frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Music has scales / raagas. What about storytelling in movies and prestige shows?

https://arc.quanten.co/archetype
11•phaedrus044•3h ago

Comments

phaedrus044•3h ago
This has been almost 2.5 years in the making.

The question we started off with was - if there are scales and raagas for music, is there something similar for storytelling. What goes well after what beat.

That took us through a journey.

Building Quanten Pulse, which led to Quanten Arc (real data, that led to a model), which then allowed us to create a benchmark database of more than 400 films.

So if you breakdown 400 hollywood blockbusters, and break them scene by scene, map emotions and durations, and character arcs, what is the patterns that you see - and if you step back, do you see clusters of patterns that resonate well.

Most people in hollywood write stories in two structures - predominantly. It is either Save the Cat, or the Heroes journey. But what if you don't want to save cats or go on the journey? (imagine if someone telling a musician, you have two scales - thats it).

We took a peek into the 400 and found 15 different narrative structures that work well. I have a feeling as we expand - into regional cinema, and different formats, we will find more.

Tell me what you think : https://arc.quanten.co/archetype

PS: While we started with Hollywood, we are starting to do this analysis for Bollywood films too (though finding scripts has been difficult)

PunchTornado•51m ago
Cool. I would go into the european or auteur films. Also Asian films like wkw.
phaedrus044•36m ago
Yep, that's definitely on the list. The only issue that I am battling with is how to take something as a positive signal to build these patterns on. Because if i take the entire universe of films, there is probably every variation of arcs. But some have worked / resonated with audiences and some haven't. The way European Cinema has been funded (predominantly through governments) mean that they do the film circuit and then disappear - and the filmmakers are off to make the next film grant. How do i find the signal to identify whats a good film or not.

There was this snide remark that someone in hollywood made where they said, they make movies whereas Europe makes (art) cinema.

I havent figured out how to resolve that yet.

But yes to korean, japanese films - that's very much on the list.

mdre•34m ago
Seems like a cool idea but it's kinda hard to tell without seeing a whole movie or two fully broken down into those scale steps. Maybe it's there behind a paywall.
phaedrus044•31m ago
We've made a few of that data fully visible. Try this :

http://arc.quanten.co/showcase/film (Anora) http://arc.quanten.co/showcase/series (The Pitt S01E01)

anentropic•5m ago
imagine if the text was bright enough to read
tnelsond4•22m ago
For individual notes there's https://tvtropes.org
phaedrus044•4m ago
Is this mostly used to flesh out character profiles?
hnhg•19m ago
This is a very interesting concept. I see in your replies to other comments that you are looking at movies from different cultures, which would be a great test of your idea. Once you have sufficiently advanced, it would be great to look at theatre too. I have a hypothesis that movie-writing began to diverge from theatre-writing in the very late 20th century in terms of structure and writing with the rise of the blockbuster and the emphasis on spectacle, and we lost something after that.
phaedrus044•11m ago
Doesn't the format by itself implicitly change the structure of the content? I know some friends who are in theatre, and even when they do 4 shows a week, there are variations that they make constantly that no two shows are the same.

My musician friends who are scholars in indian music tell me that there is a difference between a written raaga and a performed raaga and in a performed raaga, the actor has the right to improvize on that.

Im trying very hard to not go into the rabbit hole which might become purely academic :) But i would think that if we take how youtube content is structured, or tiktoks are, each format would lend to a new structure.

Thats my sense, i could be wrong. What do you think?

0gs•18m ago
so raagas are like scales? i thought it was just a type of music where the same songs are played by every artist, like blues, so maybe i don't get this idea at all. but is it about the order of scenes in movies? or like which scenes are "allowed" in a movie of a particular genre? in any case, are you familiar with the Aarne Thompson Uther index?
phaedrus044•5m ago
Raagas are like scales (which is a massive reduction though) because they are a bit more complicated. Each raaga has time, emotion attached to it as well - there are raagas you can use in a time of a day (in the morning, but not evening for a evening song etc). But yes, scales are the closest it comes to.

There are 72 major raagas - called mela kartha raagas - those are the root raagas, and there are combinations and permutations done that generates the janya raagas - which is children raagas (there are thousands of those - and different artists can create variations on these).

Most films in Hollywood have narrative beats - its 7-8 beats. Each tv show for eg, has 5-6 beats. Most micro drama episode has 2-4 beats. Its quite structure that way.

If you take a structure like Save the cat, or Heroes' journey, the order of the beats are also quite well laid out - just that those two structures dont cover the span of stories, and rest is all quite undocumented.

Im trying to work backwards - and quite aware that i am probably identifying derivatives than the root, but even the derivatives can be quite useful to guide others from generating engaging content.

I am not aware of Aarne Thompson's work. I'm looking it up right now...

Learning Software Architecture

https://matklad.github.io/2026/05/12/software-architecture.html
99•surprisetalk•1h ago•8 comments

Postmortem: TanStack NPM supply-chain compromise

https://tanstack.com/blog/npm-supply-chain-compromise-postmortem
881•varunsharma07•14h ago•360 comments

Screenshots of Old Desktop OSes

http://www.typewritten.org/Media/
239•adunk•6h ago•78 comments

Toxicity on Social Media – The Noisy Room

https://thenoisyroom.com
61•skm•3h ago•32 comments

They Live (1988) inspired Adblocker

https://github.com/davmlaw/they_live_adblocker
291•tokenburner•10h ago•91 comments

If AI writes your code, why use Python?

https://medium.com/@NMitchem/if-ai-writes-your-code-why-use-python-bf8c4ba1a055
544•indigodaddy•14h ago•593 comments

Coursera and Udemy are now one company

https://blog.coursera.org/coursera-and-udemy-are-now-one-company-creating-the-worlds-most-compreh...
22•Anon84•51m ago•3 comments

Rtwatch: Watch videos with friends using WebRTC

https://github.com/pion/rtwatch
35•nateb2022•2d ago•2 comments

UCLA discovers first stroke rehabilitation drug to repair brain damage (2025)

https://stemcell.ucla.edu/news/ucla-discovers-first-stroke-rehabilitation-drug-repair-brain-damage
361•bookofjoe•17h ago•71 comments

Claude Platform on AWS

https://claude.com/blog/claude-platform-on-aws
154•matrixhelix•10h ago•68 comments

Extremely Low Frequencies

https://computer.rip/2026-05-09-extremely-low-frequencies.html
90•pinewurst•7h ago•6 comments

Remembering Planet Source Code: Sharing Code Before GitHub Made It Easy

https://www.pietschsoft.com/post/2026/05/05/remembering-planet-source-code-sharing-code-before-gi...
23•pabs3•3d ago•3 comments

Google says criminal hackers used AI to find a major software flaw

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/11/us/politics/google-hackers-attack-ai.html
195•donohoe•22h ago•143 comments

Software Internals Book Club

https://eatonphil.com/bookclub.html
110•aragonite•9h ago•20 comments

I let AI build a tool to help me figure out what was waking me up at night

https://martin.sh/i-let-ai-build-a-tool-to-help-me-figure-out-what-was-waking-me-up-at-night/
194•showmypost•14h ago•208 comments

Optimize for change not application performance

https://www.echooff.dev/blog/developer-experience-is-a-performance-feature
11•lo1tuma•2d ago•5 comments

I hate soldering

https://user8.bearblog.dev/rant/
124•James72689•4d ago•113 comments

Music has scales / raagas. What about storytelling in movies and prestige shows?

https://arc.quanten.co/archetype
11•phaedrus044•3h ago•13 comments

Boriel BASIC

https://zxbasic.readthedocs.io/en/docs/
45•AlexeyBrin•2d ago•15 comments

Nullsoft, 1997-2004 (2004)

https://slate.com/technology/2004/11/the-death-of-the-last-maverick-tech-company.html
286•downbad_•4d ago•82 comments

Show HN: A modern Music Player Daemon based on Rockbox firmware

https://github.com/tsirysndr/rockbox-zig
91•tsiry•2d ago•19 comments

Unitree GD01: China's $537k rideable transformer robot is now in production

https://gagadget.com/en/709729-unitree-gd01-chinas-537k-rideable-transformer-robot-is-now-in-prod...
30•rguiscard•1h ago•19 comments

HDMI 2.1 Display Stream Compression (DSC) Ready for Amdgpu Linux Driver

https://www.phoronix.com/news/HDMI-2.1-DSC-AMDGPU-FRL
36•WithinReason•2h ago•4 comments

EU to crack down on TikTok, Instagram's 'addictive design' targeting kids

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/05/12/tiktok-instagram-social-media-addictive-eu-crack-down.html
5•thm•29m ago•1 comments

Library for fast mapping of Java records to native memory

https://github.com/mamba-studio/TypedMemory
149•joe_mwangi•15h ago•33 comments

Interaction Models

https://thinkingmachines.ai/blog/interaction-models/
232•smhx•14h ago•26 comments

Show HN: TikTok but for scientific papers

https://andreaturchet.github.io/website/index.html
134•ciwrl•19h ago•64 comments

GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

https://about.gitlab.com/blog/gitlab-act-2/
553•AnonGitLabEmpl•14h ago•537 comments

Yabasic (Yet Another Basic)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yabasic
8•sarreph•55m ago•0 comments

VGA Memory Access Is Complicated

https://www.os2museum.com/wp/learn-something-old-every-day-part-xxi-vga-memory-access-is-complica...
62•ingve•2d ago•7 comments