frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Data Has Weight but Only on SSDs

https://cubiclenate.com/2026/03/04/data-has-weight-but-only-on-ssds-blathering/
29•LorenDB•2h ago

Comments

tliltocatl•2h ago
I think the article is wrong in its core premise. While the electrons get added or removed from the floating gate, the total number of electrons in the SSD chip stays the same. Gates are capacitors, in order to add electrons to one capacitor plate, you have to remove an equal numbers of electrons from the other plate, i. e. from the transistor channel. The net charge of a SSD chip is always zero. Otherwise it would just go bang. <s>2.43×10^-15</s> [my bad 1] 2.67×10^15 electrons is about 300µC - that's a lot of charge to separate macroscopically.

Therefore the mass (weight is a different thing, through it is proportional to mass at a given constant gravity potential) of the data on a SSD isn't fundamentally different from a HDD - they both are caused by a change of internal energy without any change in the number of fermions. I'd expect data on SSD to have larger mass change because a charged capacitor always store more energy than a discharged one, while energy of magnetic domains is less directional and depends mostly on the state of neighbor domains - but I'm not sure about this part.

[1] Thanks stackghost.

zahlman•1h ago
TFA started out seeming well enough written but definitely turned LLM-padded in the middle. And yeah, I think you're right about the actual science.
stackghost•1h ago
>2.43×10^-15 electrons

I believe TFA reads 2.43×10^-15 kg, not electrons. Unless SSDs are creating new and exciting physics, one can't have less than one electron, as it's an elementary particle.

jmalicki•1h ago
Neutrinos weight far less than electrons (but while NAND flash involves super weird physics it's not that weird)
stackghost•1h ago
They do weigh far less, but a quantity of "10^-15 electrons" is still impossible.
nickcw•33m ago
> So, assuming the source material is correct and electrons indeed have mass, SSDs do get heavier with more data.

That is definitely wrong! No way the source material has more electrons. The only way it could do that is by being charged.

Richard Feynman, The Feynman Lectures: "If you were standing at arm's length from someone and each of you had one percent more electrons than protons, the repelling force would be incredible. How great? Enough to lift the Empire State Building? No! To lift Mount Everest? No! The repulsion would be enough to lift a "weight" equal to that of the entire earth!"

From: https://tycho.parkland.edu/cc/parkland/phy142/summer/lecture...

jmclnx•1h ago
interesting, I wonder if one can translate this into the amount of data on the drive ? Maybe it does not matter unless one cleared the drive using dd(1).

Also would trimming cause a different value even though the data size remains the same ? I would think so, assuming I understand trim.

epx•1h ago
Was expecting Boltzmann and entropy to be involved at some point :(
MengerSponge•1h ago
Yeah, I was motivated to go Wiki diving, where I just learned about the Shannon (unit). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon_(unit)

Time to replace "I'm zero surprised" with "That's a zero Shannon event"

nwellnhof•1h ago
Reminds me of an old April Fools' prank in German c't magazine. They offered a defragmentation-like tool for HDDs that claimed to distribute 0s and 1s more evenly on the drive to make it run more smoothly and extend its lifespan.
omgbear•1h ago
I think my network card does that.
jerf•44m ago
Amusingly, that's unnecessary, but possibly not for the reason most people think. It's not because the hard drive hardware is oblivious to runs of 0s and 1s exactly... it's because it's actually so sensitive that it already is recording the data in an encoding that doesn't allow for long runs of 0s and 1s. You can store a big file full of zeros on your disk and the physical representation will be about 50/50 ones and zeros on the actual storage substrate already. Nothing you do at the "data" layer can even create large runs of 0s or 1s on the physical layer in the first place. See https://www.datarecoveryunion.com/data-encoding-schemes/
themafia•31m ago
More appropriately data has a temperature.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermodynamic_beta

antimatter15•24m ago
Another fun calculation is that due to special relativity, a hard drive that is spinning gains a certain amount of mass due to the rotational kinetic energy and E=mc^2.

Assuming the platter is 100g, 42mm, spinning at 7200RPM, there is about 25J of rotational kinetic energy, whose mass equivalent is 2.8x10^-13g (0.28 femtograms).

Assuming 200 electrons per NAND floating gate with 3bits/cell TLC on a 2TB SSD, there would be 5.3x10^14 electrons, weighing about 0.5 femtograms.

tlb•7m ago
The rate at which molecules of plastic sublimate off the surface of the enclosure is probably a much larger amount of mass. The rate increases with e^kT, where k is such that it doubles about every 10 degrees C. So if you get a drive and fill it with data (which warms it up significantly) the lost casing material will dominate the mass balance.

An interactive map of Flock Cams

https://deflock.org/map#map=5/37.125286/-96.284180
294•anjel•2h ago•72 comments

MacBook Neo

https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2026/03/say-hello-to-macbook-neo/
1221•dm•7h ago•1574 comments

Does that use a lot of energy?

https://hannahritchie.github.io/energy-use-comparisons/
34•speckx•48m ago•19 comments

Something is afoot in the land of Qwen

https://simonwillison.net/2026/Mar/4/qwen/
375•simonw•5h ago•187 comments

Making Firefox's right-click not suck with about:config

https://joshua.hu/firefox-making-right-click-not-suck
180•mmsc•3h ago•115 comments

Nobody Gets Promoted for Simplicity

https://terriblesoftware.org/2026/03/03/nobody-gets-promoted-for-simplicity/
745•aamederen•9h ago•428 comments

NanoGPT Slowrun: Language Modeling with Limited Data, Infinite Compute

https://qlabs.sh/slowrun
78•sdpmas•3h ago•9 comments

Moss is a pixel canvas where every brush is a tiny program

https://www.moss.town/
103•smusamashah•10h ago•10 comments

Data Has Weight but Only on SSDs

https://cubiclenate.com/2026/03/04/data-has-weight-but-only-on-ssds-blathering/
31•LorenDB•2h ago•15 comments

Building a New Flash

https://bill.newgrounds.com/news/post/1607118
17•TechPlasma•1h ago•3 comments

The Rust Calling Convention We Deserve

https://mcyoung.xyz/2024/04/17/calling-convention/
15•cratermoon•3d ago•0 comments

“It turns out” (2010)

https://jsomers.net/blog/it-turns-out
198•Munksgaard•6h ago•68 comments

Roboflow (YC S20) Is Hiring a Security Engineer for AI Infra

https://roboflow.com/careers
1•yeldarb•3h ago

Was Windows 1.0's lack of overlapping windows a legal or a technical matter?

https://retrocomputing.stackexchange.com/questions/32511/was-windows-1-0s-lack-of-overlapping-win...
10•SeenNotHeard•1h ago•3 comments

Father claims Google's AI product fuelled son's delusional spiral

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/czx44p99457o
98•tartoran•1h ago•107 comments

Google ends its 30 percent app store fee and welcomes third-party app stores

https://www.engadget.com/apps/google-ends-its-30-percent-app-store-fee-and-welcomes-third-party-a...
91•_____k•1h ago•28 comments

Glaze by Raycast

https://www.glazeapp.com/
160•romac•7h ago•96 comments

Qwen3.5 Fine-Tuning Guide – Unsloth Documentation

https://unsloth.ai/docs/models/qwen3.5/fine-tune
208•bilsbie•9h ago•52 comments

Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs

https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2520385123
9•bikenaga•4h ago•1 comments

Raspberry Pi Pico as AM Radio Transmitter

https://www.pesfandiar.com/blog/2026/02/28/pico-am-radio-transmitter
41•pesfandiar•3d ago•20 comments

Libre Solar – Open Hardware for Renewable Energy

https://libre.solar
166•evolve2k•3d ago•46 comments

Faster C software with Dynamic Feature Detection

https://gist.github.com/jjl/d998164191af59a594500687a679b98d
28•todsacerdoti•2h ago•2 comments

The View from RSS

https://www.carolinecrampton.com/the-view-from-rss/
9•Curiositry•59m ago•2 comments

My Favorite 39C3 Talks

https://asindu.xyz/my-favorite-39c3-talks/
22•max_•3d ago•2 comments

MyFirst Kids Watch Hacked. Access to Camera and Microphone

https://www.kth.se/en/om/nyheter/centrala-nyheter/kth-studenten-hackade-klocka-for-barn-1.1461249
86•jidoka•8h ago•21 comments

Agentic Engineering Patterns

https://simonwillison.net/guides/agentic-engineering-patterns/
453•r4um•16h ago•256 comments

TikTok will not introduce end-to-end encryption, saying it makes users less safe

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cly2m5e5ke4o
383•1659447091•19h ago•370 comments

RFC 9849. TLS Encrypted Client Hello

https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9849.html
253•P_qRs•13h ago•122 comments

The Space Race's Forgotten Theme Park

https://daily.jstor.org/the-space-races-forgotten-theme-park/
15•anarbadalov•3h ago•1 comments

Emails to Outlook.com rejected due to a fault or overzealous blocking rules

https://www.theregister.com/2026/03/04/users_fume_at_outlookcom_email/
114•Bender•9h ago•70 comments