The SpaceX Sham

https://dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/spacex-ipo-elon-musk-trillionaire/

29•cdrnsf•59m ago

Comments

AlexMuir•46m ago

> Although SpaceX stock has since fallen far below its IPO price

I'm a skeptic on SpaceX but the IPO price was $135, low was $108 and current price is $130. I wouldn't say that's far below.

caconym_•36m ago

Worth noting that it actually opened at $150 on public markets. It's kind of funny how we call the $135 figure the "public offering" price when there is really nothing public about it. Maybe it made more sense in some past era when it was more difficult for third parties to make private pre-IPO investments.

Not that there's anything particularly unusual about this. High profile tech companies almost universally (actually I am not aware of any moderately recent exceptions at all) fall below the actual public opening price in the days or weeks following the IPO. I honestly don't know why anybody buys them.

encoderer•18m ago

All you had to do was put in an order with your broker (robinhood, E*Trade, etc). Some brokers did not get much allocation (Schwab) but this was not a hard stock to get at $135.

Dig1t•14m ago

Anyone could sign up for the IPO price. I’m a nobody and I was able to buy some shares at $135 on the opening day. You just had to sign up to participate before opening day.

ck2•40m ago

it's worse than a scam, he's doing real, permanent damage to the environment

* https://techcrunch.com/2026/07/31/spacex-wont-remove-all-of-...

and illegally, not sure how he's allowed to get away with it

and each starlink deorbit is putting toxic pollution into the atmosphere without penalty (launches too)

* https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2025-space-orbit-satellit...

midwestfounder•33m ago

It's difficult to get past what comes across as an attempt to analytically substantiate moralistic reasoning. The contention that it's scandalous to raise capital to support an "automated future" then a dotted line to transhumanism and then the conclusion "it's a sham" feels shoddy.

sfblah•14m ago

To me, the bigger issue with SpaceX is that there's no real argument for how space exploration will benefit humanity in any tangible way. Humans cannot live sustainably on Mars or the moon -- that's just a straight-up lie. Satellites add some value for sure, but it's pretty limited, which helps explain why most of the launches just support StarLink (which itself is probably unsustainable financially). This whole thing is just a bunch of space nerds pushing society down a terrible cul-de-sac which will lower quality of life in meaningful ways in the coming century.

gfosco•32m ago

SpaceX and Elon are the litmus test for the future. You're either with him, or your opinions are ignorant and irrelevant.

benj111•19m ago

Sarcasm? Hard to tell.

ubiquitysc•15m ago

They work for Gab, not sarcasm

qwerpy•28m ago

@cdrnsf is posting negative articles all you do? isn't it exhausting to bathe in negativity all day long?

rendang•27m ago

> punitive capital gains taxation

A strange turn of phrase. What is the crime in view that's supposed to be punished?

MarkusQ•27m ago

> Negative coverage of the IPO was limited due to the participation of so many major banks in the IPO process; they don’t want to poison the cash cow they’re milking for underwriting fees.

WTF? Anyone willing to read this far knows that this is flat out false. The negative coverage was unrelenting, and largely driven by big players peeved by the unconventional process. Anyone who bothers to continue past that point is probably just looking for validation.

jotux•9m ago

It's funny how our perceptions are driven by the source of our news. I generally perceived the positive coverage in regular news as unrelenting. I know the tech news sources I read were constantly complaining about rule changes and manipulations on the part of Spacex, but run-of-the-mill national news outlets seem to be endlessly hyping the stock to the point that a few of my non tech-savvy family members were asking if they needed to buy it as soon as they went public.

baron3dl•22m ago

The real sham has yet to materialize. You only get a single $1T IPO. For the AI labs, investors are tapped out, and the only thing left is a huge IPO. Google, Meta, Microsoft's cash reserves are drying up, they're squeezing operations for every cent, and sure they can issue some stocks to raise cash, but not $1T.

I think this bubble's failure mode matches that of a Ponzi scheme.

sfblah•16m ago

The Fed can still declare some kind of financial emergency and increase the money printing again. My guess is this is likely, given the sway that tech CEOs have over the White House, and the reality of overseas competition.

slowmovintarget•16m ago

Ah yes... Critical Space Theory.

rtaylorgarlock•14m ago

I remember when a post of mine was flagged due to pretty obvious patent trolling against a cool FOSS project, but i made the critical error of 'crying' in my title. Maybe I should flag this to get it out of my system.

3asj176•12m ago

In retrospect it was a cunning plan to get $100B from the Musk-faithful to build Terafab. Intel is in, AmericaFirsters support it and Taiwan should feel less secure now.

The stock price is of course ridiculous: Intel lagged behind TSMC, but apparently Terafab has orders for ASML's latest gen machines (2nm). If Intel will manage to get a yield, we'll see.

All this space and AI stuff is marketing. The IPO was to get free money for a serious TSMC competitor.

England set to be one of the first countries to eliminate hepatitis C

Apple Silicon and macOS VMs: 11–16× Faster LLM Inference with Llama.cpp

OpenSSH 10.5 released, AI assistance now welcome

Stealing Reasoning Traces from Proprietary LLM APIs

Show HN: iPhone app takes simultaneous images from 2 lenses, fuses into 1 photo

Why Go Is an Ideal Language for AI-Assisted Software Engineering

Manus will return to operating as an independent company

Jolt: Clojure compiler implemented with Chez Scheme

Nvidia's Risky Business

As AI eats the web, the internet’s collective memory is disappearing

France to ban unsolicited telemarketing calls

Show HN: Git-knife – edit commit messages, authors, and dates like a spreadsheet

Archive of Animal Photography Reveals 18,000 Species and Counting

Launch HN: Keet (YC S24) – An app to create video courses on anything

H3-metal – Native MiniMax-H3 inference for Apple Silicon

What I learned by putting GitHub Copilot behind a MitM proxy

Federal vendor with $50M in contracts leaves portal broken for a month

Mojo 1.0 Is Here

Show HN: Needle2: 14MB agentic LLM for phones, wearables, smart home and robots

Halcyon Video – a 3D video store for your media server

Mark Zuckerberg attacks 'closed' AI rivals as Meta returns to open models

Chicken Scheme 6.0

LFM2.5 2.6B model competitive with 4x larger models

Show HN: Scroll through all 43252003274489856000 Rubik's Cube states

How Claude marks AI-generated content

Stowaway – Take the window seat on any plane or satellite overhead

Nvidia Nemotron 3.5 Lightning

The “mechanical miracle” that ruined Mark Twain’s life

We Used to Get Jobs

Faster floating point math with Rust's new API