Congress Wants You to Pay $130 a Year Just to Drive an Electric Car

https://insideevs.com/news/796222/ev-fee-gas-tax-house-bill-2026/

16•01-_-•2h ago

Comments

mattbee•1h ago

Sounds like a bargain. In the UK we'll be paying £0.03 per mile from April 2028.

smt88•1h ago

This is a direct replacement for the gasoline taxes which pay for our roads, so $130 for most drivers is actually a bargain in the US too.

EVs are also much harsher on roads because of their weight.

cosmic_cheese•59m ago

The weight gap between EV and ICE is often exaggerated.

In fact, within ICE vehicles, the gap between sedans/hatchbacks/compact crossovers and giant SUVs and trucks is larger, and yet for some reason we aren’t taxing drivers of Suburbans and F-150s accordingly.

If we applied this logic fairly we should be pushing people to right-size their vehicles regardless of fuel type.

jonfw•46m ago

We are discussing a gas tax, and there is a strong correlation between gas consumption and weight, which implies more taxes for trucks and SUVs

eli•45m ago

We absolutely are doing that at the state and local level. Vehicle registration fees vary by weight and type of vehicle most places.

manwe150•56m ago

Redditors claim there is no evidence the weight is relevant to the wear rate of the roads, since weights have become comparable to a similar car and generally less than the average ICE truck, but that the superior acceleration of EV can be harsher on intersections https://www.reddit.com/r/electriccars/comments/1do2rtu/what_...

marcosdumay•13m ago

Well, that's a US-only argument.

mikestew•41m ago

so $130 for most drivers is actually a bargain in the US too.

I’d have to drive an EV about 35% more miles each year to make it to break even on tax versus our 35 mpg ICE car. It’s no bargain, it’s punishment for driving an EV.

EVs are also much harsher on roads because of their weight.

My Hyundai Ioniq 5 weighs less than the most popular vehicle in the US: the F-150. I don’t see those getting special taxes.

wil421•31m ago

The F-150 is not the most popular vehicle or even truck. The F-Series is, which includes all the bigger versions and fleet models.

How do you pay more taxes on EVs when you factor in gas taxes?

mikestew•27m ago

How do you pay more taxes on EVs when you factor in gas taxes?

Huh? Simple math?

$MILES_PER_YEAR/$200 (EV tax in WA) vs. $GALLONS_USED * $0.18 in the ICE car. I pay more in taxes to run the EV in a year than I do for equivalent miles in a 35mpg ICE. IOW, if I drove the Scion xB all the time, I’d pay less tax.

jquery•5m ago

The alternative is them checking the odometer each year on the EVs, which would be fairer, but I feel like Americans would complain that’s an invasion of their privacy or something. Or it would upset the rural voters who have disproportionate power in this country.

csomar•44m ago

That seems like a more logical system? You should be paying miles x vehicle weight since that’s what tear roads.

embedding-shape•37m ago

Does it matter if the car is electric or not so much for road tearing? I'd thought the wheels and engine capabilities would matter more, but I'm not car expert.

dd8601fn•31m ago

I think the idea is with ice vehicles you can tax the gas, which is a convenient roll-up summary of the above. But EVs sidestep all that.

pirates•28m ago

EVs on average are heavier than ICE vehicles, and road damage scales with weight very quickly, but that’s not to say EVs are out there tearing up all the roads. Semi-trucks, construction equipment, heavy machinery towing, etc all do way way more damage than passenger vehicles by a wide margin.

embedding-shape•25m ago

> EVs on average are heavier than ICE vehicles, and road damage scales with weight very quickly

So then tax based on weight if that's the differentiator of the damage done? I guess in combination with mileage would make most sense, and add in a scale based on net worth too to make it extra goodie.

brendoelfrendo•20m ago

Historically, we've taxed based on gasoline usage, which is a pretty decent proxy for both weight and distance traveled, so it ends up being a road use tax. EVs don't use gas, so we need to introduce new road use taxes specifically for them.

Where this new fee has issues is that it would charge EV owners roughly double the average amount paid by ICE owners in federal fuel tax, and wouldn't consider how much driving a given EV is actually doing.

abdullahkhalids•10m ago

I wonder if it makes more sense to just add a tax on tires. Tire wear for most vehicles should be proportional to actual weight [1] and mileage, modulo tire quality. So just slap a tax on each tire quality type and there is no need for a system to record the mileage and weight of every car.

[1] Commercial vehicle weight is strongly determined by the cargo load.

marcosdumay•15m ago

Fuel normally includes taxes that pay for roads.

Electricity doesn't, and it's not very fair to just add those taxes.

xdennis•30m ago

But how does the government know how much you drove?

missedthecue•21m ago

Odometer check during annual inspection

nephihaha•16m ago

More state discrimination against people in Scotland and rural communities...

semiquaver•54m ago

Absolutely dishonest framing. Road maintenance is funded via gas tax. Thus EV owners should have to pay a different way. They certainly use the roads, so why would this be controversial?

eli•47m ago

The headline is intentionally inflammatory, but that's pretty much what the article says.

FWIW, the gas tax also only pays a fraction of the actual cost of maintaining roads.

mikestew•46m ago

Road maintenance is funded via gas tax.

Federal gas tax is generally used for new roads, not road maintenance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highway_Trust_Fund

If you want an “honest framing”, raise the federal fuel tax to match inflation, then we’ll talk about EVs. Plain and simple, this is just a move to punish EV use.

xdennis•26m ago

> Plain and simple, this is just a move to punish EV use.

People have gotten incentives to buy EVs for a very long time now. Isn't it time they pay their fair share? Or do they plan to pay back all the subsidies?

For fairness you also take into account that EVs are more expensive so subsidizing EVs isn't just saving the planet, it's punishing the poor.

mikestew•21m ago

Or do they plan to pay back all the subsidies

Just as soon as fossil fuel companies pay back their subsidies, I’ll have a check ready to send to the U. S . Treasury.

I still find it difficult to believe people bring up EV subsidies with a straight face, like it’s the only thing the government has ever subsidized.

throwway120385•10m ago

It's a kind of crab bucket thing in the sense that people see other people getting slightly ahead on something and instead of looking for their own way to get ahead they reach up and try to pull the other person back down into the bucket.

convolvatron•26m ago

my understand was that the federal govt won't be collecting this tax. they are mandating that the states collect it, and if they refuse there is punitive language about withholding federal transportation grants.

semiquaver•23m ago

I read your link and it does not support your assertion. In fact it implies the opposite:

> […] attempts […] to suspend the federal gas tax, without which […] would have halted efforts to repair and expand the Federal highway system.

(emphasis mine)

Did you have a specific quote you intended to point to to support your claim?

baggachipz•44m ago

I already get ~fined~ charged an EV tax by my county and state. So now I get to be triple-punished for having an EV?

not_the_fda•18m ago

They should get rid of the gas tax and tax all vehicles by weight and miles driven.

nephihaha•15m ago

This would effectively attack people for living in rural areas, rather than urban sprawl because they have to travel further...

why_at•12m ago

I'm a totally biased EV owner, and I agree that it's only fair that EV owners pay for the roads they use.

But it's annoying to see the US government find a new way to discourage one of the most clear cut ways to reduce fossil fuel usage. If things were fair, we would be taxing gas for its contribution to air pollution and climate change.

We should be doing everything we can to encourage EV adoption, but the current administration is interested in doing the exact opposite. They apparently found a way to do so which gets bipartisan support.

delfinom•4m ago

Let in Chinese EVs.

Sure, Detroit which is on life support from making shitty overpriced cars would cease to exist. But EVs would take over the US in just 5 years.

iAMkenough•4m ago

How many miles of federal roads do you drive in a week?

throwforfeds•42m ago

Now do parking

heathrow83829•40m ago

flat rate taxes are never fair. It should be based on a per use basis. either have a tire tax or some other per mile use tax.

amanaplanacanal•35m ago

Switch everything to a weight-mile tax, if we want to be fair.

archontes•17m ago

Nonlinear.

I’ve built a virtual museum with nearly every operating system you can think of

I’ve joined Anthropic

Apple unveils new accessibility features

Gaussian Splat of a Strawberry

Gentoo News: Copy Fail, Dirty Frag, and Fragnesia Kernel Vulnerabilities

Google I/O

Graduates are booing pep talks on AI at college commencements

Show HN: Superlog (YC P26) – Observability that installs itself and fixes bugs

Intro to TLA+ for the LLM Era: Prompt Your Way to Victory

Hanoi’s humble beer glass and the memory of a nation

CISA Admin Leaked AWS GovCloud Keys on GitHub

I Found Ultra-Pure Quantum Crystals in an Abandoned Mine in the Atacama Desert

The last six months in LLMs in five minutes

Mini Shai-Hulud Strikes Again: 314 npm Packages Compromised

KV Sharing, MHC, and Compressed Attention

Peter Neumann has died

Show HN: I made a 3D pose maker for artists

Show HN: Haystack – Review the PRs that need human attention

An Apple (II) for Teacher

Gemini 3.5: frontier intelligence with action

OpenBSD 7.9

Polypad

Google IO 26 Keynote

Cursor Introduces Composer 2.5

Kv4p HT – A homebrew 1W radio (VHF or UHF) that plugs into an Android phone

Nim-Presto – REST API Framework for Nim Language

Click (2016)

Photo GIMP – A Patch for GIMP 3 for Photoshop Users

Anthropic acquires Stainless

1024000^2 Blocks, 2B2T Minecraft Server World Download Project, and Discoveries