frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Personal Statement of a CIA Analyst

https://antipolygraph.org/statements/statement-038.shtml
67•grubbs•3h ago

Comments

zenon_paradox•3h ago
The most troubling aspect of these accounts is the "unfalsifiable" nature of the countermeasure accusation. Once an examiner decides you’re manipulating your physiological response, there is no empirical way to prove you weren't. It essentially turns a high-stakes job interview into a test of how well you can suppress natural stress reactions. It’s a shame to see how many talented individuals are sidelined by a process that prizes a specific physiological profile over a demonstrated record of integrity.
Paracompact•1h ago
Am I a bad person if the picture of someone in the CIA crying is funny to me? Not out of malice or anything. It's just something I didn't know they did.

Do they also have little "Hang in there!" posters on the wall, too?

eru•1h ago
It's a bureaucracy like any other.
stego-tech•1h ago
Not bad, just as misinformed as most folks out there about the process and requirements.

National Security is a PITA, full of cutthroat sociopaths who would eat the SV VC-types for breakfast. That is a compliment, because the work they do is broadly dark and grimly necessary, at least at the levels of global geopolitics a lot of them are expected to operate at. I washed out in contracting for much the same reason this person kept "failing" polygraphs: honesty to the point of external perceptions of naivety. The types who excel in these sectors see folks like us as doormats or tissues, and react poorly when we catch them in the act and demand anything resembling respect because they know we're a threat to the entire establishment if we're allowed to succeed.

The point of polygraphs has always been about control, and folks who resist that sort of control are incidentally highlighting themselves as being uncontrollable to power alone. The books the author links are excellent starting points for understanding the true function of a polygraph, and why more places are outlawing them as a means of trying to diversify a deeply broken and hostile security apparatus by preventing it from being a "blind fools and sociopaths-only" club.

airstrike•1h ago
Not a bad person, just lacking in wisdom.
marxisttemp•45m ago
Not really
SpaceL10n•1h ago
I would use this information to reflect.
bitwize•44m ago
The movie Spy (2015) is probably the most accurate, realistic version of the CIA in cinema, replete with celebratory cakes for supervisors' birthdays and crumbling infrastructure due to insufficient funding.
mzajc•1h ago
(2018)
stego-tech•1h ago
Adding my POV from a former National Security perspective:

Author is 100% on point. The point of a polygraph is three-fold: weeding out the dipshits; exerting power over the powerless; and identifying the valuable assets (typically sociopaths). It does not - cannot - identify liars, deceit, or bad actors on its face (that comes from the manual the author linked). It's not scientific assessment, it's psychological torture.

Would I take a polygraph to reactivate my clearance? Yeah, if I had to. Would I pass? That's up to the examiner, because much like the author I won't tolerate being called a liar, nor will I capitulate to power games. I'll be honest, forthcoming, and cooperative - and if that's not enough to pass, then I don't want to work for you.

rconti•1h ago
This was all so weird to read about. I guess I just assumed the polygraph was of marginal utility, and you either passed, or you didn't. I didn't realize it was part of a combative interrogation process, even for regular employees.
fudged71•55m ago
There's two kinds of sociopaths, the uncontrollable ones and the controllable ones. The CIA only wants the latter.
wrp•11m ago
This comment or something like it should be at the top, because it's the main point about polygraphing. It's the process, not the answers that matter.

I knew a guy who did security clearance checking for the Three Letter Agencies for many years. He told be that if I ever had to do these interviews, I just need to pick good sounding lies and stick to them. He said it's the ones who try to be honest and introspective who get failed out.

ifh-hn•1h ago
I've no idea why I read to the end of that, seems like a long ramble, I kept expecting something to happen and it never did.
alansaber•1h ago
This was how I felt about reading War and Peace
UncleOxidant•47m ago
tl;dr: polygraphs aren't reliable and can be misused?
breve•9m ago
It's not that they're unreliable, they simply don't work in the first place.

The misuse is that they're used at all.

FergusArgyll•1h ago
I don't get it, I thought it's settled science that polygraphs don't work. Why are these agencies still using them?
sonofhans•1h ago
They do work. Their purpose is intimidation. They’re not truth machines, they’re pressure cookers.
constantcrying•49m ago
>I thought it's settled science that polygraphs don't work

Of course they do. And if you read the article in the OP you also realize why.

Polygraphs are an interrogation tactic, you can force a subject into a somewhat ridiculous procedure and ask them threatening questions, creating an disorientating situation. Afterwards you can accuse them of having "proven" that they are a liar. Polygraphs work, it just does not matter whether the machine is on or off.

joecool1029•1h ago
https://archive.ph/0gJFG
shevy-java•1h ago
> countermeasures such as butt-clenching

Ehm ...

I am actually not that convinced of that, largely because e. g. the KGB operated quite differently. And it seems very strange to me that the CIA would train an army of wanna-be's as ... butt-clenching recruits. The more sensible option is to have a poker face; and totally believe in any lie no matter how and what. That's kind of what Sergey Lavrov does. He babbles about how Ukraine invaded Russia. Kind of similar to a certain guy with a moustache claiming Poland invaded Germany (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gleiwitz_incident).

BoredPositron•38m ago
It's not butt clenching it's Kegels you just say butt clenching because it's funny.
marxisttemp•46m ago
The guy trying to work for the psychological torture club got psychologically tortured a little? My heart bleeds for him
Animats•20m ago
I went through national-security polygraph exams twice, and they were no big deal. Filling out SF-86 (which used to start "List all residences from birth"), now that's a hassle.

In my aerospace company days, almost everything I did was unclassified, but I was put through the mill of getting higher level security clearances so I could be assigned to classified projects. Fortunately, I never was.

ddtaylor•18m ago
I watched at Derbycon multiple times someone that could make a polygraph test do whatever he wanted, otherwise he was a murderer that murdered himself and it all happened before he was born. The test was being administered by a long time veteran polygraph operator who had recently retired.

EDuke32 – Duke Nukem 3D (Open-Source)

https://www.eduke32.com/
45•reconnecting•1h ago•15 comments

Parse, Don't Validate and Type-Driven Design in Rust

https://www.harudagondi.space/blog/parse-dont-validate-and-type-driven-design-in-rust/
51•todsacerdoti•1h ago•21 comments

I verified my LinkedIn identity. Here's what I handed over

https://thelocalstack.eu/posts/linkedin-identity-verification-privacy/
987•ColinWright•14h ago•372 comments

I Don't Like Magic

https://adactio.com/journal/22399
31•edent•3d ago•13 comments

How an inference provider can prove they're not serving a quantized model

https://tinfoil.sh/blog/2026-02-03-proving-model-identity
41•FrasiertheLion•14h ago•17 comments

Toyota Mirai hydrogen car depreciation: 65% value loss in a year

https://carbuzz.com/toyota-mirai-massive-depreciation-one-year/
30•iancmceachern•3h ago•60 comments

How far back in time can you understand English?

https://www.deadlanguagesociety.com/p/how-far-back-in-time-understand-english
231•spzb•3d ago•147 comments

What not to write on your security clearance form (1988)

https://milk.com/wall-o-shame/security_clearance.html
319•wizardforhire•4h ago•122 comments

Personal Statement of a CIA Analyst

https://antipolygraph.org/statements/statement-038.shtml
68•grubbs•3h ago•33 comments

Inputlag.science – Repository of knowledge about input lag in gaming

https://inputlag.science
32•akyuu•1h ago•3 comments

CXMT has been offering DDR4 chips at about half the prevailing market rate

https://www.koreaherald.com/article/10679206
101•phront•7h ago•70 comments

zclaw: personal AI assistant in under 888 KB, running on an ESP32

https://github.com/tnm/zclaw
21•tosh•8h ago•14 comments

Canvas_ity: A tiny, single-header <canvas>-like 2D rasterizer for C++

https://github.com/a-e-k/canvas_ity
26•PaulHoule•2h ago•13 comments

Cloudflare outage on February 20, 2026

https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-outage-february-20-2026/
103•nomaxx117•2h ago•74 comments

Claws are now a new layer on top of LLM agents

https://twitter.com/karpathy/status/2024987174077432126
120•Cyphase•20h ago•530 comments

MeshTNC is a tool for turning consumer grade LoRa radios into KISS TNC compatib

https://github.com/datapartyjs/MeshTNC
6•todsacerdoti•1h ago•0 comments

Loon: A functional lang with invisible types, safe ownership, and alg. effects

https://loonlang.com
48•surprisetalk•23h ago•22 comments

Permacomputing

https://wiki.xxiivv.com/site/permacomputing.html
59•tosh•4d ago•11 comments

Acme Weather

https://acmeweather.com/blog/introducing-acme-weather
149•cryptoz•14h ago•96 comments

A solver for Semantle

https://victoriaritvo.com/blog/semantle-solver/
45•evakhoury•3d ago•11 comments

Show HN: Iron-Wolf – Wolfenstein 3D source port in Rust

https://github.com/Ragnaroek/iron-wolf
45•ragnaroekX•5h ago•16 comments

Uncovering insiders and alpha on Polymarket with AI

https://twitter.com/peterjliu/status/2024901585806225723
102•somerandomness•1d ago•94 comments

AI uBlock Blacklist

https://github.com/alvi-se/ai-ublock-blacklist
185•rdmuser•13h ago•77 comments

Be wary of Bluesky

https://kevinak.se/blog/be-wary-of-bluesky
169•kevinak•21h ago•126 comments

Padlet (YC W13) Is Hiring in San Francisco and Singapore

https://padlet.jobs
1•coffeebite•9h ago

Microsoft team creates data-storage system that lasts for millennia

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00502-2
63•gnabgib•3d ago•54 comments

A16Z partner says that the theory that we'll vibe code everything is ' wrong'

https://www.aol.com/articles/a16z-partner-says-theory-well-050150534.html
58•paulpauper•22h ago•70 comments

Keep Android Open

https://f-droid.org/2026/02/20/twif.html
1945•LorenDB•1d ago•669 comments

Don't create .gitkeep files, use .gitignore instead (2023)

https://adamj.eu/tech/2023/09/18/git-dont-create-gitkeep/
110•frou_dh•23h ago•71 comments

The Nekonomicon – Nekochan.net Archive, Updated

http://nekonomicon.irixnet.org/
37•ThatGuyRaion•5h ago•8 comments