Rowing won't get the attention the paddleboard will?
The person is doing something physically and technically challenging. Perfect HN material.
Would love to dive into how he built the paddleboard, etc.
It's fairly large. There appears to be a hatch leading to an interior space. Presumably that's where he sleeps and stores supplies.
It's really more of a small paddle-powered boat. Given the shape and the ability to seal off the interior, it probably can survive a fair bit of rolling around in a storm.
This is a weird stunt that won’t prove anything. If he (magically) made it in a week people would still fly.
What’s the point? Don’t say “raising awareness”. Whose mind does the exercise have a chance of changing about what question? What behavioral change will that changed mind cause?
Writing, Metallurgy, Weaving, Pyramids, … all co-evolution? Could be. Or…
Thor Heyerdahl advocated hyperdiffusionist ideas, and to his credit showed two such routes were possible. However, "His hyperdiffusionist ideas on ancient cultures had been widely rejected by the scientific community, even before the expedition." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thor_Heyerdahl
I write more about it at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44399051 .
Regards food, the paddleboard looks about the same size as people who have previously rowed across the Atlantic solo.
Which is fine for a lot of the cross-Atlantic shipping traffic that is currently contributing to the CO2 emissions.
> Preparations for this special challenge have been ongoing for many months. However, for a project like this to come together, a lot of things have to fit together perfectly.
Take all the people, time and energy spend on preparations! It is probably several tons of CO2! Very long list of sponsors!
I refuse to believe, that super economy flight for $130 has higher CO2 emmisions than this stunt! It is like taking public transport!
Human is the engine here!
Take old galleys where hundred people rowed single boat. All that food to feed them! That is not very effient transport!
By my back of the envelope math, burning 600000 kcal should produce couple hundred kg of CO2. You could also make that crossing in less than a third of the time under sail, with about a third of the daily calorie consumption, for maybe a tenth of the CO2 output.
Before modern era, surely was done this way in antiquity..
I guess I just don't get it. Does the "paddleboard" represent something more than sail?
paulpauper•3d ago
foxyv•3d ago
https://youtu.be/6SYHamnHqU8?si=vp-NLeMnsdQz1R-Z
Generally speaking there is a route called the "Milk Run" from Europe to the Caribbean that has tail winds and good currents in the right direction. Also much nicer weather.
eesmith•39m ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Gyre
Looking at the current maps, I think most of the paddling will be southward, to get down to South America rather than the Caribbean.
For example, Thor Heyerdahl's Ra II, a square-sailed reed boat, went from Morocco to Barbados - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thor_Heyerdahl#Boats_Ra_and_Ra... .
The people I've heard of who have rowed across the Atlantic generally do Canary Islands to the Caribbean. There's even "The World's Toughest Row" for that route - https://www.worldstoughestrow.com/ .