you have it set to the wrong mode. If you set it to Thinking with “Extended” thinking effort, is it slower but almost never wrong (because it searches the web to get verify all its assumptions and answers).
beering•20m ago
Yeah I set thinking as my default and never looked back. It’s my daily driver and extended thinking is usually not too slow. The way that the “instant” model trades quality for speed is not worth it and I don’t need the instant gratification. (But I also don’t do entertainment chatting so ymmv.)
layer8•42m ago
Are you using the free or the paid version? Did you try personalization settings other than the default?
beering•19m ago
Set your default mode to thinking and set some custom instructions. Night and day difference in UX.
Marciplan•1h ago
in regards of sunsetting, they are better at being Google than Google is at being Google
treetalker•42m ago
FWIW, Kagi Assistant still has a Study mode / custom assistant. It works well and I use it a few times per week.