frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

The Day NY Publishing Lost Its Soul

https://www.honest-broker.com/p/the-day-ny-publishing-lost-its-soul
29•wallflower•3h ago

Comments

kurthr•1h ago
I'll offer a hopeful rejoinder. Perhaps, when AISlop generates enough of the same old story "guaranteed" hits for the mass market (and book covers to go with same), the editors will switch back to something that is novel and unlikely to be generated.

Think about what happens when you feed the first few books of a series into long context llm, along with their audience interests, pitch lines, plot summaries and character guides. When each element is multi-shot rather than zero-shot.

raldi•1h ago
The clickbait title refers to a day in fall 1995 when a Random House editor was told by his boss that the business could no longer afford to publish modestly-selling books (~10,000-40,000 copies), marking the moment when corporate scale killed the old risk-taking culture of publishing.
comrade1234•1h ago
Interesting history but what's going on now is so crazy as a reader. Amazon kindle publishes 7500 new books daily. There's no longer gatekeepers like in the article.

About two years ago I was searching for a new sci-fi book to read - I routinely rotate genres. I did my research in goodreads and started reading a trilogy that was highly rated. Holy crap it was so bad a quit about halfway through the second book. I went back to goodreads and the rating since my last visit had dropped drastically. A bot campaign or something fooled me, I guess.

I've since just started reading older stuff, before the 2000s. I'd try to find a gatekeeper to filter newer stuff for me but everything seems corrupt - even the Hugo awards gets scammed by influence campaigns.

pavel_lishin•1h ago
> I'd try to find a gatekeeper to filter newer stuff for me but everything seems corrupt

Word of mouth is the best way to do this, among friends who read similar things to you.

Even if you're recommended something you end up not liking, it's not because they're malicious, their tastes are just not the same as yours - and after awhile, you learn to adapt. Friend A recommends a space opera? Great, you have very similar tastes. They recommend a horror novel? Eh, you know that what they consider to be good horror isn't what you do, so you skip that one.

comrade1234•1h ago
I actually do do that and we all recommend each other older stuff we read years ago. :)

These are some of my most recent conversations: "try Raymond Feist's Magician series" "I'm reading the Book of the New Sun series now" "I read the Pendragon Cycle (she's English and obsessed with King Arthur stories) in high school and liked it but now it's a weird right-wing tv show"

These are all old books but still super enjoyable. (Except maybe book of the new sun - kind if a bummer)

PNewling•1h ago
Not that this is the perfect fix, but at least for sci-fi books you can usually look the Hugo Award winners[0] for ones that are solid. Not all of them are my cup of tea, but I have found that I definitely love some of the series that are found there. I'm sure there are other award types per genre that could help point you to some as well. Not that these can't be gamed, or sponsored or whatever, but at least it is a good starting point that is (¿maybe?) less prone to bot bias campaigns.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Award_for_Best_Novel

nomdep•15m ago
That was true until 10 or 15 years ago. They have been riddled with (accusations of) bias and fraud since then
moffkalast•1h ago
People who don't see any issue with writing novels with LLMs probably correlate heavily with those that also don't see any issue using a botnet of them to promote it. So it's always the worst slop that ends up being pushed the most. We could call this "the Openclaw effect".
transcriptase•30m ago
7500 books a day… what percentage are AI slop? Half the non-fiction and children’s books I see are clearly just free tier ChatGPT with poorly generated AI imagery.
boznz•8m ago
true, but what percentage a ghost-written fodder?, what percentage are best-sellers milking their fan=base with derivatives of the same slop? It has always been the problem for the reader to sort out the good stuff from the rubbish, it has just gotten a hundred times harder as the bar for writing is now a lot lower. When I meet a new person who I get on with I ask them what are their favourite books and why, it has opened my eyes to some great books I would not otherwise have found, I really wish I had kept a proper book/reading diary so I could pass these on myself, hindsight it great!
boznz•26m ago
Influencers, and people with zero talent, but who have a public audience, are the new target for publishers, so expect a fuck-tonne more rubbish to be pushed by the usual channels and algorithms.

This is not a good time to be an indie author (I should know) writing the book is only the start of the journey, if you want people to now read it you have to fight a system dead set against your success. Word of mouth eventually gets you a few readers, or sales (thankfully) but there are plenty of really good indie authors out there, and you will never find them in the normal algorithms or book recommendation sites.

Spooky23•8m ago
Publishers served a really valuable purpose of curation and keeping good authors productive.

Now we have the double whammy of a consolidated publishing system pumping out whatever James Patterson’s assistants churn out and and a long tail of drivel, both AI and regular slop.

BrenBarn•1h ago
This is not specific to publishing. The diagram tells the story: it's consolidation. Consolidation is bad. Giant companies are bad. In publishing as in other domains.
idle_zealot•1h ago
Correct. That's why even though the specific complaint from the article no longer applies, and small-volume books are easier than ever to publish, things are still shit, only in different ways. Consolidation in a market is just about the worst way to run anything; all the worst elements of a government agency and a profit-seeking business with none of the moderating factors of democracy or competition.
encrypted_bird•27m ago
It's almost like competition is critical for a healthy marketplace! (Seriously, I _don't_ understand why this is such a hard concept for a lot of people to understand...)
jbellis•1h ago
The 90s aren't coming back to publishing. The audience who reads multiple books a month is going the way of the classical symphony attendee.
comrade1234•1h ago
The opera, symphony, and ballet sell out every performance where I live. Me, my friends, wife, etc all read multiple books per month. To me it feels like the problem is in the supply-side - there's just endless content being constantly published - more than could ever be read.
righthand•58m ago
One medium where this isn’t really true is video games. Why hasn’t Steam or Itch fallen in this trap? Because they are honest stewards? Or because the software plane isn’t as large? Only news publishing and written word and movies. In fact movies even have a set number of prestige “risk” directors so they never have to reach too far out of the norm, see Yorgos Lanthimos.
like_any_other•2m ago
I deeply empathize with his complaint about book covers, but I think that's just what "design" is these days. This is Peter and Wendy, 1st edition: https://mflibra.com/products/1911-rare-peter-pan-first-editi...

This is a modern edition: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Peter-Wendy-AmazonClassics-J-Barrie...

They could have just left it alone - "fired the design team". But no - they spent time and money to vandalize it.

CasNum

https://github.com/0x0mer/CasNum
151•aebtebeten•3h ago•21 comments

Put the zip code first

https://zipcodefirst.com
134•dsalzman•55m ago•104 comments

LLM Writing Tropes.md

https://tropes.fyi/tropes-md
62•walterbell•3h ago•19 comments

A decade of Docker containers

https://cacm.acm.org/research/a-decade-of-docker-containers/
213•zacwest•7h ago•156 comments

Dumping Lego NXT firmware off of an existing brick (2025)

https://arcanenibble.github.io/dumping-lego-nxt-firmware-off-of-an-existing-brick.html
133•theblazehen•1d ago•8 comments

Effort to prevent government officials from engaging in prediction markets

https://www.merkley.senate.gov/merkley-klobuchar-launch-new-effort-to-ban-federal-elected-officia...
180•stopbulying•3h ago•63 comments

Ki Editor - an editor that operates on the AST

https://ki-editor.org/
352•ravenical•13h ago•129 comments

In 1985 Maxell built a bunch of life-size robots for its bad floppy ad

https://buttondown.com/suchbadtechads/archive/maxell-life-size-robots/
53•rfarley04•3d ago•3 comments

Package managers need to cool down

https://nesbitt.io/2026/03/04/package-managers-need-to-cool-down.html
35•zdw•3d ago•26 comments

The Day NY Publishing Lost Its Soul

https://www.honest-broker.com/p/the-day-ny-publishing-lost-its-soul
29•wallflower•3h ago•19 comments

FLASH radiotherapy's bold approach to cancer treatment

https://spectrum.ieee.org/flash-radiotherapy
177•marc__1•8h ago•54 comments

macOS code injection for fun and no profit (2024)

https://mariozechner.at/posts/2024-07-20-macos-code-injection-fun/
59•jstrieb•3d ago•10 comments

Autoresearch: Agents researching on single-GPU nanochat training automatically

https://github.com/karpathy/autoresearch
25•simonpure•3h ago•3 comments

The influence of anxiety: Harold Bloom and literary inheritance

https://thepointmag.com/examined-life/the-influence-of-anxiety/
6•apollinaire•3d ago•1 comments

How important was the Battle of Hastings?

https://www.historytoday.com/archive/head-head/how-important-was-battle-hastings
4•benbreen•3d ago•2 comments

Why developers using AI are working longer hours

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-developers-using-ai-are-working-longer-hours/
22•birdculture•43m ago•9 comments

The surprising whimsy of the Time Zone Database

https://muddy.jprs.me/links/2026-03-06-the-surprising-whimsy-of-the-time-zone-database/
29•jprs•5h ago•1 comments

Caitlin Kalinowski: I resigned from OpenAI

https://twitter.com/kalinowski007/status/2030320074121478618
27•mmaia•1h ago•9 comments

Compiling Prolog to Forth [pdf]

https://vfxforth.com/flag/jfar/vol4/no4/article4.pdf
93•PaulHoule•4d ago•9 comments

Lisp-style C++ template meta programming

https://github.com/mistivia/lmp
6•mistivia•2h ago•0 comments

SigNoz (YC W21, open source Datadog) Is Hiring across roles

https://signoz.io/careers
1•pranay01•7h ago

Re-creating the complex cuisine of prehistoric Europeans

https://arstechnica.com/science/2026/03/recreating-the-complex-cuisine-of-prehistoric-europeans/
61•apollinaire•1d ago•23 comments

Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is verified?

20•BelVisgarra•2h ago•37 comments

The yoghurt delivery women combatting loneliness in Japan

https://www.bbc.com/travel/article/20260302-the-yoghurt-delivery-women-combatting-loneliness-in-j...
188•ranit•11h ago•120 comments

Show HN: ANSI-Saver – A macOS Screensaver

https://github.com/lardissone/ansi-saver
86•lardissone•9h ago•27 comments

Files are the interface humans and agents interact with

https://madalitso.me/notes/why-everyone-is-talking-about-filesystems/
167•malgamves•13h ago•104 comments

Trampolining Nix with GenericClosure

https://blog.kleisli.io/post/trampolining-nix-with-generic-closure
3•ret2pop•2d ago•1 comments

Self-Portrait by Ernst Mach (1886)

https://publicdomainreview.org/collection/self-portrait-by-ernst-mach-1886/
86•Hooke•2d ago•16 comments

Bourdieu's theory of taste: a grumbling abrégé (2023)

https://dynomight.net/bourdieu/
35•sebg•2d ago•11 comments

Show HN: µJS, a 5KB alternative to Htmx and Turbo with zero dependencies

https://mujs.org
105•amaury_bouchard•15h ago•44 comments