frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

The origins of the school system aimed to produce independent, critical thinkers

https://www.cbc.ca/radio/ideas/humboldt-education-system-bildung-1.7172093
26•pseudolus•1h ago

Comments

synecdoche•1h ago
I've heard the opposite. That is was designed and based on military organisation and for individuals to conform to the contemporary world view.
mdp2021•1h ago
Well, where. Of course the Philosopher and the Dictator will have different positions on the matter. The thing is that (1) there is a dialectic between the two perspectives and that (2) in actual historical instances different parties will have had more space for action.
steephax•1h ago
Yes, there's a nice explanation of its origins in Moonwalking with Einstein.
logicchains•1h ago
The article addresses this:

"Yet over the years, as Humboldt's public education system was adopted, modified and spread around the world, Bildung — the cultivation of our human potential — may well have been the critical piece left out.

Soon, the state's influence on education took hold, with its own agenda. This is explored in part two of the documentary, Humboldt's Ghost."

speak_plainly•59m ago
This is true. While Humboldt designed the overarching structure of the school, Johann Gottlieb Fichte argued that Prussia lost to Napoleon because they were too individualistic and was able to influence ideas of early education in those schools. The aim, through Fichte, became a system designed to break parental bonds, who he believed filled kids heads with selfish, private interests, and in turn, the goal of education was to develop children into workers and soldiers. Fichte famously suggested that a proper education should destroy a student's free will so thoroughly that they could never choose to do anything other than what the state required.
loloquwowndueo•19m ago
Got any references for this? It’s pretty interesting, would like to know more.
EffectFeisty627•16m ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Taylor_Gatto Gatto asserts the following regarding what school does to children in Dumbing Us Down:

    It confuses the students. It presents an incoherent ensemble of information that the child needs to memorize to stay in school. Apart from the tests and trials, this programming is similar to the television; it fills almost all the "free" time of children. One sees and hears something, only to forget it again.
    It teaches them to accept their class affiliation.
    It makes them indifferent.
    It makes them emotionally dependent.
    It makes them intellectually dependent.
    It teaches them a kind of self-confidence that requires constant confirmation by experts (provisional self-esteem).
    It makes it clear to them that they cannot hide, because they are always supervised.[
steve1977•52m ago
Part of the problem might be that the terms are not used in the same way in the Anglosphere and in Germany.

In Germany, the Prussian Reforms refer to what is described in the article and attributed to Wilhelm von Humboldt, this was in the late 18th century.

What you are probably referring to is the Generallandschulreglement by Johan Johann Julius Hecker under Frederick the Great. This was published in 1763, around 40 years before von Humboldt.

netcan•17m ago
According to Ai... Humbolt's system was reformed after he left office. The "Prussian School System" was the result... the system copied by the US and others. This is the industrial era school system, famous for producing reliable factory workers, soldiers and citizens.
lmf4lol•38m ago
I was just reading Schillers letters on the Aesthetic Education of Man. It made me sad that we have such profound insight available on beauty and a fulfilling life, and still produce a school system that is completely contrary to a proper human existence.

I also vividly recall pg’s reflections on the school system in Hackers and Founders. He was spot on with his observations and still is. My own experience made so much more sense. He wrote that a decade ago it hink. Still, Nothing changed!

I have two daughters. One just finished primary school and the second is halfway through primary. Its a disaster. They dont learn proper reading and math, they dony learn creativity. Its just a big waste of time sending them there to be honest. Heck, they watch 1 hour of stupid TV shows there everyday.. why??? My wife home schools them additionally, so that they learn proper reading, math, history & art. Its sad that this is necessary. My daughters excel now all tests obviously but its frightening to see how low the average skill level of their peers is. there are 12 year olds who cant read a paragraph or do simple maths in their head. They dont know anything about the history of the country.. Its terrifying that this is the future generation. They need to carry the torch after all.

And its not the kids fault. WE as a society failed them!!!!

ps i am from Amsterdam, NL btw

pacbard•1m ago
My first reaction is that it depends on who you read.

The linked article talks about Wilhelm von Humboldt's philosophy of education. While I haven't read much into 19th-century German literature, the article seems to suggest that a national education system is foundational in nation building and, possibly on-brand romanticism, that the final goal of education is to produce "independent, critical thinkers".

The same ideals have driven the initial push for public schooling in the United States (which happened at the same time at least in the big East Coast cities). However, with the expansion west, schooling became more of an assimilation instrument, where the preparation of "informed citizens" became more of the goal. This led to public school clashes with established religious schools (mostly Catholic in Chicago and in California), which then resulted in a full separation between public and religious school funding.

The goal of education seemed to have changed with the beginning of the 20th century and the push for universal high school. Powell, Farrar, & Cohen argue in "Shopping Mall High School"[^1] that universal secondary education forced schools to become more “consumer-oriented" by offering classes and activities (i.e., sports) that would keep students in school until 18, while compromising with their original ideals to prepare citizens or critical thinkers.

[^1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shopping_mall_high_school

AI coding token costs are on track to rival human payroll

https://www.cio.com/article/4189149/ai-coding-token-costs-are-on-track-to-rival-human-payroll.html
1•eustoria•37s ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Advice to make an Anime AI special

1•anitroves•1m ago•0 comments

Panopticon for all, can AI automate privacy?

https://blog.1001ud.me/ideas/thoughts/the-panopticon-for-all
1•lekan_digital•2m ago•1 comments

Hengefinder

https://hengefinder.com/
1•bookofjoe•3m ago•0 comments

Solo bio hacker creates potential drug for Alzheimer’s

https://xcancel.com/DouglasYaoDY/status/2070904914050797582
1•jv22222•3m ago•0 comments

Employer of Record

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employer_of_Record
1•JumpinJack_Cash•4m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Is there a bad employers (who have a records of not paying) list?

2•trowa159•5m ago•0 comments

Deriving SVD without even aiming at it

https://stillthinking.net/posts/connections-in-math-svd/
1•pcael•6m ago•0 comments

Alan Mathison Turing – IT History Society

https://ithistory.org/honoree/alan-mathison-turing
1•rbanffy•6m ago•0 comments

If you thought the global financial crisis was bad

https://www.economist.com/by-invitation/2026/06/28/if-you-thought-the-global-financial-crisis-was...
1•andsoitis•6m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Making a label printer work under Linux using agentic AI

https://stefan.schueller.net/posts/making-a-label-printer-work-under-linux-using-agentic-ai/
1•sschueller•7m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Would someone in Japan try out my game?

1•bahrtw•11m ago•0 comments

Newer Claude models use more tokens but cost less per task solved

https://signoz.io/blog/claude-code-model-comparison/
1•gkarthi2800•11m ago•0 comments

Scientists Think They've Uncovered the 15M-Year-Old Origin of Laughter

https://www.404media.co/scientists-think-theyve-uncovered-the-15-million-year-old-origin-of-laugh...
4•Brajeshwar•14m ago•0 comments

How People in China Keep Outsmarting Anthropic's Geolocation Restrictions

https://www.wired.com/story/how-people-in-china-keep-outsmarting-anthropics-geolocation-restricti...
3•thm•14m ago•0 comments

Another ICE threat visit: How did agents track down this critic on his vacation?

https://www.syracuse.com/news/2026/06/another-ice-threat-visit-how-did-agents-track-down-this-cri...
4•SubiculumCode•17m ago•0 comments

Built a micro-temporal transaction velocity baseline filter (Python)

https://github.com/damariushayes/time-series-velocity-baseline
3•Zie_Mordecai•18m ago•0 comments

ASCII Art Data Visualization in the Terminal like it's still 1970

https://github.com/medialab/xan/blob/master/docs/cookbook/dataviz.md
3•gazoduke•18m ago•1 comments

Why has the web become so complex?

https://parksb.github.io/en/article/43.html
2•parksb•20m ago•0 comments

Show HN: WifiMapLinux – Residential Wi-Fi Mapping Tool for Linux

https://github.com/thongor77/WifiMapLinux
3•magetriste•20m ago•0 comments

EU Open Sources Ten-Year Network Development Planning Tools

https://github.com/open-energy-transition/open-tyndp
9•lyoncy•21m ago•0 comments

The greyforce isn't retiring and it's not about the money

https://nationalpost.com/longreads/unretirement-seniors-not-retiring
3•mooreds•21m ago•0 comments

The Regrettable Resilience of 'Resilience'

https://grberridge.diplomacy.edu/the-regrettable-resilience-of-resilience/
2•jruohonen•24m ago•0 comments

Restaurant Matchbooks Are Having a Comeback Thanks to Gen Z

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2026-06-18/restaurant-matchbooks-are-having-a-comeback-th...
3•mooreds•26m ago•0 comments

Microsoft's Satya Nadella says every company should build its own AI model

https://www.businessinsider.com/satya-nadella-said-every-company-should-build-own-ai-model-2026-6
2•croes•26m ago•0 comments

Food defined social hierarchy in 1776. Here's what was on the table

https://text.npr.org/nx-s1-5843114
2•mooreds•27m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What is everyone in SF talking about?

12•morgangiraud•28m ago•6 comments

Still blazing after all these years: Mel Brooks at 100

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2026/jun/28/mel-brooks-at-100
3•ciconia•32m ago•0 comments

LocalContextRouter – stop paying vision-token prices for text PDF pages

https://github.com/sid732/LocalContextRouter
3•sid732•33m ago•0 comments

Show HN: QuicMic – Use your phone as a PC mic in the browser (Rust, QUIC)

https://github.com/Fix3dll/QuicMic
2•fix3dll•37m ago•0 comments