frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Linear Programming for Fun and Profit

https://modal.com/blog/resource-solver
62•hmac1282•1y ago

Comments

ayhanfuat•1y ago
> X = [x1, ..., Xn]: instances of each type to launch

Is this a continuous variable? Seems discrete to me. I am surprised it is solved by simplex.

Frummy•1y ago
It's the answer, a vector of integers
ayhanfuat•1y ago
Simplex cannot give a vector of integers though, unless the constraint matrix is unimodular. Maybe the integrality constraint was relaxed.
cweld510•1y ago
You're right -- we do relax the integrality constraint, gaining performance at the expense of some precision, and we're generally able to paper over the difference at scheduling time. We've investigated integer linear programming for some use cases, but for solves to run quickly, we have to constrain the inputs significantly.
ayhanfuat•1y ago
Thanks for the clarification. I guess it wouldn’t matter much if the numbers are large. Initially I thought they were mostly ones and zeros.
stncls•1y ago
If this is business critical for you, you may want to switch to a faster solver. Glop is very nice, but it would be reasonable to expect a commercial solver (Gurobi, XPress, COpt) to be 60x faster [1]. By the same measure, the best open source solvers (CLP, HiGHS) are 2-3x faster than Glop.

Actually, the commercial solvers are so fast that I would not be surprised if they solved the IP problem as fast as Glop solves the LP. (Yes, the theory says it is impossible, but in practice it happens.) The cost of a commercial solver is 10k to 50k per license.

[1] ... this 60x number has very high variance depending on the type of problem, but it is not taken out of nowhere, it comes from the Mittelmann LP benchmarks https://plato.asu.edu/ftp/lpopt.html There are also benchmarks for other types of problems, including IP, see the whole list here: https://plato.asu.edu/bench.html

petters•1y ago
If you are able to paper over the fractional numbers and get a usable solution, an integer solver should also be able to find a feasible solution easily. Perhaps not optimal, but better than just solving the LP and rounding
hustwindmaple1•1y ago
You are basically doing a heurstic. Your solutions are not guaranteed to be optimal. Integer programming is the way to do.
cweld510•1y ago
Great to see this post here -- really enjoyed writing it! I think it's really cool how an algorithm from an operational research context can play a critical role in a high-availability large-scale cloud service.
sumtechguy•1y ago
LP is a shockingly good way to optimize a system. If you can put inputs/outputs into the correct form. Had an econ prof that loved these things for doing supply/demand maxima and minimum finding. He didnt outright say it but I think it was his current line of study when I was taking classes from him the 90s. I thought that, as he managed to bring it up in every class he taught.
Onavo•1y ago
Well, kantorovich did win the Nobel for inventing that.
underanalyzer•1y ago
Neat article. I do wish it mentioned that there are polynomial time algorithms to solve linear programming problems. According to the Google ortools docs it has the option to use those as well (but not with the GLOP solver). Might be good for when simplex is struggling (https://developers.google.com/optimization/lp/lp_advanced)
stncls•1y ago
You're right, but it's very subtle and complicated.

In theory, the simplex method is not known to be polynomial-time, and it is likely that indeed it is not. Some variants of the simplex method have been proven to take exponential time in some worst cases (Klee-Minty cubes). What solvers implement could be said to be one such variant ("steepest-edge pricing"), but because solvers have tons of heuristics and engineering, and also because they work in floating-point arithmetic... it's difficult to tell for sure.

In practice, the main alternative is interior-point (aka. barrier) methods which, contrary to the simplex method, are polynomial-time in theory. They are usually (but not always) faster, and their advantage tends to increase for larger instances. The problem is that they are converging numerical algorithms, and with floating-point arithmetic they never quite 100% converge. By contrast, the simplex method is a combinatorial algorithm, and the numerical errors it faces should not accumulate. As a result, good solvers perform "crossover" after interior-point methods, to get a numerically clean optimal solution. Crossover is a combinatorial algorithm, like the simplex method. Unlike the simplex method though, crossover is polynomial-time in theory (strongly so, even). However, here, theory and practice diverge a bit, and crossover implementations are essentially simplified simplex methods. As a result, in my opinion, calling iterior-point + crossover polynomial-time would be a stretch.

Still, for large problems, we can expect iterior-point + crossover to be faster than the simplex method, by a factor 2x to 10x.

There is also first-order methods, which are getting much attention lately. However, in my experience, you should only use that if you are willing to tolerate huge constraint violations in the solution, and wildly suboptimal solutions. Their main use case is when other solvers need too much RAM to solve your instance.

Onavo•1y ago
The most interesting question is how you scrape the prices. The cloudprovider really need to provide an API.
underanalyzer•1y ago
Very interesting! Thanks for the reply. I wonder if they tried these other solvers and decided they were either too slow b/c their problems were too small or the answers were too inaccurate

Payments Canada announces launch of Canada's Real-Time Rail (RTR) payment system

https://www.payments.ca/canada-launches-real-time-rail-bringing-247-payment-infrastructure-nation...
374•ocd•4h ago•202 comments

Claude Fable 5.2 and Mythos 5.2

https://www.anthropic.com/claude-fable-and-mythos-5-2
566•meetpateltech•1h ago•273 comments

USPS now offers official ZIP Code boundary polygons

https://postalpro.usps.com/zcb
37•munro•39m ago•17 comments

Our Smallest, Most Efficient Model: Muse Ember

https://research.meta.ai/blog/muse-ember
144•dvaplima•2h ago•62 comments

CUI – Native UI components for C

https://yappologistic.github.io/CUI/
48•hilti•1h ago•11 comments

E-means: 10x faster k-means at equal loss

https://e-means.github.io/
75•porridgeraisin•1h ago•3 comments

Infineon marks innovation milestone with 300mm power silicon carbide wafer

https://www.infineon.com/press-release/2026/infpr202611-028
52•sshah03•2h ago•19 comments

DeepX claims inference up to 100B parameters at less than 5 W

https://www.eetimes.com/deepx-tapes-out-second-gen-chip-projects-6-7x-performance-gain-with-lpddr...
82•giuliomagnifico•2h ago•9 comments

Fold Epic Paper Airplanes

https://www.foldableflight.com
697•vismit2000•8h ago•124 comments

Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick yet

https://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/2026/10/magenta-solar-panels-may-be-agrivoltaics-cleverest-t...
184•speckx•6h ago•100 comments

Show HN: MeowDisplay Is iPhone Mirroring, but in Reverse

https://meowdisplay.app/
42•raiseCatError•1h ago•15 comments

Show HN: Every satellite that passed over any place this week, and its photos

https://www.watched.earth
83•a585gupt•2h ago•19 comments

Y/N (YC S23) is hiring a growth lead to distribute superhuman A.I. storytelling

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/yn/jobs/TjDn3YZ-founding-growth-marketer
1•gabrielbirnbaum•3h ago

A primer on GPUs and kernel optimization

https://www.nabo.dev/blogs/kernel-primer
29•nomi_uw•3d ago•0 comments

On Being an Engineer in 2026

https://twitter.com/shaharglazner/status/2119796029256032278
27•talboren•5h ago•17 comments

Is Opus 5.5 nerfed? Thinking patterns changed on November 3

https://twitter.com/shanemelaugh/status/2119192075505893695
589•rzk•13h ago•408 comments

November 2026 Claude Fable 5.2 Scores 65 on Artificial Analysis, Highest So Far

https://artificialanalysis.ai/models/claude-fable-5-2
5•theanonymousone•33m ago•0 comments

Deuterium's Impact on OLED Displays (2024)

https://www.oled-info.com/deuteriums-impact-oled-displays
10•zeristor•1d ago•4 comments

Show HN: DBDelve – Open-Source DB Client Made with Rust and GPUI

66•shayan_abbas•4h ago•22 comments

What is malloc doing, anyway?

https://benmandrew.com/articles/what-is-malloc-doing-anyway
180•benmandrew•9h ago•41 comments

When will this stop? The Raspberry Pi 5 16GB SBC now sells for $385

https://www.cnx-software.com/2026/11/03/when-will-this-stop-the-raspberry-pi-5-16gb-sbc-now-sells...
197•pera•2h ago•164 comments

Iran was behind cyber-attack on French supermarket freezers, Paris says

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/09/france-blames-irans-revolutionary-guards-for-cyber-...
35•disenchanted•1h ago•24 comments

Show HN: Recalc – Spreadsheet where cells can be Claude Code or Codex terminals

https://github.com/sshah03/recalc
13•sshah03•1d ago•1 comments

Too many men suffering in silence, national health report finds (Canada)

https://www.westcentralonline.com/articles/too-many-men-suffering-in-silence-national-health-repo...
277•nosecreek•2h ago•309 comments

Pigshell: Unix the Web

http://pigshell.com/v/0.6.4/
46•pbohun•5h ago•16 comments

Zebkit – Chromium as an embeddable library

https://github.com/ikey4u/zebkit
100•Riiiiichard•6h ago•36 comments

Going back two years on Hacker News is like entering another, better universe

https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2024-11-08
223•EmX_3000•3h ago•134 comments

Cryptocurrency lawsuit: Ethereum Foundation required "suicide pledge"

https://www.denverpost.com/2026/11/06/ethereum-suicide-pledge-lawsuit-mandate-boulder-crypto/
142•ceejayoz•5h ago•145 comments

Google Gemini routes personal Drive files and emails to human annotators

https://github.com/thisisme6598/gemini_files/
18•gf74918•2h ago•4 comments

Try Gleam

https://nchagnet.eu/blog/you-should-try-gleam
97•nchagnet•8h ago•100 comments