frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Fixrleak: Fixing Java Resource Leaks with GenAI

https://www.uber.com/en-IL/blog/fixrleak-fixing-java-resource-leaks-with-genai/
22•benocodes•2mo ago

Comments

leosanchez•2mo ago
C# has Roslyn analyzers for this. Doesn't java have something similar ? Is AI appropriate technology for static analysis ?
jillesvangurp•2mo ago
There were static code analyzers like findbugs able to do stuff like this 20 years ago. These days, your IDE should tell you off as well. And hopefully teams configure their builds to catch stuff like this using any of the available plugins for this.

LLMs seems overkill for this. But of course letting it do general code reviews is not a bad idea. And static code analyzers aren't perfect. Doing this at scale might be a bit tricky though; you'd have to go file by file. I assume Uber might have many millions of lines of code to screen. And maybe their developers aren't that concerned with addressing warnings.

But going file by file might be simple enough. And you can probably screen for important stuff with some decent system prompt and instruct it to check for potential resource leaks and similar issues and produce detailed bug reports with some priority if it finds them and a diff that addresses the issue. Could be a nice use case for agentic AIs to screen code like this.

TYMorningCoffee•2mo ago
These existing tools (spotbugs, findings, sonarqube, null away, checker framework, pmd, etc) provide detection but not resolution. Resolution thru LLM is what Uber proposes.
nradov•2mo ago
Resolution of the kind of resource leaks that SonarQube finds is usually the work of a few seconds. And it should be integrated into the developer workflow in such a way that those bugs are found and fixed before the code even gets checked in. In other words, if that code is even making it into a repo where GenAI can find and fix it then you have deeper engineering process problems. Fix the root cause rather than patching around them with more tools.

And once SonarQube flags a resource leak to a developer, a competent developer would learn from that and never make the same mistake again.

TYMorningCoffee•2mo ago
It's not identifying the leaks. In their architecture they use Sonar qube for the detecting. The LLM provides the fix.
kmarc•2mo ago
I'm working in the developer productivity space.

I think you'd be surprised, how many people do production code WITHOUT automated formatting / linting / static analysis.

Now these people and their managers are staring at the shiny new thing, the LLMs. They missing googling skills are fixed by LLMs ont heir everyday life, so they think a magic "code quality tool" (AI) would help them in they work.

To answer your question, obviously there are many linters/analyzers for Java (and for other languages too), both for static and dynamic code analysis, formatters, everything.

nitinreddy88•2mo ago
Is this open sourced? It would be super useful if we can run against open source community projects to see the accuracy
TYMorningCoffee•2mo ago
This architecture is promising. Large legacy code bases can have static analysis violations in the 1000s which devs never have the time to address. I've seen sonar tube reports that require man years to resolve everything.
time4tea•2mo ago
This could be interesting, but all the example code is so poor, and the extent of the fix so limited that it feels like this is 'AI' for the sake of it.

Stringly-typed, catch-log-ignore, generates warnings in IDE anyway...

Fixed 90 of 125 errors that were found by a different technology... probably.could have been fixed by one developer in 1-2 days anyway - how long did this take?

daxfohl•2mo ago
Mostly agree with these points, but it does say that it automates some of the fixes in complex cases that the non-AI tool couldn't handle.

Besides, gotta start somewhere. It's probably a PoC, for a platform that will eventually handle all sorts of things.

johnbender•2mo ago
> Besides, gotta start somewhere. It's probably a PoC, for a platform that will eventually handle all sorts of things.

I agree and I think we should give folks leeway to make progress but this seems to be the qualifier for nearly every GenAI demo I’ve seen

tuyguntn•2mo ago
> all the example code is so poor, and the extent of the fix so limited

I agree about the limitations, but look from another perspective, is it good use of time asking experienced engineers who get paid 300-500k/year to go and fix these issues? Probably no.

Would it bring them a joy finding simple leaks and fixing them? Probably no again.

Then this tool is a nice addition to the engineers

fjwufjfa•2mo ago
> try (BufferedReader reader = new BufferedReader (new FileReader (filePath) )){

won't FileReader leak if the BufferedReader constructor throws?

nick__m•2mo ago
That BufferedReader constructors is not supposed to throw, unless the reader is null or you're out of memory. If your out of memory you should probably abort the program execution because the difficulty of correctly recovering from an OOM exception is between hard and impossible.

Edit: Disregard the above, it was too naive.

It cannot leak because of a stronger warranty. In the JLS, it is specified that the try-with-resources track successfull initialisation of AutoClosable resources, not successful assignation. So one try with resources can desugar into the logical equivalent of multiple nested try-catch-finally !

delusional•2mo ago
> difficulty of correctly recovering from an OOM exception is between hard and impossible.

In Java out of memory is signaled with an OutOfMemoryError which is a throwable (and can be caught) but is not technically an exception. Errors should generally never be caught and cannot be recovered from, which is how they differ from exceptions.

nick__m•2mo ago
It's possible to recover enough to cleanly save the user work and shutdown. You have to mesure of much memory you need for a clean shutdown and allocate a byte[sizeForShutdown] at the start of the application in the top level exception handler (the only one that should catch that error) and free that byte array before doing anything else.

Now you can argue that this is not truly recovering from exception but it is a lot better than what you can do with most of the other Error subclasses. I said most because there are easy to recover from Error like the StackOverflowError where you just have to fail the operation or request that caused the error.

nradov•2mo ago
Does the JLS actually guarantee that if you free that byte array then the extra memory will be immediately available? I thought there could potentially be some lag. The safer approach would be to create all of the objects you need for a clean shutdown during program launch and keep them around. Then you won't need to allocate any memory in the exception handler.
nick__m•2mo ago
Your approach is safer for sure and doesn't require me the read the JLS before going to see my mother for mother's day, so it's doubly better !
adra•2mo ago
It's not great, but you can always catch and retry if your belief is that the GC will free enough memory to allow the attempt to continue after the memory pressure subsides.

Let's say you get 1/100 requests that are randomly sent to your process. That 1 takes 100x the average memory usage of the others. You could spin it out to different services to better handle the weird one-off, but that doesn't always make sense. Sometimes you just need to be ok with working the 100x job and let the other 99 get progressive falloff retry. Different solutions are always possible.

Quekid5•2mo ago
> It's not great, but you can always catch and retry if your belief is that the GC will free enough memory to allow the attempt to continue after the memory pressure subsides.

No, you cannot. Catching, for example, StackOverflowError (which inherits from Error) can lead to very strange deadlocks and such (if locking is relying on try-finally discipline, as it should), even if you do "almost nothing" before re-throwing.

It's a huge hornet's nest of weirdness to even attempt to catch anything which derives directly from Error. (Rather than RuntimeException/Exception.)

EDIT: There are some really strange subclasses of Error now that I think about it. E.g. VirtualMachineError ... I don't think I've ever seen that in any logs, thankfully, but what exactly is the program (running on the failing VM) supposed to do if that is thrown? It'd be like trying to carry on or log an error if suddenly 1==2 turned out to be true.

delusional•2mo ago
> There are some really strange subclasses of Error now that I think about it. E.g. VirtualMachineError

An OutOfMemoryError is a VirtualMachineError. The Java runtime doesn't technically contain the idea of "finite memory". The language sort of assumes there's an infinite amount of memory. When there isn't and the VM is forced to throw an OutOfMemoryError it's technically a breach of the abstraction of the language and the VM is unable to continue working.

kburman•2mo ago
I'm not sure I fully understand the purpose of this tool. Modern IDEs are quite good at detecting these types of issues. And if they don't catch something, I often just copy and paste the method with some context-into an LLM and ask it to find the problem. It usually handles all the necessary changes for me.
microflash•2mo ago
Can we not solve this by an OpenRewrite recipe?

https://docs.openrewrite.org

Postgres LISTEN/NOTIFY does not scale

https://www.recall.ai/blog/postgres-listen-notify-does-not-scale
289•davidgu•3d ago•108 comments

Show HN: Pangolin – Open source alternative to Cloudflare Tunnels

https://github.com/fosrl/pangolin
22•miloschwartz•4h ago•2 comments

Show HN: Open source alternative to Perplexity Comet

https://www.browseros.com/
154•felarof•8h ago•52 comments

What is Realtalk’s relationship to AI? (2024)

https://dynamicland.org/2024/FAQ/#What_is_Realtalks_relationship_to_AI
231•prathyvsh•10h ago•78 comments

Graphical Linear Algebra

https://graphicallinearalgebra.net/
177•hyperbrainer•10h ago•12 comments

Batch Mode in the Gemini API: Process More for Less

https://developers.googleblog.com/en/scale-your-ai-workloads-batch-mode-gemini-api/
20•xnx•3d ago•4 comments

FOKS: Federated Open Key Service

https://foks.pub/
175•ubj•13h ago•42 comments

Turkey bans Grok over Erdoğan insults

https://www.politico.eu/article/turkey-ban-elon-musk-grok-recep-tayyip-erdogan-insult/
81•geox•2h ago•55 comments

Flix – A powerful effect-oriented programming language

https://flix.dev/
216•freilanzer•12h ago•88 comments

Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity

https://metr.org/blog/2025-07-10-early-2025-ai-experienced-os-dev-study/
513•dheerajvs•9h ago•325 comments

Red Hat Technical Writing Style Guide

https://stylepedia.net/style/
159•jumpocelot•11h ago•70 comments

Yamlfmt: An extensible command line tool or library to format YAML files

https://github.com/google/yamlfmt
24•zdw•3d ago•12 comments

Belkin ending support for older Wemo products

https://www.belkin.com/support-article/?articleNum=335419
52•apparent•7h ago•46 comments

Launch HN: Leaping (YC W25) – Self-Improving Voice AI

49•akyshnik•8h ago•25 comments

How to prove false statements: Practical attacks on Fiat-Shamir

https://www.quantamagazine.org/computer-scientists-figure-out-how-to-prove-lies-20250709/
198•nsoonhui•16h ago•153 comments

Show HN: Cactus – Ollama for Smartphones

107•HenryNdubuaku•7h ago•45 comments

eBPF: Connecting with Container Runtimes

https://h0x0er.github.io/blog/2025/06/29/ebpf-connecting-with-container-runtimes/
33•forxtrot•7h ago•0 comments

Regarding Prollyferation: Followup to "People Keep Inventing Prolly Trees"

https://www.dolthub.com/blog/2025-07-03-regarding-prollyferation/
39•ingve•3d ago•1 comments

Grok 4

https://simonwillison.net/2025/Jul/10/grok-4/
176•coloneltcb•6h ago•145 comments

Analyzing database trends through 1.8M Hacker News headlines

https://camelai.com/blog/hn-database-hype/
115•vercantez•2d ago•61 comments

Not So Fast: AI Coding Tools Can Reduce Productivity

https://secondthoughts.ai/p/ai-coding-slowdown
53•gk1•2h ago•30 comments

Diffsitter – A Tree-sitter based AST difftool to get meaningful semantic diffs

https://github.com/afnanenayet/diffsitter
89•mihau•13h ago•26 comments

Matt Trout has died

https://www.shadowcat.co.uk/2025/07/09/ripples-they-cause-in-the-world/
139•todsacerdoti•18h ago•41 comments

Is Gemini 2.5 good at bounding boxes?

https://simedw.com/2025/07/10/gemini-bounding-boxes/
258•simedw•13h ago•57 comments

The ChompSaw: A Benchtop Power Tool That's Safe for Kids to Use

https://www.core77.com/posts/137602/The-ChompSaw-A-Benchtop-Power-Tool-Thats-Safe-for-Kids-to-Use
80•surprisetalk•3d ago•64 comments

Foundations of Search: A Perspective from Computer Science (2012) [pdf]

https://staffwww.dcs.shef.ac.uk/people/J.Marshall/publications/SFR09_16%20Marshall%20&%20Neumann_PP.pdf
3•mooreds•3d ago•0 comments

Show HN: Typeform was too expensive so I built my own forms

https://www.ikiform.com/
166•preetsuthar17•17h ago•86 comments

Final report on Alaska Airlines Flight 1282 in-flight exit door plug separation

https://www.ntsb.gov:443/investigations/Pages/DCA24MA063.aspx
129•starkparker•5h ago•141 comments

Radiocarbon dating reveals Rapa Nui not as isolated as previously thought

https://phys.org/news/2025-06-radiocarbon-dating-reveals-rapa-nui.html
16•pseudolus•3d ago•5 comments

Optimizing a Math Expression Parser in Rust

https://rpallas.xyz/math-parser/
127•serial_dev•16h ago•55 comments