Elliptical Python Programming

https://susam.net/elliptical-python-programming.html

184•sebg•11mo ago

Comments

benob•11mo ago

TIL that in python, 1--2==3

seplox•11mo ago

It's not a python thing. 1-(-2), distribute the negative.

qsort•11mo ago

In most C-like languages that would be a syntax error. E.g. in C and C++ as a rule you tokenize "greedily", "1--2" would be tokenized as "1", "unary decrement operator", "2", which is illegal because you're trying to decerment an rvalue.

Python doesn't have "--", which allows the tokenizer to do something else.

nyrikki•11mo ago

In C, that is really because Unary minus (negation) has precedence over binary operations.

    +a - b; // equivalent to (+a) - b, NOT +(a - b)
    -c + d; // equivalent to (-c) + d, NOT -(c + d)

https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/language/operator_arithmet...

    +-e; // equivalent to +(-e), the unary + is a no-op if “e” is a built-in type
     // because any possible promotion is performed during negation already

The same doesn't apply to, !! Which is applied as iterated binary operations (IIRC)

I am pretty sure the decriment operator came around well after that quirk was established.

seanhunter•11mo ago

Peter van der Linden’s book “Expert C Programming” (which is awesome btw) says that one of them (Kernighan, Richie or maybe Ken Thompson I forget) realised early on that the c compiler had the wrong operator precedence for bit twiddling and unary and boolean operators but “at that stage we had a few thousand lines of C code and thought it would be too disruptive to change it”

j2kun•11mo ago

Also worth noting that `1 - -2` works and produces 3 in C because the space breaks the operator.

plus•11mo ago

For those who are curious, `...` is a placeholder value in Python called Ellipsis. I don't believe it serves any real purpose other than being a placeholder. But it is an object and it implements `__eq__`, and is considered equal to itself. So `...==...` evaluates to `True`. When you prefix a `True` with `-`, it is interpreted as a prefix negation operator and implicitly converts the `True` to a `1`, so `-(...==...)` is equal to `-1`. Then, you add another prefix `-` to turn the `-1` back into `1`.

`--(...==...)--(...==...)` evaluates to `2` because the first block evaluates to 1, as previously mentioned, and then the next `-` is interpreted as an infix subtraction operator. The second `-(...==...)` evaluates to `-1`, so you get `1 - -1` or `2`.

When chaining multiple together, you can leave off the initial `--`, because booleans will be implicitly converted to integers if inserted into an arithmetic expression, e.g. `True - -1` -> `1 - -1` -> `2`.

> There should be one-- and preferably only one --obvious way to do it.

This article is obviously completely tongue-in-cheek, but I feel the need to point out that this sentence is not meant to be a complete inversion of the Perl philosophy of TIMTOWTDI. The word "obvious" is crucial here - there can be more than one way, but ideally only one of the ways is obvious.

pletnes•11mo ago

Numpy actively uses … to make slicing multidimensional arrays less verbose. There are also uses in FastAPI along the lines of «go with the default».

abuckenheimer•11mo ago

excellent explanation, to add to this since I was curious about the composition, '%c' is an integer presentation type that tells python to format numbers as their corresponding unicode characters[1] so

'%c' * (length_of_string_to_format) % (number, number, ..., length_of_string_to_format_numbers_later)

is the expression being evaluated here after you collapse all of the 1s + math formatting each number in the tuple as a unicode char for each '%c' escape in the string corresponding to its place in the tuple.

[1] https://docs.python.org/3/library/string.html#format-specifi...

nomel•11mo ago

Expanding on this a little, I will be replacing all occurrences of 2 with two blobs fighting, with shields:

    >>> 0^((...==...)--++--(...==...))^0
    2

rmah•11mo ago

>> There should be one-- and preferably only one --obvious way to do it.

Except for package management, of course. There, we need lots and lots of ways.

blooalien•11mo ago

And apparently string formatting which should have an ever growing number of ways to handle it. :shrug:

elijahbenizzy•11mo ago

Ok do this but for JavaScript

voidUpdate•11mo ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JSFuck

mariocesar•11mo ago

If you're curious, the code in ellipsis results in executing:

    print('hello, world')

mturmon•11mo ago

Thank you!

I noticed some ** and * in the thing sent to eval(), which (given that the building blocks are small integers) seemed related to prime factorizations.

The initial %c is duplicated 21 times (3*7, if I read correctly), and then string-interpolated (%c%c%c...) against a long tuple of integers. These integers themselves are composed of products of factors combined using * and **.

There is also one tuple "multiplication" embedded within that long tuple of integers -- (a,b)*2 = (a,b,a,b). That is for the 'l' 'l' in "hello".

It's all very clever and amusingly mathy, with a winking allusion to the construction of natural numbers using sets. It made me Godel.

callamdelaney•11mo ago

I think we're really starting to over crowd pythons syntax and I'm not a fan.

noddleah•11mo ago

you're telling me you never program in python elliptically??

acbart•11mo ago

Pretty sure this would have been possible in Python 2.6. The Ellipsis object has been around for a very long time.

MadVikingGod•11mo ago

This behavior can be replicated with any class that has two special methods: __neg__ that returns -1 and __sub__ that accepts ints and returns 1-other.

For example if you make this class:

  class _:
       def __neg__(self):
           return -1
       def __sub__(self, other):
           return 1-other

You get similar behavior:

  >>> --_()
  1
  >>> _()--_()
  2

Fun python for everyone.

maxloh•11mo ago

You can do this on JavaScript too.

  alert(1)
  // equals to:
  [][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]][([][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]]+[])[!+[]+!+[]+!+[]]+(!![]+[][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]])[+!+[]+[+[]]]+([][[]]+[])[+!+[]]+(![]+[])[!+[]+!+[]+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]+(!![]+[])[+!+[]]+([][[]]+[])[+[]]+([][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]]+[])[!+[]+!+[]+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]+(!![]+[][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]])[+!+[]+[+[]]]+(!![]+[])[+!+[]]]((![]+[])[+!+[]]+(![]+[])[!+[]+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[!+[]+!+[]+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]+([][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]]+[])[+!+[]+[+!+[]]]+[+!+[]]+([]+[]+[][(![]+[])[+!+[]]+(!![]+[])[+[]]])[+!+[]+[!+[]+!+[]]])()

https://jsfuck.com/

We haven't seen the worst of what gambling and prediction markets will do

CERN to host Europe's flagship open access publishing platform

Why so many control rooms were seafoam green (2025)

John Bradley, author of xv, has passed away

My minute-by-minute response to the LiteLLM malware attack

Doom entirely from DNS records

How much precision can you squeeze out of a table?

Show HN: Turbolite – a SQLite VFS serving sub-250ms cold JOIN queries from S3

Colibri – chat platform built on the AT Protocol for communities big and small

Fermented foods shaped human biology

OpenTelemetry profiles enters public alpha

Moving from GitHub to Codeberg, for lazy people

HyperAgents: Self-referential self-improving agents

Personal Encyclopedias

Stripe Projects: Provision and manage services from the CLI

Building a Blog with Elixir and Phoenix

From zero to a RAG system: successes and failures

Fast regex search: indexing text for agent tools

Running Tesla Model 3's computer on my desk using parts from crashed cars

My home network observes bedtime with OpenBSD and pf

Taming LLMs: Using Executable Oracles to Prevent Bad Code

End of "Chat Control": EU parliament stops mass surveillance

The Oxford Comma – Why and Why Not

New York City hospitals drop Palantir as controversial AI firm expands in UK

Interoperability Can Save the Open Web (2023)

Light on Glass: Why do you start making a game engine?

Obsolete Sounds

Olympic Committee bars transgender athletes from women’s events

Shell Tricks That Make Life Easier (and Save Your Sanity)

Show HN: Orloj – agent infrastructure as code (YAML and GitOps)