Ask HN: Help with doing statistics over machine code

2•phafu•1y ago

I'd like to do some statistics over the machine code gcc generates, such as a histogram of used instructions, average volatile/preserved registers usage of functions etc. For now just x86_64 SysV-ABI would be enough.

However I'm not aware of any pre-existing tool that lets me easily do this. The options I currently see are either make gcc output assembly and write a parser for the GNU Assembler format (possibly by reusing the asm-parser of the compiler-explorer project), or write a tool that reads (disassembles) object files directly using elfutils.

Any hints, prior work, further ideas, links to useful resources, or any other kind of help would be much appreciated.

Comments

baobun•1y ago

"Static analysis" should be a relevant search term. Assuming you don't need to tie the instructions back to C code then the "gcc" part seems circumstancial for implementation? I guess you might want to parse the ASM into an Abstract Syntax Tree (AST) represenation and work on that?

If you do want to tie it back to the source, this looks relevant: http://icps.u-strasbg.fr/~pop/gcc-ast.html

phafu•1y ago

For my purpose I don't need to get back to the original source, no.

The gcc part is only relevant with regards to what dialect of assembler I need to parse. If I go that route, I'd write a parser for the GNU assembler, and that would of course work with any code in that dialect, regardless from which compiler it came from (I haven't checked whether other compilers can produce GNU assembler though).

There Is No 'Hard Problem of Consciousness'

Building a multi-agent system from scratch: 50 lines of bash and Git

Multiple commencement speakers booed for AI comments during graduation speeches [video]

Turn inbound call recordings into structured JSON

What A.I. Did to My College Class

Ben Affleck Banned from Hard Rock Casino When Caught Counting Cards (2014)

LLM Performance by Programming Language

First-Ever Tokenized Space Tourism: AI and Space and Blockchain

Archivists Turn to LLMs to Decipher Handwriting at Scale

Dot-Coms That Deliver (2001)

The American epoch of oil is collapsing. What comes next could be ugly

AI Leak Watch: 435,608 potential AI API key matches in public GitHub code

The automation of jobs will never end

Why Panama Is the Ideal Destination for Real Estate Investment

Spirit Airlines Passenger Brings 'Emotional Support' Rotisserie Chicken Thru TSA

Possible atmosphere detected on small trans-Neptunian object

Slop Bucket Idea – a dataset of AI slop (train AI what not to do)

Hubris of Timing: Why being right abt the future isnt enough to capitalize on it

How fast is N tokens per second really?

Students deserve better than COLLEGE

Show HN: Dashbuster – Replace em dashes on any website

I went inside OpenAI's secretive San Francisco headquarters

Most Americans don't trust AI – or the people in charge of it

Apple announced the iPhone 17e with a chip developed in Israel

Show HN: How to Kill the Dead Internet

Microsoft will let you remap the Copilot key to restore right ctrl functionality

Tracking Skyscraper-Size Asteroids, Failed Supernovas and Interstellar Visits

I built a local layer that kills Token Tax–Python lib+Chrome extension+Mac app

Terms of (Ab)Use: An Analysis of GenAI Services [pdf]

ArXiv will ban authors for a year if they let AI do all the work