Ask HN: Help with doing statistics over machine code

2•phafu•1y ago

I'd like to do some statistics over the machine code gcc generates, such as a histogram of used instructions, average volatile/preserved registers usage of functions etc. For now just x86_64 SysV-ABI would be enough.

However I'm not aware of any pre-existing tool that lets me easily do this. The options I currently see are either make gcc output assembly and write a parser for the GNU Assembler format (possibly by reusing the asm-parser of the compiler-explorer project), or write a tool that reads (disassembles) object files directly using elfutils.

Any hints, prior work, further ideas, links to useful resources, or any other kind of help would be much appreciated.

Comments

baobun•1y ago

"Static analysis" should be a relevant search term. Assuming you don't need to tie the instructions back to C code then the "gcc" part seems circumstancial for implementation? I guess you might want to parse the ASM into an Abstract Syntax Tree (AST) represenation and work on that?

If you do want to tie it back to the source, this looks relevant: http://icps.u-strasbg.fr/~pop/gcc-ast.html

phafu•1y ago

For my purpose I don't need to get back to the original source, no.

The gcc part is only relevant with regards to what dialect of assembler I need to parse. If I go that route, I'd write a parser for the GNU assembler, and that would of course work with any code in that dialect, regardless from which compiler it came from (I haven't checked whether other compilers can produce GNU assembler though).

Still on Its Way to Cleveland

Kotlin keeps up with Rust in DHH's Campfire rewrite

Building a Better NAS for My Homelab

SNTPings by Studenten Net Twente

New Version of OnemanBSD Includes WebKitGtk

Before Computer Science Became a Boys' Club, Margaret Hamilton Wrote the Code

Scientists discover 180k giant tortoises on one Seychelles island

The Next Chapter of USV

Tomek Korbak: OpenAI's head of safety told they no longer trust me

'Breathtaking,' 'Devastating': Mathematics Reels After New OpenAI Release

Show HN: Higherlevel – Define and review what AI agents build

Why Android apps can't talk to your camera when you're connected to a VPN

Folio – A free, open-source Markdown reader and editor for Windows and Linux

Kairos Experiment – How I disproved my own AI memory framework

Spring Boot JPA vs. JDBC: How Much Can a Small App Save?

Can AI Agents Make Open-Ended Scientific Discovery? Evidence from Station

How people use social media may matter more than screen time for mental health

The Failed Fight to Unionize One of Gaming's Most Idealized Studios

Applying NASA's satellite-imaging trick to ancient museum objects

SupaQuery – Analytics that identify B2B website visitors

That's how it's supposed to feel

Tesla Rebrands Full Self-Driving as Tesla Assisted Driving in Europe

Underdog Saluki: Qwen3.8-27B in under 8GB with tool calling intact

Trace a Token Through TP/CP/SP/EP/DP/PP in Moe Inference

Hiring US-to-China Oil Tanker Costs More Than Launching a Space Rocket

Show HN: CPU First Decision Model

Infinite Ascent – Our approach to open research and intelligence

Show HN: Widefleet – Open-source platform for agent-built apps and workflows

Hi Fellow Furries

Swarmfile: A streaming version-control system