frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

From MIT: AI financial advice is surprisingly good

https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/ai-financial-advice-surprisingly-good-especially-if-you-ask-right-questions
47•foxtrot8672•1h ago

Comments

tehlike•57m ago
In a similar fashion, it will tell you to stay away from many different ways of portfolio construction where you take on smarter risk with diversification.

It will tell you something like TQQQ is not a good long term hold, when it can be perfectly fine especially if you mix in with 60-20-20 with TQQQ-GDE-ZROZ, and DCA and annually rebalance.

AI will tell you "common" things people say, not necessarily smarter things that may be more suitable for you. This is not a bad thing, you just need to know better than to listen everything as a gospel.

joshuamorton•32m ago
> It will tell you something like TQQQ is not a good long term hold, when it can be perfectly fine especially if you mix in with 60-20-20 with TQQQ-GDE-ZROZ, and DCA and annually rebalance.

As someone who long-term-holds TQQQ (I am lazy) it is pretty much true that holding TQQQ doesn't make sense. It is basically unambiguously better (ie. the risk-adjusted returns are higher) to directly hold options that construct the same amount of leverage over the time period you want to be leveraged over.

tehlike•24m ago
> I am lazy > directly hold options that construct the same amount of leverage

A lazy guy on hackernews, with knowledge on TQQQ, options.

You are making my case.

Holding TQQQ vs doing with options are different in many ways. You will get a tax drag that you need to be mindful of.

You are also not saying something that goes against what I said. The reason LLM says TQQQ is not a good long term hold is because it can go to zero or near zero due to leverage - which is "technically" true. You are saying something else.

I am also lazy.

drivebyhooting•7m ago
Look up “nonconvexity”. TQQQ during draw down will kill your gains.
clickety_clack•54m ago
Half the title is missing, and the missing half is doing some heavy lifting: “– especially if you ask the right questions”
dmix•52m ago
I use YNAB (https://www.ynab.com/) for budgeting so I already had all of my financial data in a single source. Exporting the CSVs locally and asking Claude to be my financial advisor legitimately gave me good advice. Not just nagging me to save more (which is always useful), but how to organize my budget categories better, detecting longer term spending patterns I wasn't thinking much about, researching credit card reward programs based on my spending patterns, digging deep into interest and tax rates in way I never bothered etc.

That was the first time I felt like real people's jobs were threatened by AI. Financial advisors and tax accountants better adapt quickly.

mschild•28m ago
> Financial advisors and tax accountants

Financial advisors giving generic advice, sure. Tax accountants though? I'd be careful. I know the mistakes that llms make when complexity gets involved (especially tax codes and laws) and frankly I don't know enough about them to be able to verify whether what I'm getting out of it makes sense. I could probably verify it with enough research but then I just could so it myself anyway. Or I just pay an accountant a smallish fee and let them handle it.

daf72•19m ago
Nice idea! Do you mind sharing the prompt you used, interested in trying this out myself.
Terr_•10m ago
I've fallen behind in using it, but for self-hostable stuff, consider: https://actualbudget.org/
wisty•46m ago
Until you ask it to juatify your poor decisions, I bet.
tomsto•41m ago
Human financial advice is surprisingly bad.
ElProlactin•33m ago
Because so much of it is self-interested. People pushing products that they get paid to push.
paulpauper•40m ago
AI financial advice encourages people to save more, diversify their investing, and take on less risk as they age.

sounds like pretty generic advice. I thought they meant it gives good stock picks or trading strategies. That would be noteworthy. This is just "meh".

QwenGlazer9000•35m ago
Not just Generic. Any of the finance guys on YouTube that aren't grifters will say this. Post-train on a single one of them and boom AI is a financial guru.
fn-mote•25m ago
> I thought they meant it gives good stock picks or trading strategies

Sadly, Gemini Flash fails to demolish individual stock picking as a strategy.

Its response included a very lukewarm note picking the few winners is hard, but no further warnings about just how hard (essentially impossible).

Thinking mode didn’t produce any better caveats.

I guess I’ll read the article, but this doesn’t sound like advice that is going to put financial planners out of business.

ashu1461•5m ago
It is mentioned in the article that without context, it does give generic fail safe advice, but as the prompts get better it would also lead you to the right direction.
Mikejames•30m ago
i copied the page into claude and added

i want to create a Financial advisor agent.md / i can use for a system prompt in a claude project or as a a agent in a wider financial research workflow

by looking at this paper and access to the internet identify ways to address the points that are identified where ai is good and bad at and improve on those areas and ultimately provide a comprehensive financial advisor agent

in research mode - let’s see how it goes!

jbs789•28m ago
The hard part is behavioural/emotional/psychological rather than technical.

Usually discussions about money are never actually about money, but rather safety, fear, etc.

That’s where a real advisor earns their keep. Understanding the client and instilling confidence/comfort.

jmyeet•24m ago
Financial advice for most people is incredibly straightforward and it can be summed up as: cut expenses and invest conservatively.

Cutting expenses is the absolutely best thing you can do because it gives you more money to save AND reduces how much money you need to survive in retirement. Drive a 2007 Camry instead of buying a new F150 every 2 years. Live in a small as space as possible. Don't buy designer whatever.

Own your home (if you can). Invest in a diversified passively-invested portfolio. Don't gamble (including crypto). A Vanguard total market fund is fine.

Unfortunately many people make life-changing bad financial decisions when they're the least capable of understanding the implications and that is by taking on massive amounts of student loan debt. You go to your dream school because, well, it's your dream, but your potential career has no way of conceivably paying back that $250k+ for an out-of-state private school. Favor in-state tuition at a state school or whoever will give you a scholarship. You can go further and do 2 years at a community college before transferring to a 4 year program.

Somewhat controversially, I'm also not opposed to people finding the right job in the military for 4 years to pay for tuition. Not something that'll destroy your body or put you in harm's way. Ride a desk for 4 years. Lots of people don't have this option because of common conditions like asthma or ADHD however. In certain branches you might be able to do 2+ years of that college concurrently.

Now society has cooked the housing market and that's a massive problem that's only going to get worse. It wasn't that long ago that you could buy a relatively cheap starter home. You need a fairly serious income for that now.

Oh and if you have children you absolutely need life insurance on yourself and your partner and disability insurance as well.

Subscribe to my newsletter for the low low prices of $500/month.

tehlike•22m ago
Cut expenses, and buy index funds.
ctkhn•14m ago
The average index fund may not even be the best idea anymore - look at how most of the index providers except S&P caved on including an enormous but barely-tested IPO that has now dropped almost 20% since it launched barely 45 days ago.
jamestimmins•24m ago
AI seems to struggle most when it has to make decisions with lots of trade-offs, especially where the context or implications of various decisions are nested, which is presumably why it struggles to write full software systems that are well-designed.

By comparison, financial advice is pretty simple, and there is a universally agreed-upon approach that most people should follow to maximize long-term financial health.

aprilthird2021•13m ago
> By comparison, financial advice is pretty simple, and there is a universally agreed-upon approach that most people should follow to maximize long-term financial health.

What will AI do when those rules, which it's trained on their repetition so much, don't apply anymore? ~8% annual stock gains for the next 40 years may not hold and an 80/20 stock/bond ratio may not be as wise in upcoming decades

toomuchtodo•10m ago
Models can be updated when foundations domain knowledge graphs are built on change. At this time, target date funds and pensions containing trillions of dollars adhere to the assumptions you mention (asset class allocation, growth rate assumptions, returns, safe withdrawal rates ["Trinity study"], etc), and so consumers of AI provided data assuming these foundations could do much worse (as they do today).

You literally just need to stick the Bogleheads forum into Siri (or your device's assistant equivalent) for most folks, if they'll listen.

https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Getting_started

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Index_Card

If you want to get fancy, crib off of California's now mandatory financial literacy curriculum for grounding.

https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/cr/cf/personalfinance.asp

santiagobasulto•16m ago
LLMs are aligned to be cautious. And “good” financial advice is extremely simple. A conservative approach gets you there 80% of the time. Is when people want to get too smart (or they’re bordes) that money is lost (gambling mostly: literally or with bad investments). So yeah, I’d assume AI is good at this.
networkOne•11m ago
Yes, financial planners will be one of the first industries to totally revamp itself because of AI. $2,000 for some SoA which is 99% boiler-plate? No thanks.

I spent years in this industry, and the advice from these 'experts' is demonstrably poor.

ofjcihen•5m ago
What’s the one piece of advice everyone sells but you think should be free?
kmijyiyxfbklao•10m ago
If every human in the world offloaded life decisions to the current AI models, we would live in a better world by the commonly used metrics (less crime, better life expectancy, people doing better financially)
mjr00•8m ago
AI financial advice is surprisingly good... for now. But given the historical trajectory of both the finance and advertising sectors I can't imagine it will, for long. AI responses without ads are unoptimized space!

It only takes Draftkings writing a very large check to Google before it responds to financial questions with solid advice before ending with, "Since you have a few spare hundred dollars laying around, why not try a high-risk investment into same-game parlays?"

Terr_•6m ago
[delayed]
burner420042•4m ago
I use Tiller. They take the transaction history from your linked bank accounts and store it in a google spreadsheet for you. That's it. $99 a year.

From there I unleash claude on my spending habits. I'm only a few months in so I'm more focused on financial hygiene.

AI financial advice is surprisingly good if you ask the right questions

https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/ai-financial-advice-surprisingly-good-especially-if...
50•foxtrot8672•1h ago•33 comments

Diátaxis

https://diataxis.fr/
120•ryanseys•2h ago•18 comments

Seedance 2.5

https://seed.bytedance.com/en/blog/one-take-creation-flexible-referencing-introducing-seedance-2-5
75•njaremko•2h ago•23 comments

Postmortem for Kernel Soundness Bug #14576

https://leodemoura.github.io/blog/2026-8-1-postmortem-for-kernel-soundness-bug-14576/
103•juhopitk•4h ago•36 comments

But can your calculator run Linux?

https://raymii.org/s/articles/But_can_your_calculator_run_Linux.html
47•jandeboevrie•3h ago•3 comments

Unraveling the mysteries of habit formation

https://www.kyoto-u.ac.jp/en/research-news/2026-07-28
6•hhs•31m ago•2 comments

Morph (YC S23) Is Hiring Member of Technical Stuff

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/morph/jobs/0Z8vI3K-member-of-technical-staff
1•bhaktatejas922•34m ago

CISA Alert: Water Sector PLC Targeting

https://censys.com/blog/cisa-alert-water-tower-plc-targeting/
44•speckx•4h ago•31 comments

Just because a game is on disc doesn't mean it will work in the future

https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2026/07/the-disc-is-not-the-game-physical-releases-increasingly-re...
78•rbanffy•1d ago•62 comments

The Art of 64-bit Assembly

https://nostarch.com/art-64-bit-assembly-v2
170•0x54MUR41•9h ago•80 comments

How Google helped destroy adoption of RSS feeds (2023)

https://openrss.org/blog/how-google-helped-destroy-adoption-of-rss-feeds
333•pudgywalsh•5h ago•109 comments

"Everyone Has Been Sold a Lie" on AI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pHcZpvIfho0
19•tcp_handshaker•36m ago•1 comments

NetBSD 11.0

https://blog.netbsd.org/tnf/entry/netbsd_11_0_released
187•jaypatelani•5h ago•81 comments

Beltrunner: Game Design Postmortem

https://blog.gingerbeardman.com/2026/07/30/beltrunner-game-design-postmortem/
7•tobr•1d ago•3 comments

Nyctography: A substituton cypher by Lewis Carroll

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nyctography
39•nanna•4d ago•3 comments

RipGrep musl binaries occasionally segfault during very-large searches

https://github.com/BurntSushi/ripgrep/issues/3494
239•throwaway2037•10h ago•161 comments

Explorative modeling: Train on the best of K guesses

https://alexiglad.github.io/blog/2026/explorative_modeling/
74•DSemba•8h ago•21 comments

Pgtestdb's template cloning approach to testing is fast

https://brandur.org/fragments/pgtestdb
58•brandur•7h ago•36 comments

Glyphs 4 – the leading Mac font editor

https://glyphsapp.com
41•microflash•4d ago•8 comments

Kaisel – Routes as Values. Dart 3 Native Router for Flutter

https://kaisel.dev/
49•TheWiggles•6h ago•7 comments

Linux on ESP32

https://github.com/GrieferPig/esp32-s31-linux
90•boveyking•4d ago•32 comments

A Surveillance Treaty in Disguise: Canada Signs UN Cybercrime Convention

https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2026/07/a-surveillance-treaty-in-disguise-the-trouble-with-canadas-qu...
251•iamnothere•9h ago•136 comments

Kenji/Serious Eats – 30-Min Pressure Cooker Pho Ga

https://www.seriouseats.com/30-minute-pressure-cooker-pho-ga-recipe
68•stasomatic•7h ago•48 comments

RamenHaus

https://ramen.haus/
215•oler•14h ago•105 comments

Cursor removed cost information from the usage page and CSV export

https://forum.cursor.com/t/usage-page-to-token-amount-what/167153
290•EugeneOZ•8h ago•125 comments

The Burau representation of the braid group is faithful for n = 4

https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.05283
39•wglb•4d ago•18 comments

Register deprivation: spills and runtime under forced register scarcity

https://rjp.io/blog/2026-07-19-register-deprivation
23•surprisetalk•2d ago•4 comments

Flint: A Visualization Language for the AI Era

https://microsoft.github.io/flint-chart/
246•vinhnx•20h ago•66 comments

Anime User Interfaces

https://animeuserinterface.tumblr.com
7•akyuu•39m ago•0 comments

Manual: •.,:;…!?·

https://type.today/en/journal/dots
108•behnamoh•2d ago•25 comments