frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Tell HN: PayPal blocks GrapheneOS

394•leumon•7h ago•224 comments

Amazon now hides all customer reviews on products

31•tonymet•1h ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Hugging Face is out. Who is hosting open models?

11•FireUpTheTorren•2h ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Why is AI civil tech and not military first?

6•esher•2h ago•6 comments

Solving all open source tech debt with Codex

2•surajkrajan•1h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Should I leave web development to study medicine in my mid-30s?

3•lovepuzzles•1h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: How do you guys stop coding agents from acting out of line?

2•vivekyyy•1h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How to Vibe Design as Engineer?

3•metrofun•1h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Ideas for dealing with overly-do-gooder agents

2•zof3•2h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Dear LinkedIn, do you want to do business, yes or no?

6•stefanos82•4h ago•8 comments

Tell HN: Gmail can mark legit mail from google.com as spam

5•salviati•2h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How do you feel about the new 5H usage limit in Codex?

3•embedding-shape•2h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: If I am 16 what should I learn? Which books should read?

2•AmirMakirr•3h ago•9 comments

Bast Text to Speech Tool

2•chaofan11•42m ago•0 comments

Another Webpage Screenshot and OG Image Generation API

2•foodpad•4h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Do you still do pair programming in this agentic age?

6•Andugal•9h ago•4 comments

AI Artist

2•thallukrish•3h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Why do tools like customer.io abandon self-serve after their Series A?

14•alessandroetc•21h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Where else do you spend time on the internet other than HN?

10•Gecko4072•1d ago•13 comments

Ask HN: Why are Claude models so verbose?

9•JacobWolf•1d ago•9 comments

Taalas API Anyone?

2•revanthmatha•17h ago•2 comments

Encoding Myself into the System

4•nharziro•17h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Those making $500/month on side projects in 2026 – Show and tell

73•kaladan•3d ago•96 comments

Ask HN: Good large format (>20 inches) touchscreen E-Paper display options?

30•foota•2d ago•8 comments

I keep getting flagged for AI, but I suck at writing. How can I solve this?

6•quesobob•20h ago•8 comments

Ask HN: How about delayed MIT/GPL?

5•afiori•22h ago•4 comments

Tell HN: Even HN is getting heavy traffic by AI crawlers

8•ksec•23h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: What are you using to access x.com at the moment?

6•throwaw12•1d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: How do you code review?

9•idose•1d ago•7 comments

Looking for people to follow designing systems to ship code with AI agents

8•mutahn•1d ago•1 comments
Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Why is AI civil tech and not military first?

6•esher•2h ago
A lot of civilian tech started out for military use: rockets, Teflon (kind of), nuclear power (arguably), weather forecasting. There was a recent discussion about how much the CIA invested in NeXT. Now I look at OpenAI and Anthropic. They seem to build civilian products first and only later rent them out for military purposes / national security. Why not the other way around, military technology adapted for civilian use? It seems to me there is a lot of application. Robots, drones, surveillance. What am I missing?

No conspiracies please.

Comments

embedding-shape•2h ago
> They seem to build civilian products first and only later rent them out for military purposes / national security

I guess the keyword here is "seem", we don't actually know, and it'd probably take 20+ years before anyone would know. Most people didn't know about lots of military technology until it's basically mainstream on the entire planet, so you're right now (potentially) in the moment where that stuff is happening, we just don't know about it.

functionmouse•2h ago
Military industrialist Palmer Luckey orchestrated contemporary VR with his Oculus Rift so that consumers would subsidize the costs of his miltech projects. I believe this is the same thing. Push your miltech with the "gadgets and toys and digital assistants" angle so that regular people foot the bill.
ericmay•2h ago
> Push your miltech with the "gadgets and toys and digital assistants" angle so that regular people foot the bill.

I wouldn't characterize it so uncharitably. We need this military technology and if we aren't getting the funding or efficiency we need from the government and private companies see the need (and there is a need) then this is just an example of the dynamism of our economy working well. In some other countries when such a conundrum arises they can't response - reliant only on the government to put together some big program that doesn't go anywhere and can't pay high enough salaries to attract talented people to make it work.

PaulHoule•2h ago
Look at drones. Drones are a revolution in military affairs if there ever was one but they were not brought to you by military contractors like Boeing and Lockheed-Martin but instead developed as a consumer technology by the likes of DJI.

In some sense military technology is like an ant and consumer technology is like a 100 foot high giant robot. Military technology will produce innovation in wartime but in peacetime it is a backwater.

gwbas1c•1h ago
Militaries tend to keep a lot of their technology secret, for some reasons:

- They don't want the enemy to also have the technology.

- They don't want the enemy to be able to plan against surprise weapons.

So, for example, if Ukraine developed a robot that looked like a wild animal, could conceal a bomb, and then walk across the border and explode at a target, they wouldn't want Russia to know. They would keep it super-secret and keep exploiting it until Russia figured out how to monitor the border for robotic animals.

---

This isn't a conspiracy; it's something you can learn about by studying WWII tech development. The Nazi enigma machine is a great example: The Nazis kept it secret, and the computers that the Allies built to break the codes were also kept secret.

The same thing applies to the Manhattan project: The general public knew nothing about it, knew nothing about testing the bomb, and didn't even know about Hiroshima and Nagasaki until after the war.

---

Instead, I would assume that militaries have advanced AI that we won't learn about for 5-15 years.

ThrowawayR2•1h ago
The Cold War ended with the fall of the Soviet Union and then western military R&D funding dropped drastically. Shrunken military R&D pipeline = less cool discoveries that eventually filter over to civilian applications.