frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Who owns the code?

https://whoownsthecode.com/
19•dgellow•1h ago

Comments

leothetechguy•25m ago
Personally I don't even want to own my code. If it is useful to others I want them to have the same rights I have to it.

Or should I say, In the case of AI, "my" code :)

avaer•20m ago
Hypothetical but serious question on your stance: if someone takes "your" code, claims authorship, sells access, and becomes a billionaire from it while you get accused of plagiarizing "their" code and can't get a job coding, are you still cool with it?
DarmokJalad1701•16m ago
> takes "your" code, claims authorship, sells access, and becomes a billionaire

yes. It is open source. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WTFPL

avaer•13m ago
I'm not arguing against open source, I'm just trying to point out the downstream effects of an absolutist stance on it.
Retr0id•14m ago
Being accused of plagiarism seems orthogonal. Even if I assert IP ownership of my code, someone else can falsely claim it as theirs. They are wrong in both cases and in both cases it'd have to be settled in court.
avaer•6m ago
If nobody owns the code and everyone has the same rights to it (per the parent) the person copying the code would have the same right to claim they wrote it. And there are definitely people who will do this when there is money and reputation to be gained. It happens all the time even with the IP protections we have.

My point is that the blast radius of losing those protections goes beyond open source.

dvt•16m ago
Intellectual property does not necessarily have to be copyrightable but, as always, nuanced discussion will get lost in clickbaity headlines.
righthand•15m ago
Well gee golly is it a tool for the author or not? When’s it’s in their favor of 10000x performance increase or some kind of notoriety it’s “I built this!” when it’s time for responsibility it’s “the machine did this”.
wild_egg•13m ago
I'm sure we are going to have to wait for some actual court cases to establish precedent but I don't really see why this is the case.

If I use a fancy brush in Photoshop to paint flowers into a PNG — do I own the resulting image? Code is bytes of text on disk, not much different from bytes of pixel data in a BMP.

If I have to type every character by hand in order to own the bytes, then it would stand that I would have to input every pixel by hand in Paint to own a graphic. No? Even using the Fill tool is automating the creation of those bytes and would mean I don't own them. Right?

I have an intention for some bytes of data to be set. If I use an LLM to set them instead of my own fingers, why are the bytes suddenly not mine?

I do not understand.

dgellow•9m ago
> Code is bytes of text on disk

Not at all, code is the implementation of an idea. The support/encoding is irrelevant. A human creation is protected by copyright. In the case of prompting an LLM, the human creation is the prompt, the LLM does author the implementation. But it’s not known what happens to the ownership of the LLM generated code

cbarnes99•4m ago
You clearly didn't actually look at the link and are just responding to the title. There's Supreme Court precedent. It doesn't get any clearer than that.
Retr0id•12m ago
// © 2026 whoownsthecode.com. All rights reserved.

Ironic.

SwellJoe•9m ago
In what way? If it's written by a human, as is still a thing someone can do, it can be copyrighted.
Retr0id•6m ago
The web design and layout is typical of Claude, and Claude is listed as a contributor to the project on GitHub: https://github.com/rhundhausen/whoownsthecode

The non-decorative body text seems human enough, though.

bethekidyouwant•10m ago
Owning digital things is dumb at best you restrict access to them
mapontosevenths•9m ago
How long do you think Microsoft, Apple and the other mega-corps will continue to put up with this? All of them have AI code in all of their products.

The law will change. Probably soon.

protocolture•8m ago
AI = No author is so bloody reductionist.

The copyright ruling was about prompting without modification. The second you modify the result significantly by hand, the ruling doesn't apply. It also had a huge carve out for any future LLM that was more deterministic, which might apply to people with huge skill and other md files to tram in AI. It just hasnt been tested.

These armchair copyright lawyers need to launch a lawsuit and stick their money where their mouth is instead of creating dumb clickbait nonsense.

dingaling911•7m ago
And if I use an effect in photoshop, do I own the resulting image?
peesem•5m ago
come on. people are doing a lot more than that with LLMs
tiahura•6m ago
IIRC, no Federal Circuit has ruled on this.

Currently pending is Doe v. GitHub, Inc., No. 24-7700 (9th Cir.). https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69495342/doe-et-al-v-gi... Oral arg: https://storage.courtlistener.com/mp3/2026/02/11/doe_v._gith...

zephen•3m ago
Who owns the code if you built it with AI?

Someone else!

All they have to do is show it's close enough to code that was swallowed during training.

Songwriters have been successfully sued for many decades for creating songs that are too close to songs that they probably heard.

Once this line of reasoning gets applied to code, all hell will break loose.

GLM-5.3 Artificial Analysis Benchmarks

https://artificialanalysis.ai/models/glm-5-3
37•apitman•1h ago•10 comments

A 3D fruit fly on macOS desktop powered by the real FlyWire connectome

https://github.com/DenisSergeevitch/desktop-fly
48•phoenix120•1h ago•9 comments

Being ambitious and being a dad

https://nicholascharriere.com/blog/being-ambitious-and-being-a-dad/
140•nichochar•2d ago•60 comments

Who owns the code?

https://whoownsthecode.com/
23•dgellow•1h ago•28 comments

The Amazon tax

https://seths.blog/2026/08/the-amazon-tax/
823•herbertl•9h ago•505 comments

fx :Tiny, open, native coding agent.

https://fx.sh
35•handfuloflight•1h ago•18 comments

How does IKEA come up with names for its products?

https://www.ikea.com/se/en/customer-service/knowledge/articles/6f564c4d-2ccc-46de-b643-545a3948dc...
192•NaOH•5h ago•124 comments

Claude Code Teaching macOS to Natively Print to the HP Laser 1008a

https://cdn.kuber.studio/chat/hp-laser-1008a-driver
84•amrrs•2h ago•54 comments

Turbovec – Google's TurboQuant for vector search in Rust

https://github.com/RyanCodrai/turbovec
187•fittingopposite•5h ago•23 comments

Companies promote incompetent employees to management to limit damage they do

https://lawsofsoftwareengineering.com/laws/dilbert-principle/
48•behnamoh•2h ago•46 comments

Beware Management Consultants

https://about.iceland.co.uk/our-story/the-dark-ages/beware-management-consultants/
408•KolmogorovComp•3h ago•101 comments

Using the railway network as a flatbed scanner

https://philo.gay/linecam/
375•otherayden•10h ago•57 comments

Fixing a bricked Framework laptop

https://quantum5.ca/2026/08/16/fixing-bricked-amd-7040-series-framework-13-laptop-with-20-tools/
333•jp_sc•10h ago•224 comments

Cursor launches Origin, GitHub alternative

https://cursor.com/changelog/origin-code-hosting
421•tomasreimers•1d ago•332 comments

The Microsoft Rebrand Registry

https://www.msrebrandregistry.com/analysis.html
5•jnord•47m ago•1 comments

Linux 7.3 improves performance when running out of vRAM

https://pixelcluster.dev/VRAM-Overcommit/
493•flaburgan•15h ago•258 comments

Memory prices climb 500% in 12 months

https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/ram/memory-prices-climb-500-percent-in-12-months-up-to...
422•haunter•1d ago•345 comments

And then the men with guns tell you to do it anyway

https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2026/08/and-then-the-men-with-guns-tell-you-to-do-it-anyway/
104•_djo_•6h ago•52 comments

2,500-year-old sculpture discovered at UNESCO site in Turkey

https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2026/08/07/colossal-2500-year-old-sculpture-discovered-turkey-une...
59•speckx•5d ago•22 comments

Norway should buy OpenAI

https://www.onethousandmeans.com/p/norway-should-buy-openai
187•alexeigannon•3h ago•210 comments

A 25-year-old video patent just expired, ending a legal headache for Linux

https://www.xda-developers.com/25-year-old-brazilian-video-patent-expired-legal-headache-linux/
47•theanonymousone•3d ago•12 comments

Pacing model development in an era of cyber-critical capabilities

https://openai.com/index/pacing-model-development-cyber-capabilities/
59•j4mie•5h ago•33 comments

Claude Code May–August 2026 weekly limits promotion

https://support.claude.com/en/articles/15910845-claude-code-may-august-2026-weekly-limits-promotion
246•tyre•6h ago•212 comments

Evolve: An incremental game about evolving a civilization

https://pmotschmann.github.io/Evolve/
64•frozenseven•3d ago•22 comments

Python Polars Cheatsheet (based on our O'Reilly book)

https://opensource.posit.co/resources/cheatsheets/polars/
154•jeroenjanssens•9h ago•32 comments

Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers

https://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/sustainablebuildings/article/7/2/024501/1233035/Data-Cente...
278•cwwc•5h ago•406 comments

Launch HN: machine0 (YC S26) – Persistent CPU and GPU VMs from the CLI

https://machine0.io
54•bwm•6h ago•34 comments

Terry A. Davis Quotes

https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Terry_A._Davis
7•LAC-Tech•46m ago•0 comments

Apple announces changes for apps in the European Union

https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2026/08/apple-announces-changes-for-apps-in-the-european-union/
87•newusertoday•7h ago•144 comments

Mycorrhizal Infrastructure Map

https://a-hidden-infrastructure.spun.earth/map
31•num42•3d ago•7 comments