frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Why Agile Often Fails

3•ghassenfaidi•1d ago
To be honest, I've always looked down on Agile and such methodologies, it's so hard to be fair when you've been bombarded with buzzwords for a long time. Even terms like "iterative" or "incremental" feel like buzzwords to me - even though they are very useful ideas. It felt like boring management stuff. But it turned out Agile is pretty good, but how people implement can differ, and it can go wrong.

Same goes for teaching best practices, some teachers like to follow rubrics: "top 10 things to do as a teacher". But often it fails and it turns students off because the teacher isn't focusing on the values behind the practices, they just implement them mindlessly. For example you see many teachers starting a lecture (in classroom or online course) by stating the objectives of the lecture. The problem is that they treat it as an item on their checklist and it often ends up being boring and soulless and you just feel like skipping it.

In my country we have an old wisdom that is loosely translated as: "judging a thing is a reflection of one's perception of it."

And how we perceive something can affect how motivated we are. For example, two people can perceive studying differently, and hence it can change how much they do it. It's part of being a human. Ideas can have a huge impact on our emotions and actions. The problem with many meetings is that not everyone in the team sees the value in them. Devs for instance often find meetings annoying and take a lot of time that could have been used for "real work" and build software. They perceive meetings as a chore, they think of it as a tool for the PM, management stuff - the PM wants to see if things are going well and if it's according to the plan. so the devs will probably speak as little as possible and just get it done to go back to "real work". - which sadly reduces the meeting's value. They think of it as a status sync. And that's how most stand up meetings are honestly. No wonder many people hate them.

But it doesn't have to be that way, if you can show your team that it can actually be useful for them, by actually designing useful meetings: if the meeting becomes a planning tool for everyone, a meeting that makes sure everyone is taking good decisions (and not just following the plan), not just a mere status sync. Devs might suddenly find it useful. If the devs start to think of it as a way to understand how the project is going and coming up with ways that make everyone work better. Suddenly it becomes important to them.

Yet changing someone's mindset about something is not easy or a simple process. And it's not just about throwing buzzwords or -ities. In fact even a term like "mindset" and "motivation" can be a turnoff to many people - including me. Human beings are complex, it's not a simple equation, thoughts affect emotions and behaviors, and behaviors will affect the thoughts again. And it's not as simple as changing how you perceive something, if something is truly useless no matter how one tries to think of it positively it would shatter when it faces the real world.

One final important idea is that we often try to seek perfection. As if we need to be passionate about everything! People don't need to love everything they do. It's okay if the meeting is a bit boring, it can have some value to the PM nevertheless. But we can do better.

Comments

dieselgate•2h ago
Agile is a bad methodology but it’s usually better than all the others. It’s actually a good way to manage a team from the Management side but is annoying to be on the dev side. I’ve been on both sides.
andyjohnson0•1h ago
You seem to be relatively new to HN. This isn't a place for hosting your blog posts. Instead why not put this on an external site, expand on it a bit, and submit a link? Thats how HN works.

ChatGPT Desktop forwards your SSH agent to remote machines

186•DenGorbachev•10h ago•60 comments

Ask HN: What are you working on? (November 2026)

273•david927•21h ago•935 comments

Ask HN: Do you still enjoy coding in C++?

45•hasley•8h ago•58 comments

Ask HN: How do you evaluate the skills your AI agents use?

14•enesalatas•4h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How do you manage your AI agents' context across clients and projects?

74•Michel_Aventin•2d ago•50 comments

uBlock Origin Can't Block Facebook Ads

5•anidsiam•2h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How did you convince family and friends to join your XMPP/Matrix server?

99•mtlynch•2d ago•93 comments

Ask HN: How your SEO traffic doing? Up or down?

3•bigmuzzy•8h ago•0 comments

Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscribers (personal accounts)

734•jameslk•5d ago•201 comments

Ask HN: What's your current AI agentic setup?

568•eggbrain•5d ago•699 comments

Ask HN: Will Humans Become Useless?

3•misano•10h ago•10 comments

Tell HN: A flood of reports of Opus 5.5 being nerfed

20•b--l•18h ago•13 comments

Ask HN: What in the world is taking Ubuntu so long?

218•linsomniac•3d ago•142 comments

Those who have lost their job to AI what was your job?

2•dev_grex•12h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Is it normal to not write code for a years as software engineer?

4•khalidahmad•16h ago•9 comments

I am building Threadz. Human first AI writing app

3•shoebilyas_hanz•18h ago•1 comments

Why Agile Often Fails

3•ghassenfaidi•1d ago•2 comments

Claude usage credits purchased after Dec 7 will expire 12 months after purchase

17•bbg2401•2d ago•10 comments

Ask HN: What are your advice for a CS/IT student for the future?

5•L0in•1d ago•19 comments

I turned an ESP32-S3 into a Tailscale gateway with recovery functions

8•Mattboxx•2d ago•3 comments

We're bringing back the HN meeting in Mexico City

10•ysangkok•1d ago•0 comments

HN's HTML has changed slightly

4•1vuio0pswjnm7•23h ago•3 comments

Seeking advice: Wix stolen my .com domain

13•wixcom•3d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: If LLM reverse engineering is deemed illegal, is that precedent for OSS?

4•apatheticonion•1d ago•10 comments

Is YouTube starting to protect channel RSS feeds?

6•kradeelav•1d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: What tech companies do you think have a good moral compass?

6•gehwartzen•2d ago•16 comments

Ask HN: What fun things to do with an iPhone 11?

9•wanderingpixel•3d ago•8 comments

Tell HN: Be Careful with Stripe Connect

18•breue•2d ago•5 comments

Slickdeals.net Is Compromised

22•intenex•2d ago•2 comments

You've reached the end!