frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: What do you believe or not believe about AI?

4•maniac_2000•4h ago
There is quite opposing discourse on the internet as to whether AI is going to take everyone's job, or if we are witnessing one of the greatest pre-IPO PR jobs in history. Or both.

I'm wondering what people smarter than me believe or don't believe.

Comments

spottedmarley•3h ago
I believe in a few years we'll have moved on to some other amazing new technology and LLMs will just be another tool in that stack. Datacenters will become relatively obsolete and most of them will hopefully become indoor MTB and/or skate parks, maybe indoor e-moto tracks.
drltaidev•3h ago
In a way I wish this would become true, and to some extent I believe it will (excitement will go down, and some part of the bubble will burst). But I can't fully see it happening this way, these tools are just so disruptive in so many different areas... perhaps not all, but it can speed up the development of almost anything so I don't see it disappearing. I hope it'll help improving its own efficiency as well so we can still get rid of some of the datacenters (or at least stop building more of them), but I don't see it going away as "just another tool", it really sits on top of other tools I think.
spottedmarley•43m ago
If the goal is genuine artificial intelligence (or artificial cognition), and I think it is, then an LLM can only ever be a piece of that puzzle, they represent the language center of the AI brain. True cognitive intelligence will require a completely new and novel technology that doesn't yet exist and it will itself rely on a language model for all its powerful reasoning tools. Reasoning is only part of cognition, the role of an LLM in the AI puzzle.
drltaidev•3h ago
What makes this hard to predict is that it's a question about human behaviour as much as about technology... if we do it well, I don't think AI should take everyone's job but it should certainly make our jobs more fun and give us more free time. But when did humanity really do things well...

On the other hand, jobs are about money in the end, who spends money? Humans, not AI (I mean, AI does but still ultimately because humans wanted it to). Products & services sell because humans want or value them. Since the technology/building side becomes so cheap (especially in software), who will actually earn money is determined by who can produce stuff/services that humans actually want to pay for (not what they actually need, but what they think they need/want). I'd say that should keep a large human component in decision making, at least on a strategic level. On a tactical and detailed implementation level, yeah AI is gonna be doing most of the work.

chistev•2h ago
Humans are bad at predictions.

Ask HN: A New Decade. Any Predictions? (2010)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21936234

Ask HN: A New Decade. Any Predictions?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21941278

Ask HN: What are your predictions for 2023?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34125628

tompark•1h ago
A belief: Just as human exceptionalism misled us to believe in a geocentric universe, we'll discover we've been wrong about consciousness too. That is, non-human animals have degrees of consciousness, and we'll see that it's possible for machines too.

A correlated belief: AGI is coming, eventually, AI technology will get there before climate change and economic pressures stop it from happening.

An obvious observation: Large scale upheaval doesn't affect everyone to the same degree or even in the same direction. Some people and companies actually prospered during the Great Depression. People died and suffered during wars and plagues, while others gained advantage and opportunity -- often due to circumstances and chance, but sometimes beliefs/decisions/actions/preparation made a difference.

An example of my bias: during Covid, people told me that remote work was the new normal and moved away. I said in 5 years we'll all be back in the office. I was wrong, but so were they.

Cheese48923846•1h ago
My best guess is it will be similar to tractors and farming.

1 guy on a tractor does the work of a whole team of animals and men. But I don't think any commercial farm has ever gone down to 0 men, and I don't think they ever will. Too many things need real eyes on the ground to make decisions and adjust.

Outside context gained through sensory input (eyes, ears) may be hard to fully replace. You'd need a human to at least give the AI that extra context. Help it work inside the bubble it's contained to.

Destructive things like warfare, I think AI will do great. But even if massive armies of land/air/sea robots controlled through starlink satellites become the norm, there will almost certainly still be human soldiers around. Context, working in civilian populated zones where judgement is needed, etc.

Tell HN: I'm going on strike this November

37•curiousaboutml•2h ago•28 comments

Ask HN: What do you believe or not believe about AI?

4•maniac_2000•4h ago•7 comments

Expericencing an issue in Gmail where emails do not delete in Firefox

7•rc_kas•1d ago•3 comments

Slow Cloudflare Connections

3•bryonyoni•21h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: T'was the night of Claude Reset and quota left: Funniest app you built?

9•julianpye•21h ago•4 comments

DietPi v10.8 has been released

17•stephanstsdietp•23h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Do you still read clean code and software architecture books?

16•pelcg•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Is it not possible to enroll for Apple Developer anymore?

32•olalonde•2d ago•17 comments

Ask HN: Can we do something about this impending AI dystopia

6•justforfunhere•1d ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Why Is Anthropic's Customer Support Bad?

4•tj-teej•1d ago•5 comments

Median product "lifespan" has fallen from ~4y down to ~1.5y

88•stanislavb•5d ago•34 comments

What to do if you discover AI models trained using your copywrighted book?

13•andrea81•1d ago•8 comments

Necro-Economics Eyal Weizman

4•abdelhousni•18h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What are your career plans in the age of AI?

12•akudha•1d ago•18 comments

Ask HN: How do you grow OSS projects?

5•tarasyarema•2d ago•15 comments

Is AI just another get rich quick scheme?

18•jqpabc123•4d ago•27 comments

Ask HN: Will There Be Another iPhone Mini?

3•rishikeshs•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Are tab completion models dead?

22•sandruso•3d ago•17 comments

Tell HN: Steamcmd doesn't work on Apple Silicon

6•stdc105•5d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: How fast is your CI these days?

8•easterncalculus•2d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Mined crypto on Azure when I was 13, after 12y still cannot open account

7•realaccfromPL•2d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Kimi Code hit its 5-hour limit after $1.37 of API usage

8•waximabbax•3d ago•3 comments

I'm creating my own OS, check it out, LimonOs no Unix no Linux

5•Drfoxi•2d ago•4 comments

Took apart Claude Code, then turned it into a free course on harness engineering

10•pauliusztin•4d ago•0 comments

You've reached the end!