Ask HN: Why Reddit blocks all automated access but has .json for all URLs?

3•ksajadi•3h ago

Reddit is aggressively blocking all automated access (see their robots.txt) and uses a lot of heuristics to block crawlers that do not honor it.

However, at the same time all Reddit URLs can be made machine readable by adding a .json to the end.

Can anyone explain what's the point of that?

Comments

PaulHoule•3h ago

Circa 2009 or so I was interested in automated link building systems, there were some sites that had no defenses, but I saw enough going on around Reddit that I just didn't want to mess with it.

downbad_•3h ago

I just want to know why Reddit keeps banning people for no good reason,while letting bots roam free.

ksajadi•2h ago

It's turned into a bizarre place. Today I asked the same question on /r/meta and my question was immediately removed without explanation. I tried to message the mods and got bounced with a "you cannot send a message to that user"

Ask HN: Is Anthropic doing too much vibe coding?

Ask HN: What are you working on (non-AI)?

Ask HN: What are you working on? (May 2026)

Ask HN: We just had an actual UUID v4 collision...

Ask HN: Why Reddit blocks all automated access but has .json for all URLs?

agent-dash: TUI for managing Claude Code and OpenCode in tmux

Rumors of my death are slightly exaggerated

Ask HN: If HTML supersedes Markdown fr AI, Will it be versatile enough for devs?

Ask HN: Is Spam getting worse or is Gmail getting worse?

Ask HN: How to get started in electronic music

Ask HN: How are you preparing for interviews nowadays?

Ask HN: Will low quality AI customer support be the new normal?

Ask HN: Best static site generator for a docs site in 2026?

Ask HN: What happens when eventually all E2E mess. apps removed from app stores?

Our keyboards are tracking us

Ask HN: How often do you investigate issues in production vs. looking at logs?

Ask HN: How do you choose a model for a task?

Ask HN: Can a tinnitus be triggered by high frequency noises?

Remind HN: Today is Mother's Day, call your moms

Ask HN: What Wintel/AMD (Laptop) Harware are you liking?

Ask HN: Why Reddit blocks all automated access but has .json for all URLs?

Comments

Ask HN: Is Anthropic doing too much vibe coding?

Ask HN: What are you working on (non-AI)?

Ask HN: What are you working on? (May 2026)

Ask HN: We just had an actual UUID v4 collision...

Ask HN: Why Reddit blocks all automated access but has .json for all URLs?

agent-dash: TUI for managing Claude Code and OpenCode in tmux

Rumors of my death are slightly exaggerated

Ask HN: If HTML supersedes Markdown fr AI, Will it be versatile enough for devs?

Ask HN: Is Spam getting worse or is Gmail getting worse?

Ask HN: How to get started in electronic music

Ask HN: How are you preparing for interviews nowadays?

Ask HN: Will low quality AI customer support be the new normal?

Ask HN: Best static site generator for a docs site in 2026?

Ask HN: What happens when eventually all E2E mess. apps removed from app stores?

Our keyboards are tracking us

Ask HN: How often do you investigate issues in production vs. looking at logs?

Ask HN: How do you choose a model for a task?

Ask HN: Can a tinnitus be triggered by high frequency noises?

Remind HN: Today is Mother's Day, call your moms

Ask HN: What Wintel/AMD (Laptop) Harware are you liking?