COBOL to Kotlin via Formal Models (IR and Alloy and Golden Master)

https://marcoeg.medium.com/from-cobol-to-kotlin-795920b1f371

62•marcoeg•3mo ago

Comments

marcoeg•3mo ago

I’ve been experimenting with formal, verifiable modernization and taking a small COBOL batch program and translating it through an intermediate representation and Alloy formal model into Kotlin, while proving equivalence with the legacy output.

Repo: https://github.com/marcoeg/cobol-modernization-playbook

Would love feedback from people who’ve worked on reverse engineering or legacy transformations at scale.

tshanmu•2mo ago

how are you creating the IR?

kvemkon•2mo ago

> formal, verifiable modernization

Would it be possible to do the same to modernize a Kotlin program becoming legacy in the future to something even more modern?

tadfisher•2mo ago

The code is slop, correct?

All the inputs and outputs are hardcoded. The code doesn't do anything except write hardcoded strings to files. Am I mistaken?

marcoeg•3mo ago

Source code: https://github.com/marcoeg/cobol-modernization-playbook

dfboyd•2mo ago

Isn't the first code sample pasted in there twice?

Jtsummers•2mo ago

Yes, starting at:

  STOP RUN.```cobol

Then the code repeats.

bigdatajs•2mo ago

The problem I have with all Cobol translation models is that it completely ignores the actual modernization of the system. You've traded one type of syntactic sugar with another.

agumonkey•2mo ago

you mean cobol 2002+ revisions ?

mike_hearn•2mo ago

I think they mean that "COBOL" is often used as a synonym for old mainframe based software. The language isn't the biggest issue with such systems, usually. Any programmer can learn COBOL, just translating one syntax to another doesn't buy you much. It's also about the hardware the stuff runs on, the database systems, the job schedulers, etc.

agumonkey•2mo ago

oh right, fair point

djoldman•2mo ago

> 1. Both systems run with the same fixed input files (data/accounts.dat, data/txns.dat).

> 2. Each writes its results to out/accounts_out_*.dat.

> 3. Python scripts convert fixed-width output to CSV and compute SHA-256 checksums.

> 4. If the hashes match — behavior is proven identical.

Step 3 above introduces the possibility that the python scripts alter the output in such a way that the outputs don't actually match prior to the python.

I'm curious why step 3 is not "If the two outputs match — behavior is proven identical."

drob518•2mo ago

From the article:

> This enduring reliance exists not out of nostalgia, but necessity: COBOL’s reliability, stability, and the prohibitive cost and risk of replacing decades of deeply integrated logic make it one of the most mission-critical technologies ever built.

That sentence struck me as odd. Is COBOL any more "reliable" or "stable" than any other language? I'm no COBOL expert, but when I've looked at it and read about how it works, it seems rather verbose and mundane. That's not unexpected; it was developed in a different era with different sensibilities.

skissane•2mo ago

Historically, COBOL lacked dynamic memory allocation-all data structures were fixed size and allocated at program startup. Although COBOL now has the equivalent of malloc/free, its long-time absence encouraged a coding style of using it sparingly-which does make a whole class of bugs less common in COBOL programs

bhawks•2mo ago

Yes no dynamic memory allocation, however there still are many ways to ABEND your COBOL program. The reliability aspect comes from the fact that these systems have been running for 40+ years, and places where it could have ABEND'd probably have been fixed [hopefully].

drob518•2mo ago

Okay, sure, but neither of those things are specific to COBOL. You can write C programs that allocate all memory statically and chase down every core dump over time and have a very reliable C program. Or better yet use Lisp or even Java with GC, if you find C too unsafe.

skissane•2mo ago

Programming languages are a bit like natural languages-they aren’t purely systems of formal rules, they are also usage patterns-there are lots of sentences which are formally correct English, but which few English speakers would ever construct-valid syntax and semantics, but stylistically and pragmatically abnormal. In the same way, a programming language is more than just the set of strings accepted by its compiler, it is a culture-language A may produce (in practice) more reliable code than B, not because of its feature set, but due to the cultural baggage that comes with it-but in a broader sense of “language”, that culture is part of the language too.

rdc12•2mo ago

With C in the embedded world it is very common to write entire applications that never only use static memory and the stack. Sometime programmers will allow dynamic memory during init only, other times not even then (I tend to favour the never approach, as I can verify that malloc is never called anywhere).

bhawks•2mo ago

Having COBOL sources which match whats running in production is a load bearing assumption :).

Tiny C Compiler

You Are Here

SectorC: A C Compiler in 512 bytes

The F Word

Speed up responses with fast mode

LLMs as the new high level language

Software factories and the agentic moment

Hoot: Scheme on WebAssembly

OpenCiv3: Open-source, cross-platform reimagining of Civilization III

Stories from 25 Years of Software Development

GitBlack: Tracing America's Foundation

FDA intends to take action against non-FDA-approved GLP-1 drugs

Show HN: A luma dependent chroma compression algorithm (image compression)

Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and working with Disney

First Proof

Brookhaven Lab's RHIC concludes 25-year run with final collisions

Vocal Guide – belt sing without killing yourself

I write games in C (yes, C) (2016)

Start all of your commands with a comma (2009)

Show HN: I saw this cool navigation reveal, so I made a simple HTML+CSS version

Italy Railways Sabotaged

Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback

Selection rather than prediction

The AI boom is causing shortages everywhere else

72M Points of Interest

A Fresh Look at IBM 3270 Information Display System

Coding agents have replaced every framework I used

Unseen Footage of Atari Battlezone Arcade Cabinet Production

France's homegrown open source online office suite

Microsoft account bugs locked me out of Notepad – Are thin clients ruining PCs?