Ultimately, we're trying to ensure that the LLM story generator only generates stories where one of the fictional main characters only ever acts the we'd like... which could be much harder.
but its still roleplaying and the role is an abstraction we cant measure. its the negative space.
its basically: we can define its role but it constructs its environment from the role. the same way a child role plays as a caregiver, the LLM does the same.
its like All the things Havard taught you (finite) vs All the things Havard doesnt teach you (infinite).
the LLM is in the infinite negative space. we call it role play.
... or words to that effect. Can't be arsed to dig out a search engine and will rely on seriously addled brain.
- evals
- limiting AIs to tool calling, bounded planning, interpreting/producing natural language.
- bounding non determinism
- investing in small tools/security (If something shouldn't happen, then it shouldn't not be possible, RBAC style).
They can be good enough for a massive amount of contexts.
orionblastar•1h ago
colechristensen•44m ago
TZubiri•36m ago
But the usefulness of LLMs comes from following what you say. An LLM that follows your lead when you say "The answer to the collatz conjecture is" is much more useful than one that answers "not known and if you think you know it you are wrong."
Reminds me of the tip about working with lawyers, if you ask them whether you can do something, the answer will often be no. However if you ask them how you can do something, they tend to give you more advice on how to do it.
teravor•14m ago
this also holds for cybersecurity, if you don't let the model go online you can carefully construct a scenario where it believes you inserted a vulnerability into a project for it to find.
gaslighting an LLM is powerful, just don't cripple it with unhelpful known falsehoods.
add-sub-mul-div•40m ago
forinti•25m ago
I guess AI is a new form of alienation and also a new light on the lunacy of bureaucracy.
jay_kyburz•19m ago
I occasional test it out and suggest something dumb and it will tell me that its a dumb idea.
I also always ask AI to speak to me as if it were an Australian bogan and it has no problem telling me my code looks like a dogs breakfast or that ive lost the plot. Keeps me grounded.
sodapopcan•6m ago