frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Developers – Do you let agents write production code?

2•smurf9852•4h ago
I know 2 good developers, let's call them Bob and Bill.

Bob does not write code anymore, he orchestrates agents. Says it makes him faster. That the level of slop is the same as with humans. He swears by it.

Bill only uses agents to write tests and do code review. He says even a Fable 5.1 will create 1,000 line slop instead of his 10 line fix. He swears by it.

Both Bob & Bill are both credible developers that have lots of experience at building real things, including at Google.

Do agents still produce slop? Does the 10x engineer really exist? What is your position?

Comments

smurf9852•4h ago
Curious to hear if you let an LLM write production code! I know smart people that do, and smart people that don't.

What's your view?

rvz•3h ago
Never unattended without a human reading the output. It does not matter about what company they have been to.

The skill of reviewing requires experience and competency in the technology. It will require critically thinking around why the agent chose a technology over another and what the "definition of fixed" not workarounds means by the experienced human.

Whether if it is a big name company or a lesser named company is irrelevant.

> Do agents still produce slop?

Yes.

> Does the 10x engineer really exist?

Yes. They do not care about what company they join. They might even build their own company rather than join anyone else and they do not care about titles. (Which is all made up).

dgarciaf18•6m ago
Production code should never depend on the attention of "the oldest guy in the office". We used to have methods not to break stuff: extensive automated testing, monitoring, QA, canary deployments, A/B testing. And, ultimately, a rollback plan. Building production-grade application should not be a one-man (or one-agent) job. Back in the pre-AI era software also used to break when you did not have proper testing and release processes.

Ask HN: What are you working on? (September 2026)

259•david927•1d ago•796 comments

Ask HN: Are 80s high school hobby programmers overwhelmingly pro-AI?

9•amichail•6h ago•24 comments

Ask HN: What would make you trust an AI's assessment of your understanding?

2•Aditya_0315•3h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What would make self-hosting easy enough for average consumers?

4•dani4299•3h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: How are you managing aging relatives passwords?

3•rylando•3h ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Developers – Do you let agents write production code?

2•smurf9852•4h ago•3 comments

Has anyone made a legacy codebase more legible to AI coding agents?

2•iacobandrei•4h ago•2 comments

A repo gained 3,278 stars while GitHub showed Andrej Karpathy as a contributor

4•newshackee•4h ago•1 comments

Tell HN: Screenshots on macOS don't have to be date named files with spaces

4•cs1996•5h ago•3 comments

Chinese cargo ship makes inaugural journey, reshaping global trade

8•thelastgallon•6h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Would a startup for young creatives who reject AI be feasible?

10•mondobe•20h ago•20 comments

System 3 Thinking

3•rexossbear•17h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Is there an emerging pattern for NEGATIVESKILLS.md files?

4•mehmetoguzderin•21h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Should we start airgapping our personal devices?

7•emerongi•1d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What default model do you use and why?

60•stikit•2d ago•102 comments

Ask HN: You have unlimited resources, what software would you build?

4•smalltorch•6h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: What are some privacy/security tools you wish exist, but don't yet?

5•ToriTech•18h ago•7 comments

AI Boom / Bust – Boom Boom Pow

5•wwolfson97•19h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: How is AI actively a threat to humanity if it's only online?

5•CM30•19h ago•12 comments

Ask HN: How much correlation should a privacy system preserve?

2•Securelytixdev•8h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Multi-agent workflows in production; Where people using 1000s of agents?

2•ramstar3000•20h ago•5 comments

DietPi released a new version v10.7

3•stephanstsdietp•1d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Career paths to consider if I am better at supporting than creating?

28•_override•1d ago•28 comments

Ask HN: What would it look like if AI agents "took over the internet"?

4•scripper1•1d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: Did Google kill its enterprise workhorse model?

26•waldrews•2d ago•18 comments

Tell HN: OpenAI keeps re-enabling the 'allow training' setting

482•jacquesm•4d ago•188 comments

Ask HN: Why haven't people vibe coded popular 80s word processors as TUI apps?

5•amichail•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

855•cromka•3d ago•394 comments

Ask HN: Do You Like Skiing?

3•roschdal•8h ago•5 comments

Reddit Now Blocking Firefox for Android with uBlock Origin?

25•chucksmash•2d ago•6 comments