Self-imposed ban – a lightweight bash script to block commands

25•alex-moon•3d ago

Comments

samrus•6h ago

Why? I use the terminal but i have no idea how cli commands would get so distracting you have to parental lock yourself out of them like its entertainment or social media

haiku2077•6h ago

On window managers like i3 or sway, you launch programs (including GUI applications) via their shell command in an autocompleting micro-menu.

hk1337•5h ago

Ban yourself from vim so you don't get stuck in it for hours?

kjkjadksj•3h ago

Some people get distracted by work and not social media during their down time

ABU_ALLIL_123•2h ago

Lvoe

accoil•2h ago

I have a small post command hook in fish that looks at arg0 and prints out any associated reminder for the program I just used. I use it to remind myself that I'm testing an alternative (e.g I used grep today, and it printed out a reminder that I have rg installed). I guess it could be used as a harsher version of that.

jmholla•6h ago

Why have a dependency on Zenity instead of displaying the message in the terminal? Seems weirdly limiting to have a GUI dependency for a terminal application thus making this unusable on headless systems. I think you could make it optional and use STDERR if Zenity's not around.

yjftsjthsd-h•6h ago

I assume it's meant to work for programs that aren't being launched from the terminal

xunil2ycom•3h ago

My question exactly, minus the optional part. If it's a command-line tool, it should not require any GUI elements at all.

ramses0•6h ago

So, I love that the README is nearly as long as the code itself.

Shorthand:

    PATH=$HOME/.bans:$PATH  # (prefix path with "banned" cmd-dir)
    printf "echo 'bad!'" > "$HOME/bans/some-cmd"  # (make `some-cmd` run `echo 'bad!'`)

...and then some goodies around tracking, reasons, etc... some niftiness around "auto-expiring" the banned command (self-deletes the "bad" shell script that's shadowing the actual command usage).

As to the sibling "why?" ... it's trivial to circumvent: `ban ls "I run it too much..."`, `/bin/ls` is still unaffected, `rm ~/.bans/ls`, etc... but I _do_ like the pause to allow a return to rationality, eg: "Hey, maybe I do run `ls` too much..." and then deciding how to proceed.

It'd probably be nicer if it did something like `(Bad) Chrome.app/*` on OSX, but as an exercise in shell gymnastics, I'm kindof all here for it! :-)

samrus•5h ago

> "Hey, maybe I do run `ls` too much..."

This cant be a though someone has ever had. Your telling me people are getting addicted to the ls command?

lupusreal•5h ago

I'm addicted to sl. I love those trains.

z_open•4h ago

I am. Every time I cd I ls even though I know what's in there.

zamadatix•4h ago

I think it's more an example of a "why did I just cd ls cd ls cd ls that directory tree instead of leveraging tab completion" type thing than "man, I gotta get over my ls addiction or I won't be able to provide for my family".

I've found myself doing similar hints to nudge more efficient-but-less-exercised things into my day to day usage. E.g. making /etc/crontab a comment to get more used to creating systemd timers instead. Otherwise I'd just do it without thinking.

zahlman•3h ago

> why did I just cd ls cd ls cd ls that directory tree instead of leveraging tab completion

Sometimes I find myself repeatedly ls'ing even though I'm making good use of tab completion. There's something about seeing the names that helps with remembering what I was going to do.

hombre_fatal•3h ago

This is why I like GUIs. Seeing the files that are modified in my git gui reminds me of what Im doing instead of running git status. And seeing all the available things I could do is more stimulating than having to keep coming up with the text commands to type.

johnisgood•2h ago

For that I use Git Cola[1], it is quite nice.

[1] https://git-cola.github.io/

zahlman•1h ago

Come to think of it, I would probably benefit from rate-limiting myself on `git status`.

zamadatix•2h ago

  cd /etc/c<tab><tab>...

can list the names similar to

  cd /etc/<enter>ls c*<enter>cd c...

but there will always end up being times an actual ls is the right call, just not necessarily as ones default method.

max-privatevoid•3h ago

Bad habits do happen. I forced myself out of `sudo su` and into `sudo -i` by configuring my sudo rule to allow any command except `su`.

ofalkaed•3h ago

This popped up on HN last week: https://github.com/mieubrisse/cmdk I don't really get it but apparently some people really have issues with ls and cd and feel they use them too much.

skeptrune•5h ago

Haha, this is fun

nikolayasdf123•5h ago

kind of cool. like "App/Time Limits" in Apple

foxinsocks5•5h ago

What if I ban rm too?

johnisgood•4h ago

You will not be able to use the command. I am not sure if other scripts could, however. I have not checked the implementation.

msgodel•5h ago

I wrote a similar piece of software but it just limits time spent on certain web sites per day.

It's amazing how much something so simple can change your life if you have a problem with that. I'd highly recommend everyone enable it. I think iOS has something like that built in too so you don't even need my stuff unless you're on eg Linux.

RS-232•4h ago

> ban ban

teddyh•4h ago

Frog put the cookies in a box. “There,” he said. “Now we will not any more cookies.”

“But we can open the box,” said Toad.

“That is true,” said Frog.

zahlman•3h ago

Yes. It's still helpful.

The same arguments apply to, for example, leading-underscore names in Python code.

nektro•3h ago

wish the README showed an example of what trying to use a banned command looked like.

rather than this being useful to stop "distracting" commands i see this being useful in stopping agents from calling `rm` for example

nektro•3h ago

oh i see, it installs a bash script in a PATH thats a higher priority than the real one.

autoexec•1h ago

> i see this being useful in stopping agents from calling `rm` for example

I used to do that kind of thing a long time ago. MS-DOS wouldn't ask for confirmation when deleting files, so I'd use a hex editor to rename the del command, then create a batch file named del.bat that would ask if you really wanted to remove the file. Even had something like the recycle bin at one point to prevent accidental deletes.

You could even set up some very weak security by renaming commands like ls/dir and it could keep some casual snoops out of your system or prank/annoy someone else by replacing their commands to make them do funny things.

priyashpatil•1h ago

What if I ban ban

LIGO detects most massive black hole merger to date

Kiro: A new agentic IDE

Cognition (Devin AI) to Acquire Windsurf

NeuralOS: An operating system powered by neural networks

Replicube: 3D shader puzzle game, online demo

Building Modular Rails Applications: A Deep Dive into Rails Engines

Cidco MailStation as a Z80 Development Platform (2019)

Embedding user-defined indexes in Apache Parquet

Strategies for Fast Lexers

Japanese grandparents create life-size Totoro with bus stop for grandkids (2020)

SQLite async connection pool for high-performance

Lightning Detector Circuits

The Corset X-Rays of Dr Ludovic O'Followell (1908)

Meticulous (YC S21) is hiring in UK to redefine software dev

Data brokers are selling flight information to CBP and ICE

Two guys hated using Comcast, so they built their own fiber ISP

Anthropic signs a $200M deal with the Department of Defense

Grok 4 Heavy ($300/mo) returns its surname and no other text: "Hitler"

It took 45 years, but spreadsheet legend Mitch Kapor finally got his MIT degree

Impacts of adding PV solar system to internal combustion engine vehicles

Show HN: Refine – A Local Alternative to Grammarly

Tandy Corporation, Part 3 Becoming IBM Compatible

M.2 SSD Can Self-Destruct by Giving Itself a Burst of Voltage

East Asian aerosol cleanup has likely contributed to global warming

Lossless Float Image Compression

Six Game Devs Speak to Computer Games Mag (1984)

Show HN: Ten years of running every day, visualized

A Century of Quantum Mechanics

Why random selection is necessary to create stable meritocratic institutions

You Are in a Box