frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Are startups today worth it even in a best case scenario?

4•enigmous_hippo•3h ago
I'm gonna open this with the disclaimer that this is purely a financial and risk comparison post. No one is complaining that we are poorly compensated. It is good to discuss compensation so we can make informed and educated decisions when deciding how to commit the next few years of our lives.

A close friend of mine joined an AI startup (being intentionally vague) around 1.5 years ago and despite the company doing extremely well on valuation, I'm surprised at how he's not really better off than just working at a large tech company.

Concrete numbers for the startup: -200k salary -Equity grant over 4 years is 500k -The company's valuation has since went from single billions to tens of billions, leaving him with a 10x multiplier when looking only at valuation. After you account for dilution, it's closer to 6x. -Liquidity event annually allows you to sell 10% of your vested shares

Big tech at a similar years of experience is around 400-500k total comp, and the RSU component is generally liquid.

For example sake and ease of calculation, if you assume that my friend's entire equity was vested, and he was able to sell 10% of it, it would amount to approximately $300k/liquidity event, which brings him to around 500k a year as well (200k + 300k). In reality, he's really only able to access $300k/4 since that's all he has vested and that brings him closer to $75k for this liquidity event. There are a lot of variables I'm leaving out obviously such as potential future value, IPO, etc., but the thing that is surprising to me overall is that this is a close to best case outcome, yet the employee doesn't really end up any better off than big tech due to lack of liquidity and dilution. I mean I get it, impact, interesting work, etc. -- the qualitative measures -- aren't really accounted for, but I'm not looking to make a wholistic comparison.

This brings me to the question: Is the risk in a startup ever justified for a lower level employee (engineer, Product Manager, Program Manager, etc.)?

Comments

fullshark•2h ago
Unless you are early in your career and the startup gives you on the job learning experience with amazing future benefits (sort of like a paid internship), the traditional answer is you should value start up equity at $0 and financially you will come out behind.
toomuchtodo•2h ago
It is a lottery ticket and learning opportunity to then lever up into being a founder or a properly compensated role at a profitable company. If you’re there for another reason (besides enjoying the startup grind “for the love of the game”), you’re doing it wrong.

Not financial advice, but don’t take liquidity events for granted. Could it be worth more in the future? Maybe. Could also go to zero. Liquidate according to your risk tolerance when liquidity windows open.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50182326

Ask HN: Tips for transitioning from web development to embedded/firmware?

94•llmblockchain•3d ago•65 comments

Ask HN: I have been unemployed for 2y. 15 years of experience, US. What to do?

718•LetThingsBeDiff•1d ago•819 comments

Ask HN: Are startups today worth it even in a best case scenario?

4•enigmous_hippo•3h ago•2 comments

I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA

132•proberts•2d ago•176 comments

Ask HN: Is Anthropic being public better or worse for your org?

7•ares623•15h ago•8 comments

Will Solving a legendary math problem with AI be a candidate for a Fields Medal?

6•DivingForGold•4h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Where the company's employees launch the tools that Claude created

3•vmuhammadsaid20•11h ago•2 comments

Tell HN: OpenRouter prompts to Minimax may have been read

62•dannyw•1d ago•11 comments

Does anybody read their emails anymore?

7•ky0ung•1d ago•19 comments

Ask HN: Are the trades a safe career transition?

35•Rd6n6•6h ago•65 comments

Ask HN: Any actual balanced reviews of GTA 6?

12•tetris11•2d ago•22 comments

GitLab 19.6.0 is out and still vulnerable to Ruby2Shell and NGINX2Root

29•hoechst•3d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: What's stopping us from putting agents in general purpose robots?

12•ex-aws-dude•2d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Should Uber Ratings Decay over Time?

12•AB3TZ•1d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Where do you see Software in 5 years?

24•Odbyteusz•3d ago•35 comments

Ask HN: Why no AI-led memory vulns in Python?

11•uticus•3d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Rust, Zig, or C?

10•selectedambient•1d ago•25 comments

Ask HN: When does your app need its own UI vs. using it via MCP?

13•amoorthy•3d ago•12 comments

The End of Continuous Rework

5•alexhr•3d ago•2 comments

Interesting Learnings Working for a Startup

21•Jessiejia11•4d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Do you feel developers are more "grumpy" these days?

7•ksajadi•1d ago•12 comments

Open-Source FPGA The "startup idea" to "go big fast"

2•daly•21h ago•13 comments

Second Brain and Agent Maintenance Thoughts on AI Usage?

5•harrisonsmith10•2d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Cheapest CPU Vms

14•mrkn1•3d ago•10 comments

Anthropic should give stock to Stack Overflow (and OpenAI too)

13•thetjmccarty•3d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What is your current hardware set up?

5•dfdydx•1d ago•7 comments

Claude Gets Hella Paranoid

19•noduerme•4d ago•14 comments

Ask HN: Did books that went viral on HN publish their manuscript?

4•illidan1000•2d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: How do you manage the curse of rabbit hole?

12•BOOSTERHIDROGEN•3d ago•7 comments

You've reached the end!