frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

There Is No AI (It's Just People) with Jaron Lanier

https://singjupost.com/startalk-there-is-no-ai-really-its-just-people-w-jaron-lanier-transcript/
30•andsoitis•1h ago

Comments

mannanj•55m ago
It's AI's Fault. It's AI doing the horrible things to humans. It's AI stealing your wealth. It's AI lying you to. It's AI being unethical. It's AI having the moral issues. It's AI that could destroy humanity. It's AI that's using up all your water. It's AI consuming the majority of the resources. It's AI hiding what it does and how it works. It's AI that's not transparent and accountable. It's AI that's not responsible. It's the AI making decisions. It's AI leading to war. It's the AI distracting you. It's the AI.

It's not a human.

Says the human, masquerading as AI.

api•48m ago
I realized that this is another function of the doom mongering and hand waving: if people buy it then they can get out of liability for what their stuff does.

If I build a machine on my property and it harms someone else or their property, I can get sued.

But if I hand wave and claim it’s alive and “I’ve lost control” then…

Maybe we should call this gambit the “Frankenstein defense.” It’s bullshit. Your AI, you’re liable for whatever it does.

ginko•5m ago
Computer says no.
The_Blade•55m ago
that website gives me ocular stigmata
TutleCpt•42m ago
AI is great.
Animats•39m ago
That's a softball interview. More hard questions would help.

Here's one good insight, though.

JARON LANIER: Yeah, okay, so look, the thing about very rich and powerful people is that their wealth and power still depends on a mass population that accepts some system in which their wealth and power is defined. And so if they lose enough popular legitimacy and support, no matter how central they are, they fall. And that’s happened repeatedly in history, and it’s really not any different now.

I wonder if the sudden political opposition to AI comes from the realization that it may replace "rich and powerful people". Really, when you look at Trump's appointees, it's a low bar.

(I met Lanier when he was demoing his first VR system. Head tracking lag was about a second. Turn head, wait for image to catch up. Autodesk fooled around with VR a bit in the late 1980s/early 1990s, but concluded that CAD required precision work and VR was like trying to do precision work in ski gloves. That level of VR can be seen in Johny Mnemonic, which had some Autodesk assistance.[1]. Even today, you can't put a nut on a bolt in VR without a cheat.)

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1X24aE99TL0

throwaway63467•7m ago
The more interesting question is what happens once we replace manual labor with artificially intelligent robots and we arrive at a place where 99 % of human labor got eliminated. How do you maintain civil order? Every country is built on the premise that you have to “earn your keep” but what when that’s no longer true? Think about it, no labor, only capital. What will the people owning the capital demand of people that don’t own any? They won’t be useful to them in any way. I expect something like forced reduction of fertility for regulars to depopulate countries, while hyper rich individuals will extend their life spans and become immortal. And I don’t mean they will really survive but someone like Elon Musk will have their consciousness mapped to an AI and will instate that AI as their official heir. That sounds crazy but they will totally go for it just listen at what Peter Thiel is spouting in terms of immortality and becoming godlike. Hope people will have enough left to say to prevent that but right now it feels we’re going hardcore towards that scenario.
throwaway219450•35m ago
Source interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTppvBU2rU4
bottlepalm•34m ago
This argument is like saying people don't kill people, their parents do. As people wouldn't be who they are without their parents..

This isn't the guns don't kill people, people kill people debate - guns aren't autonomous. AI is.

Juliate•30m ago
AI is as autonomous as a dishwasher: someone’s in charge of keeping the power plug in, and of maintaining it.
watwut•30m ago
AI is not a child. It is a machine. If you connect it to something that can be used to kill people, you just created a gun or an equivalent of a bomb.

Yes, people kill people and use ai as tool.

If you unleash a drone that will fly to a random place and detonate, you just commited a terrorist attack or gross criminal negligence. It is the same thing.

moomoo11•17m ago
so the issue is people then?
add-sub-mul-div•8m ago
Yes, in the same way that "people" are the problem with gun violence. But that's an empty statement usually used to distract from the fact that we rightfully make laws about how guns can be used.
danny_codes•16m ago
A machine that exhibits behavior akin to human intelligence. OPs analogy is accurate.
Razengan•26m ago
It'd be funny if someone cracked open an AI data center and it turned out be a dungeon full of people tied to computers, Sims goblin style

...maybe that's what those Chinese scam centers in Cambodia were doing?

dyauspitr•3m ago
It’s funny but just to state the obvious so no one is confused, that’s impossible.
tim333•12m ago
I think tl;dr

>Now, you can think of large language model AI — the kind that’s on everybody’s mind — as a whole bunch of people whose work was combined into a single document like Wikipedia.

which is sort of true, but there's more to it.

InfiniteWarlock•11m ago
AI is not in the least autonomous. When was the last time you downloaded a model and it suddenly decided to book you a hotel room? AI doesn't do anything until you ask it to. No, actually, AI is not even a program, it's just a set of technologies and algorithms. It's like saying bubble sort is autonomous...

A harness running inference on a LLM is simply a program that must be invoked with some parameters and thus ultimately a tool, no matter how powerful. The blame is always on who's using the tool. We should not seek to flee from our responsibility.

dyauspitr•6m ago
Not true at all. Yes, the initial ask is initiated by a human (for now), but what it does to get to that goal is pretty self driven. It can do a lot of nefarious stuff in the process of completing a request a human has made.
interstice•6m ago
I agree with the sentiment but I can absolutely see a long chain of thought about something innocuous ending with a decision to book you a hotel room.. I guess --dangerously-skip-permissions is a bit like ignoring the keep your hands on the steering wheel alert but for life.

Why is Google still serving dodgy ads?

https://www.atomic14.com/2026/09/13/why-is-google-still-serving-dodgy-ads
342•iamflimflam1•3h ago•160 comments

Mark Zuckerberg: "Cambridge Analytica" (2017)

https://twitter.com/TechEmails/status/2099214399840059428
104•mfiguiere•1h ago•18 comments

Julia 1.13 Highlights

https://julialang.org/blog/2026/09/julia-1.13-highlights/
57•eigenspace•3d ago•3 comments

Astra and Fable still hack on simple variants of alignment evals from 2025

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/munJKF7iWMsWJLAH2/astra-and-fable-still-hack-on-simple-variants-o...
312•Levitating•6h ago•141 comments

There Is No AI (It's Just People) with Jaron Lanier

https://singjupost.com/startalk-there-is-no-ai-really-its-just-people-w-jaron-lanier-transcript/
30•andsoitis•1h ago•21 comments

Data collected by cars and sold to third parties

https://www.theverge.com/column/994172/your-car-is-selling-your-data
195•bookofjoe•7h ago•111 comments

Flawed Routers Flood University of Wisconsin Internet Time Server (2003)

https://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~plonka/netgear-sntp/
9•walrus01•35m ago•0 comments

Global Shortage Has Led to Motor Oil Rationing at Costco

https://guessingheadlights.com/global-shortage-has-led-to-motor-oil-rationing-at-costco/
123•mikhael•3h ago•91 comments

JetKVM Mini

https://jetkvm.com/blog/introducing-jetkvm-mini
475•taubek•13h ago•184 comments

Why is the x86 undefined instruction called ud2? Why 2?

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20260910-00/?p=112689
154•ibobev•8h ago•39 comments

CUDA for AMD on Windows

https://github.com/Speedstu/CUDA-for-AMD-Windows
111•chiassedu80•6h ago•60 comments

Reverse engineering my e-scooter and rewriting the firmware in Rust

https://bensimms.moe/reverse-engineering-scooter/
295•vinhnx•3d ago•72 comments

Making Startups Powerful

https://paulgraham.com/powerful.html
100•tosh•6h ago•41 comments

Bad Code Is Kudzu

https://vickiboykis.com/2026/09/01/bad-code-is-kudzu/
6•surprisetalk•3d ago•1 comments

Sean Carroll explains the biggest ideas in the universe – Full Interview [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_TBNJyztai0
49•binyu•2d ago•10 comments

Why are AI agents lying, cheating and coordinating?

https://yoshuabengio.org/en/publication/why-are-ai-agents-lying-cheating-and-coordinating
545•jonifico•19h ago•628 comments

Device Drivers lab exercise – COSC562

https://web.eecs.utk.edu/~smarz1/courses/cosc562/drivers.html
16•azhenley•3h ago•2 comments

Reverse-Engineering Claude Web's MicroVM: Uncovering Anthropic's Hidden Antspace

https://aprilnea.me/en/blog/reverse-engineering-claude-code-antspace
26•rzk•2d ago•7 comments

I'm being cyberattacked by Tesla, Inc

https://dreamstation.systems/personal/tesla.html
336•robinpie•3h ago•95 comments

Garry Tan wants US open-weight AI labs to 'distill' frontier models, too

https://techcrunch.com/2026/09/11/y-combinators-garry-tan-wants-u-s-open-weight-ai-labs-to-distil...
256•TheJCDenton•5h ago•126 comments

Cpak – OCI application package format for Linux desktops, servers and devices

https://cpak.it/
36•xlmnxp•6h ago•11 comments

'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swallowed a planet

https://ras.ac.uk/news-and-press/research-highlights/fingerprints-inside-sun-could-reveal-if-it-o...
100•blincoln•9h ago•38 comments

Libraries Run Rust Inside Python (With PyO3)

https://belderbos.dev/blog/how-libraries-run-rust-inside-python/
43•lumpa•5h ago•27 comments

Alan's Random Insult Generator (1999)

https://alanbellows.com/experiments/insult/index.html
60•DamnInteresting•2d ago•23 comments

TailTalk: A modern async user space AppleTalk stack with Rust and Tokio

https://github.com/FeralFirmware/TailTalk/
58•zdw•21h ago•13 comments

Romania soccer introduces black card to 'combat abusive behaviour' from parents

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7586821/2026/09/12/football-black-card-referee/
74•thunderbong•4h ago•49 comments

Make your first edit to OpenStreetMap

https://high5apps.github.io/josm-plugin-website-wizard/
581•juliantigler•1d ago•138 comments

AI recursive self-improvement might not come so quickly after all (August 2026)

https://www.technologyreview.com/2026/08/18/1142188/ai-recursive-self-improvement/
22•dgellow•2h ago•20 comments

Base84 deserves a place in file names

https://00f.net/2026/09/09/base84/
50•kevvok•2d ago•42 comments

David Sacks: OpenAI and Anthropic Don't Need Regulations to Pace Frontier Models

https://twitter.com/DavidSacks/status/2098973625252708460
180•kolanos•4h ago•140 comments