frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Is AI-generated output copyrightable? Should it be?

3•robalni•7h ago

Comments

Sahil-Das•7h ago
In my opinion, AI generated output should be copyrightable as long as, and only if, the person using AI prompted it to generate the output based on an idea they originally had. If the idea itself was AI generated, I don't think it deserves copyright. But if the idea was original and AI was just used as a system to do the heavy lifting (coding etc.), then I don't see an issue with being able to copyright the output. This is just my opinion.
robalni•7h ago
Do you think it makes a difference to replace the AI with another human then?

If I have an original idea and ask you to do the work, should I get copyright?

ksaj•6h ago
You might bring ghost writers into this discussion.

If an AI did all the work, then it "traditionally" isn't copyrightable because it was generated algorithmically off other people's work, and not your own. A ghost writer willingly gives up their claim to their work, which surely is based on everything they've ever read before, too.

How different is that really? Definitely worth the input of a few differing voices.

Sahil-Das•5h ago
Yes. Because the idea is still yours. I am merely executing what you tell me to do, and that means I am not intellectually involved in the idea at the same level as you are. It was not my idea to begin with. If you let AI execute your idea, the idea is still yours, and execution was done upon your command and according to your ideas, hence, the output generated should be copyrightable.
ksaj•6h ago
Suno (an AI music site) specifies in their FAQ that the music isn't copyrightable. But your lyrics might be. And if you put a project together (and album or whatever) then that might also be. If you orchestrate a video for it, that is likely copyrightable. But the music itself isn't, since it was an algorithm based on a lot of other people's work that made that happen - not your skill or effort.

People who use AI to improve their own work most definitely have an argument that they own a copyright to the output. But in this case, they might only have claim to the lyrics, for example.

NoahZuniga•52m ago
Depends on where you are (copyright law varies by country!). In the US courts have ruled that computers can not be creative so anything generated by a computer is by default not copyrightable. If there is enough creativity included into the work by a human operator, then the work does become copyrightable.

And for should it be, I think this is a fine situation. Don't see a need to change it.

Tell HN: Anthropic no longer allowing Claude Code subscriptions to use OpenClaw

1052•firloop•1d ago•801 comments

Ask HN: Is there any interest in a native Qt/C++ Discord client?

20•txtsd•3d ago•22 comments

Training mRNA Language Models Across 25 Species for $165

144•maziyar•3d ago•33 comments

Why doesn't HN have a mobile app?

2•kranirudha•1h ago•2 comments

Skills to construct and read docs following the progressive exposure principle

4•Felix-Zhenghao•5h ago•1 comments

Write Your Own Copy

24•operatingthetan•14h ago•13 comments

Microsoft Discontinuing Publisher. Alternatives?

7•supliminal•13h ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Who is hiring? (April 2026)

276•whoishiring•3d ago•353 comments

Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (April 2026)

88•whoishiring•3d ago•340 comments

Ask HN: How Do You Relax?

12•azeirah•18h ago•18 comments

Intelligence Cannot Be Trained?

7•hyperzzw•1d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements

73•cmos•5d ago•65 comments

Anthropic to limit Using third-party harnesses with Claude subscriptions

17•guiyuwei•1d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Learning resources for building AI agents?

8•7e10•1d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Is AI-generated output copyrightable? Should it be?

3•robalni•7h ago•6 comments

Third-party Claude harnesses will now draw from extra usage

14•iBelieve•1d ago•4 comments

Anyone else having a terrible experience with Claude Code's remote control?

3•leddo•10h ago•0 comments

Tell HN: Chrome says "suspicious download" when trying to download yt-dlp

309•joering2•4d ago•98 comments

Lightweight IDE to Pair with Claude Code?

5•zupancik•1d ago•2 comments

Tell HN: YouTube history setting privacy implications

5•tinaclaussen•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Should we collectively stop spell checking and fixing grammar

5•sankalpnarula•1d ago•17 comments

Ask HN: What dev tools do you rely on that nobody talks about?

43•crcsmnky•3d ago•37 comments

Ask HN: Why still embed heavy 3rd-party iFrames for simple social proof?

4•LordKode•1d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How relevant is low code according to you in today’s world with Claude?

9•kinj28•2d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: What are you moving on to now that Claude Code is so rate limited?

10•esperent•2d ago•16 comments

Ask HN: Academic study on AI's impact on software development – want to join?

31•research2026•4d ago•16 comments

Ask HN: What is your dev set up like?

13•break_the_bank•2d ago•27 comments

Stripe closed my UAE business account and is withholding $3.5K

25•alganzory•2d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Are agents _still_ writing most of your code?

5•etamponi•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: European Tech Alternatives?

104•BrunoBernardino•2d ago•54 comments