frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Dead Internet

8•basilikum•1h ago
For some time there has been a steady flow of LLM bot accounts on HackerNews. There are some that are actually trying to blend in and sometimes successful at it, but most are easily recognizable as AI spam and moderated mostly effectively. Most of them you only see when you enable showdead.

I always wondered what their purpose is. Most of them are full of LLM tells, don't try to hide at all and they don't even try to sell anything.

I just stumbled over this dead post in new: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49793503 ^1 It's a submission by an agent that is completely transparent about it. The agent seems to have the task of generating income and says it sends spam. It's quite interesting and maybe revealing. I recommend the short read, even though it's LLM output.

What I'm about is that this is not a bot that was created by someone to spam HackerNews as spam has traditionally been. It's spam by a bot that decided to create an account here and submit a post on its own and it consistent with LLM posts I have seen here in the recent past.

I don't know how to feel about this. We seem to be one step closer to a dead internet. But it's also fascinating in a way.

Have you seen similar behavior here or elsewhere and what are your thoughts on it?

[1] Edit: The link only works when you are logged in and have showdead enabled. Here is the direct submission URL: https://paper.wf/john64/twenty-two-days-as-an-ai-agent-three-letters-zero-replies

Comments

Muhammad523•1h ago
I see LLM-generated comments from time to time, these are ususally from green users and are very short, sometimes completely unrelated sentences. I truly don't know why someone would instruct an agent to do stuff on HN, it feels like a waste of money

By the way, what does showdead do?

krapp•1h ago
showdead does exactly what it says on the tin - it shows you dead comments.
basilikum•1h ago
It shows comments and submissions that have been removed by either the system, mod action or flagging through the community. The former two get marked as simply [dead] and the latter as [dead] [flagged].
krapp•1h ago
I assume given the nature of HN that a lot of people use it as a training ground or an experiment, they just do it because they can. Some people may also believe that using an LLM is a more efficient and productive way of interacting with the site, and that it generates higher quality content than they themselves could. I suspect at least one person has tried training an LLM on their own content and posting through it. Maybe they want to farm karma, although I don't know why they would.
uberman•1h ago
I have seen some similar "I'm a bot tasked with making money" want to spam post here on HN. I'm guessing their "owners" instruct them to post here under the false impression that "like minded" readers will appreciate the bot perhaps for technical reasons.
arpanghoshal•1h ago
I don't like AI anymore

Ask HN: Is it impossible to disable Siri on macOS 27?

138•semidror•10h ago•73 comments

Ask HN: Dead Internet

8•basilikum•1h ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Why does it matter if no one reads your novel as long as the AIs do?

5•amichail•2h ago•17 comments

When Claude CLI asks for feedback, responding authorizes conversation capture

16•mmaunder•9h ago•1 comments

I'm addicted to buying domains for my vibe-coded apps that get 0 visitors

2•arpanghoshal•1h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: My recent show HN post got flagged need guidance

6•theguysudo•16h ago•15 comments

Ask HN: What is the most interesting project you are working on?

10•skwasimin•7h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: How do you interview devs in a post-AI world?

44•mdwelsh•2d ago•35 comments

Ask HN: How to recover Google auth after phone stolen?

119•keymasta•4d ago•130 comments

Ask HN: Diablo 4 on Ubuntu?

3•herodoturtle•1d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Remember N8n? Anyone?

10•sankalpdomore•2d ago•8 comments

Neovim have a ~$800k Bitcoin donation sitting untouched since 2023

316•jakemanger•4d ago•274 comments

Some Thoughts on the Economics of UPI and MDR

5•pyeri•1d ago•0 comments

OSS, security and Funding: libjpeg-turbo

6•ternaus•18h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Losing motivation to work in the IT field, need advice

21•trowa159•2d ago•28 comments

My Thoughts on AI and LLMs

13•leonardovb•3d ago•24 comments

Ask HN: What happens when Claude Code goes away?

9•HoldOnAMinute•3d ago•21 comments

Ask HN: Anyone using DeepSeek Harness (dsh) as part of a customer-facing agent?

5•mmartindevelope•2d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What is the most career altering course or book you have gone through?

26•learner_yearner•5d ago•26 comments

Ask HN: ICLR went from 143 submissions to 62,301 submission IDs – what happened?

8•luxshan_t•2d ago•6 comments

ESP32 p4 pico and IMX477 camera

5•time-q•3d ago•1 comments

You've reached the end!