frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Qt Group Buys IAR Systems Group

https://www.qt.io/stock/qt-completes-the-recommended-public-cash-offer-to-the-shareholders-of-iar-systems-group-1760351460000-3668995
43•shrimp-chimp•6h ago

Comments

joezydeco•2h ago
Two companies with horrendous licensing methods and prices. They'll do great together.
rrgok•2h ago
Everytime a QT post comes someone bitch about the licensing model. And every time I google and try understand what is wrong with the licensing model. And everytime I end up confused about it.

Could you kindly ELI5 me what is wrong with QT licensing model?

joezydeco•2h ago
If you get confused by it then that's all that needs to be said. The rest has been discussed over and over. I've dropped Qt for other front-end tech and I'm happier now.
CoastalCoder•1h ago
I'm curious what you settled on and why. Care to elaborate?
markfeathers•2h ago
From my perspective they spread FUD about open source licensing. QT core is LGPL3. Many applications would be fine with using LGPL3 in commercial applications. Read QT's landing page on licensing, and fossa has a good block post on requirements.

https://www.qt.io/qt-licensing

https://fossa.com/blog/open-source-software-licenses-101-lgp...

>And everytime I end up confused about it.

I think this is the point. If you're making a real application you may pay for the licensing to avoid the uncertainty/risk.

michaelsbradley•2h ago
It’s LGPL mostly, with some non-core libraries that are GPL or use other licenses:

https://doc.qt.io/qt-6/licensing.html

Over the years it has been noted by many that Qt’s wording and warnings about the LGPL amount to spreading FUD or outright misinformation in what seems like an attempt to scare managers and C-suite folks into buying commercial licenses “just in case”.

bradfa•1h ago
Qt (the company) releases MOST of their code under open source licenses, but not all. Qt4 was LGPLv2.1, Qt5 and beyond are under LGPLv3.

In every major Qt release, there's a handful of super useful but kind of niche widgets which aren't released under open source licenses, presumably as a sales tactic as buying licenses gets you these widgets and sometimes that is cheaper than building them yourself, but unless you need these, you probably don't care about this.

Although my experience attempting to buy licenses from Qt is about a decade out of date now, the way it roughly worked was you paid a per-seat-per-year fee to get a developer license or build-machine license. Then you bought bundles of deployment licenses, and the bigger the bundle then the lower the cost per license. If you are buying a bundle of a few thousand devices then you pay more per license than if you're buying a bundle of a few million. Either way, it is a significant chunk of cash you have to front to get your block of licenses and normally embedded projects are EXTREMELY sensitive to per-unit costs.

seba_dos1•1h ago
Nothing's wrong with their licensing model, but they've been known for misrepresenting their licensing model in order to steer people towards their commercial offerings.
bobmcnamara•1h ago
> And every time I google and try understand what is wrong with the licensing model. And everytime I end up confused about it. Could you kindly ELI5 me what is wrong with QT licensing model?

This right here! We customers and users alike are often confused by QTs piecemeal licensing model.

freedomben•1h ago
I could be misunderstanding, but my read of the GP is that they aren't confused about the licensing model, they're confused by the hate for it
linhns•1h ago
Because it’s unclear and incomplete. Always prone to some KDE whims.
vintagedave•2h ago
I'm familiar with the normal MSVC/Clang/GCC/EDG C++ compilers, but not IAR's. They seem to make C++ compilers for embedded systems. Does anyone know if these are their own, or based on something like Clang?

Their supported standards list 'libc++' [1] which implies LLVM and potentially Clang. I could not find info online.

"IAR Embedded Workbench C++ is dialectal and contains some features not part of standard C++." [2] Their extensions seem to be to relax some awkward syntax, and for embedded systems support such as memory positioning (?)

Qt is huge in the embedded space, such as automotive, where I see IAR is as well. Makes sense as an acquisition. I used to work as the C++Builder product manager, which has custom C++ language extensions, and I always personally (not a statement from my prior employer in any way) wondered if Qt might someday look to that toolchain too -- it does not target embedded computing, but it has excellent expertise in custom compiler changes including extensions to address exactly the same problems (as I understand) that Moc tries to solve. In general especially with the state of the C++ committee, and Qt dealing with some custom handling, I would expect owning a compiler toolchain with a willingness to customise the language to be highly beneficial for them.

[1] https://www.iar.com/embedded-development-tools/iar-embedded-...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAR_Systems#IAR_Embedded_Workb...

thadt•2h ago
It's been a few years since I've slung code with it, but I'm pretty sure IAR had their own compiler (along with it's own special occasional bugs). Of the IDE's I've used, it wasn't that bad. But QT Creator was better. Bringing together IAR's tech and reach with QT's expertise does make a lot of sense.
Palomides•2h ago
I'm not sure there's much overlap in use cases, considering the two very separate classes of 'embedded'; Qt is used on Linux capable devices and IAR is MCUs

why would Qt want to customize a compiler when they still need to support llvm/gcc/msvc?

ndiddy•40m ago
There's a class of high-spec microcontrollers that have a ton of RAM and flash and built-in support for stuff like touchscreens. It looks like Qt is able to run on these: https://www.qt.io/platform/develop-software-microcontrollers... . I'm not sure how much of their business is people targeting bare-metal microcontrollers, but there is at least some overlap.
bobmcnamara•1h ago
IAR has their own backend and I believe front-end as well.

They routinely smoked GCC and Clang, and sometimes ARMs tools on a variety of tasks.

I'm not sure I see the advantage on Qt owning a compiler though - one of Qt's strengths is portability.

bluGill•40m ago
The advatage might be they can ensure the compiler supports the new features qt wants to use.

reflection could replace moc, (likely c++29 needed) but if compilers don't implement that part of reflection qt can't use it. If qt can get compilers updated that helps them.

maleldil•27m ago
Relevant link regarding Qt moc and reflection https://wiki.qt.io/C%2B%2B_reflection_(P2996)_and_moc
p0w3n3d•2h ago
I have a C++ seasoned colleague who says that It framework went behind the current C++ standard, however I remember Qt Framework much cleaner than C++ itself (by making a sort of a enhanced subset), and would prefer use it. What are your opinions?
freedomben•1h ago
Take this with a grain of salt because it's been about 10 years since I slung serious C++. Just my opinion of course, but if you go all-in with the Qt libraries, it's a lot better (and safer). Most people only think about Qt as a GUI framework, but it's much, much more than that. It's a very rich set of libraries that do way more than just UI. We actually used Qt for our server too!

So I agree with you, Qt tends to be a lot cleaner than standard C++ (or even C++ with Boost). I highly value consistency in a codebase, and Qt really makes that possible.

bluGill•38m ago
Modern c++ does some things better than qt, others it is still worse. Just unique ptr is better than qt's parent-child object model (memory management only, parent child is useful for other things)
rurban•1h ago
I once tried to get a IAR C++ embedded codebase to compile with g++ and it's stdlib on a very small chip. It eventually compiled but never worked. I'll have to rewrite it in C instead.

There were many hacks, like filling the stack with sentinels to detect it at run-time. The linker script was horrible. Rewrote everything from scratch. The resulting code was many KB too large for the available space, it would have needed to slim down the stdlib. Even with the much better optimizations and LTO it was still too big.

Nice for that time, but essentially unusable. The company needed 10 years for that code, my plan is to rewrite it in 2 weeks.

ndiddy•6m ago
If IAR was able to make the existing C++ codebase fit in the chip's flash and GCC wasn't, that seems like a win for IAR. If you're selling products in volume, the cost of the IAR license is dwarfed by the amount of money you save by using a part with less flash.

BERT Is Just a Single Text Diffusion Step

https://nathan.rs/posts/roberta-diffusion/
231•nathan-barry•3h ago•49 comments

Production RAG: what I learned from processing 5M+ documents

https://blog.abdellatif.io/production-rag-processing-5m-documents
125•tifa2up•2h ago•37 comments

Why a 'Boring' Life Might Be the Happiest One

https://karunpal.substack.com/p/why-a-boring-life-might-be-the-happiest
26•articsputnik•35m ago•1 comments

AWS Multiple Services Down in us-east-1

https://health.aws.amazon.com/health/status?ts=20251020
1061•kondro•10h ago•1474 comments

TernFS – an exabyte scale, multi-region distributed filesystem

https://www.xtxmarkets.com/tech/2025-ternfs/#posix-shaped
21•kirlev•43m ago•1 comments

Alibaba Cloud says it cut Nvidia AI GPU use by 82% with new pooling system

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/semiconductors/alibaba-says-new-pooling-system-cut-nvi...
178•hd4•5h ago•128 comments

Space Elevator

https://neal.fun/space-elevator/
1208•kaonwarb•13h ago•264 comments

DeepSeek OCR

https://github.com/deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR
745•pierre•11h ago•195 comments

Optical diffraction patterns made with a MOPA laser engraving machine [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsGHr7dXLuI
48•emsign•6d ago•3 comments

How to stop Linux threads cleanly

https://mazzo.li/posts/stopping-linux-threads.html
89•signa11•5d ago•30 comments

AWS outage shows internet users 'at mercy' of too few providers, experts say

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/oct/20/amazon-web-services-aws-outage-hits-dozens-web...
62•evolve2k•46m ago•23 comments

Dutch spy services have restricted intelligence-sharing with the United States

https://intelnews.org/2025/10/20/01-3416/
57•Refreeze5224•53m ago•10 comments

Servo v0.0.1

https://github.com/servo/servo
329•undeveloper•5h ago•94 comments

Docker Systems Status: Full Service Disruption

https://www.dockerstatus.com/pages/incident/533c6539221ae15e3f000031/68f5e1c741c825463df7486c
289•l2dy•10h ago•115 comments

Entire Linux Network stack diagram (2024)

https://zenodo.org/records/14179366
500•hhutw•14h ago•41 comments

Chess grandmaster Daniel Naroditsky has passed away

https://old.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/1obnbmu/grandmaster_daniel_naroditsky_has_passed_away/
43•ntnbr•54m ago•12 comments

Show HN: Playwright Skill for Claude Code – Less context than playwright-MCP

https://github.com/lackeyjb/playwright-skill
91•syntax-sherlock•6h ago•33 comments

Modeling Others' Minds as Code

https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.01272
44•PaulHoule•4h ago•36 comments

Qt Group Buys IAR Systems Group

https://www.qt.io/stock/qt-completes-the-recommended-public-cash-offer-to-the-shareholders-of-iar...
43•shrimp-chimp•6h ago•23 comments

Pointer Pointer (2012)

https://pointerpointer.com
200•surprisetalk•1w ago•24 comments

Automate all the things with Swift Subprocess

https://blog.jacobstechtavern.com/p/swift-subprocess
10•jakey_bakey•1w ago•1 comments

The Peach meme: On CRTs, pixels and signal quality (again)

https://www.datagubbe.se/crt2/
56•zdw•1w ago•21 comments

Matrix Conference 2025 Highlights

https://element.io/blog/the-matrix-conference-a-seminal-moment-for-matrix/
113•Arathorn•6h ago•76 comments

Fractal Imaginary Cubes

https://www.i.h.kyoto-u.ac.jp/users/tsuiki/icube/fractal/index-e.html
46•strstr•1w ago•3 comments

Introduction to reverse-engineering vintage synth firmware

https://ajxs.me/blog/Introduction_to_Reverse-Engineering_Vintage_Synth_Firmware.html
168•jmillikin•15h ago•23 comments

Optimizing writes to OLAP using buffers (ClickHouse, Redpanda, MooseStack)

https://www.fiveonefour.com/blog/optimizing-writes-to-olap-using-buffers
26•oatsandsugar•5d ago•9 comments

Gleam OTP – Fault Tolerant Multicore Programs with Actors

https://github.com/gleam-lang/otp
175•TheWiggles•19h ago•79 comments

How to Enter a City Like a King

https://worldhistory.substack.com/p/how-to-enter-a-city-like-a-king
67•crescit_eundo•1w ago•62 comments

Intel fabs misusing J1 Visas

https://old.reddit.com/r/Semiconductors/comments/1ob8igx/i_work_at_an_intel_fab_as_an_engineer_an...
22•kappi•1h ago•8 comments

Commodore 64 Ultimate

https://www.commodore.net/product-page/commodore-64-ultimate-basic-beige-batch1
103•guerrilla•3h ago•49 comments