frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

'VPNs are lawful technical tools,' says EU Court in landmark copyright ruling

https://www.techradar.com/vpn/vpn-privacy-security/vpns-are-lawful-technical-tools-says-eu-court-in-landmark-anne-frank-copyright-ruling
112•healsdata•1h ago

Comments

sebastiennight•44m ago
For those who (like me) missed the essential key word in the OP's title:

This ruling is about copyright, and seems mostly unrelated to recent conversations about escaping censorship and surveilance, and the overall final throes of the open web.

It's still pretty important since the lawsuit filed by the Anne Frank Fonds could be caricatured as "if this content is illegal in our country, it should not be on the Internet in other countries, because our citizens can still circumvent the publisher's geofence and access it" which would have wild consequences if that line of thought was applied.

But, still:

> At its core, the case forced Europe's top judges to answer a highly technical question: if a publisher actively tries to block visitors from a specific country, are they still breaking the law if a user sneaks past the digital border using circumvention software?

> According to the CJEU, the answer is no.

Could be conceived to have a tenuous link to the current debate on censorship, surveilance, etc.

petcat•16m ago
Somewhat related to this same debate on censorship:

French regulators order block of Polymarket's website [0]

> The French gambling regulator said the site's continued availability constituted advertising. A ban on financial transactions to the site was already in place.

After failing to compel Polymarket to geoblock France, it's crazy that French "regulators" can just order ISPs to block a website without any judicial review just because the mere existence of it on the internet constitutes "advertising" to French people.

It seems like the EU in general is struggling badly with how to control internet access. Whether it's blocking VPNs, requiring access to private chats, or just blocking websites completely.

[0] https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/07/17/france-b...

ryandrake•30m ago
The irony of trying to block content/visitors based on country, while publishing on a platform called the "World Wide" web. IP address blocks that roughly correspond with geographic regions is kind of a design flaw.
skinfaxi•22m ago
Is it a design or implementation flaw?
embedding-shape•19m ago
That's what happens when you have idealistic nerds implementing a vision of what they want , rather than the typical software that is designed and built almost like an representation of the organization that built it, i.e Conway's Law.
Havoc•29m ago
Now watch the octogenarian UK lawmakers outlaw them anyway...right after they print the proposed law out because they don't do so well with computer stuff
EmbarrassedHelp•28m ago
Hopefully this ruling adds to some precedent in favour of VPNs to future court battles attacking VPNs for circumventing age verification.
shevy-java•21m ago
Well, the EU courts will just follow suit the moment the legislation is changed. Today France did so - young people are disallowed from accessing antisocial media. The next step will be verification. Any parent not sniffing on their children will be put in jail. King Macron decreed this today. (He is such a small man though - all the small french, such as Napoleon, have a compensation-problem with regards to their rather insignificant height.)

Here is a copy/pasteable snippet for lazy lobbyists so someone pass this to the lobby-judges at the EU courts:

"In light of recent changes to legislation and the deadly effect of social media on babies and unborn ones, VPNs are agents of terrorism, attempting to circumvent healthy restrictions pertaining to protecting such young folk from the vile dangers of antisocial media consumption. Anyone attempting to browse the web for information without presenting a valid unique ID including biometric data is guilty of terrorism, facing a minimum penalty of 25 years and 1.000.000€ fine."

This fight is, by the way, not just against VPNs. Age sniffing has never ever only been about children or VPNs. Some people still think it is about "protecting children". It's interesting.

ChrisArchitect•25m ago
EU posts about it:

Copyright in the European Union and geo-blocking: a work that is in the public domain can be published online free of charge in a Member State even if it remains protected in another Member State

https://curia.europa.eu/site/upload/docs/application/pdf/202...

Other blog post:

CJEU clarifies when geo-blocking limits online copyright liability

https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-eve...

shevy-java•24m ago
That's good, but the lobbyists in the EU will continue to try to destroy VPN. The "we must protect children" is the ruse they are using right now. Everyone will have a unique ID in the future, otherwise you will be unable to browse (at the least for commercial systems such as Microsoft-based computer systems; I can not yet predict how it will work for Linux but systemd already has that field for your age: https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/40954 - Poettering forbid further discussion about that issue too)
merb•18m ago
Btw this also could come with negative consequences, like that they want to force id checks to access copyrighted material
kps•17m ago
Without robust copyright protection, what will incentivize Anne Frank to write more diary entries?
Retric•13m ago
People do care about income streams for their descendants or charitable organizations etc. So it’s not completely ineffective.

What’s broken is extending copyright after a work was already created. But that’s true even if the creator was still alive.

OpenAI and Hugging Face partner to address security incident

https://openai.com/index/hugging-face-model-evaluation-security-incident/
183•mfiguiere•52m ago•78 comments

FreeInk: Open ecosystem for e-readers

https://freeink.org/
225•FriedPickles•2h ago•52 comments

Gemini 3.6 Flash, 3.5 Flash-Lite, and 3.5 Flash Cyber

https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/models-and-research/gemini-models/gemini-3-6-flash-3-5-flas...
509•logickkk1•5h ago•400 comments

Long presumed dead, a thriving coral reef is discovered in West Africa

https://e360.yale.edu/digest/benin-coral-reef
240•speckx•5h ago•40 comments

Jack Dorsey launches Buzz to combine team chat, AI agents and Git hosting

https://runtimewire.com/article/jack-dorsey-block-buzz-team-chat-ai-agents-git
142•ryanmerket•3h ago•131 comments

'VPNs are lawful technical tools,' says EU Court in landmark copyright ruling

https://www.techradar.com/vpn/vpn-privacy-security/vpns-are-lawful-technical-tools-says-eu-court-...
126•healsdata•1h ago•14 comments

Apple defeats liability for not scanning iCloud for CSAM

https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2026/07/apple-defeats-liability-for-not-scanning-icloud-for...
262•speckx•6h ago•226 comments

Apple Private Cloud Compute SoC 3 audit reports

https://support.apple.com/guide/certifications/apple-private-cloud-compute-soc-3-audit-apc95a31b9...
58•throwfaraway4•3h ago•14 comments

Qwen-Image-3.0: Rich Content, Authentic Details, Deep Knowledge

https://qwen.ai/blog?id=qwen-image-3.0
509•ilreb•12h ago•206 comments

PCjs Machines

https://www.pcjs.org/
160•naves•7h ago•18 comments

Laguna S 2.1

https://poolside.ai/blog/introducing-laguna-s-2-1
115•rexledesma•3h ago•26 comments

Meta's AI models are powering the first wave of Genesis Mission projects

https://ai.meta.com/blog/genesis-mission-lawrence-berkeley-national-laboratory-segment-anything-d...
73•surprisetalk•3h ago•49 comments

France's Anssi Will Block PQC-Free Products from Certification Starting 2027

https://postquantum.com/security-pqc/anssi-pqc-certification-2027/
72•Sami_Lehtinen•5h ago•32 comments

Bloomy (YC S26) is hiring a founding engineer

1•alexsouthmayd•4h ago

Show HN: A self-running space economy SIM in Rust and Bevy

https://github.com/Kalcode/spaceprojectsim
46•kalcode•2h ago•13 comments

Advertise in ChatGPT

https://ads.openai.com/
192•montecarl•2h ago•198 comments

Slater – Low-memory graphdb designed for read-heavy graphs

https://github.com/Hikari-Systems/slater
17•rickkjp•2h ago•7 comments

Apple has decided to compete for creativity app users

https://alex4d.com/notes/item/apple-competing-for-creativity-app-users
60•speckx•2h ago•40 comments

Show HN: Justif – Knuth-Plass justification and microtypography for the web

https://justif.lyall.co/
12•lyall•4d ago•2 comments

My USB Drive Has a Hidden Encrypted Vault

https://rootkitlabs.com/2026/06/22/I%27m-Building-a-Secure-USB-Drive/
109•machinehum•1d ago•68 comments

Show HN: Read the Tape – Wordle for daytrading, five blind S&P 500 charts a day

https://readthetape.cc/
9•will_asouka•1d ago•4 comments

Mickey Mouse Sells a Bundle

https://www.marginpoints.com/essays/mickey-mouse-sells-a-bundle-hn
4•historian1066•14m ago•0 comments

The unreasonable difficulty of time series forecasting

https://suzyahyah.github.io/machine%20learning/2026/06/27/trouble-with-time-series.html
90•suzyahyah•3d ago•31 comments

The Price of Happiness (2024)

https://happiness-science.org/price-of-happiness/
25•andyjohnson0•2h ago•8 comments

The World's 2,400 Castles

https://thecastlemap.com/
140•marklit•4h ago•102 comments

AI Agent – TRMNL

https://help.trmnl.com/en/articles/14130438-ai-agent
22•joeyespo•2h ago•14 comments

Show HN: CodeAlmanac – Karpathy-style codebase wiki from your conversations

https://github.com/AlmanacCode/codealmanac/
28•divitsheth•3h ago•12 comments

Greedy is optimal for single-pass semi-streaming matching

https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.14656
14•MarcoDewey•3h ago•0 comments

Cheap self-hosted Kubernetes on Hetzner cloud (2025)

https://blog.qstars.nl/posts/cheap-self-hosted-kubernetes-on-hetzner-cloud/
50•victorbrink•2h ago•26 comments

Uhubctl – control USB power per-port on smart USB hubs

https://github.com/mvp/uhubctl
32•gregsadetsky•3h ago•12 comments